Mafiascum.net

@math why did you claim ascetic btw?

Also @bob do you have any more like general gamestate reads?

In post 638, Menalque wrote:

In post 572, Tayl0r Swift wrote:the first post was me mocking the quoted post. i was pointing out the lack of actual content in it. the second post is not complaining that the game is active, but complaining that people are being very overconfident. its 24 hours in, we are still very much feeling each other out. i fully anticipate taking a bit longer to do that than the rest of you need, but even for people who are quick to develop reads, that was a bit premature. some people had posted fewer than 5 times.

Okay this kinda makes sense on the first point, I can see how that reads as a joke

But like where were people being overconfident in the second case? Like are you saying that early reads = inherent overconfidence or something else that I’m missing?

people were literally giving solves and i think not just for ego reasons in postgame. and people were talking like they had the game solved. its whatever. people are making a much bigger deal out of that post than was meant by it.

In post 648, PlusJOYED wrote:I don't wanna repeat myself to saudade and menalque, I posted my thoughts on IV/taylor fast before in my readlist and I've been sus on them both for very early

Okay only I’m not asking so much about your specific reads rn I’m trying to understand what your process is to decide if you like, actually have one or not

In post 651, Tayl0r Swift wrote:people were literally giving solves and i think not just for ego reasons in postgame. and people were talking like they had the game solved.

do u remember who? and like do you have a take on that either way? +scum/+town ?

In post 653, Menalque wrote:

In post 651, Tayl0r Swift wrote:people were literally giving solves and i think not just for ego reasons in postgame. and people were talking like they had the game solved.

do u remember who? and like do you have a take on that either way? +scum/+town ?

it was shellyc who dropped a 3 scum game solve lmao
I commented on that too

PlusJoyed why do I feel that its so hard to communicate with you into working together as a team to solve the game

Yeah, but she’s since clarified that wasn’t meant as like a solve which is why I’m curious as to hear more on what Taylor’s reaction to it was

In post 652, Menalque wrote:

In post 648, PlusJOYED wrote:I don't wanna repeat myself to saudade and menalque, I posted my thoughts on IV/taylor fast before in my readlist and I've been sus on them both for very early

Okay only I’m not asking so much about your specific reads rn I’m trying to understand what your process is to decide if you like, actually have one or not

The answer is yes and I've posted it before
I'll post it again with more in depth stuff / reevaluate when I get off work

Okay, I can wait, ty

Saudade were you saying that you thought teacher was scummy bc that’s not a read I’m getting at all

saudade please don’t yell at me i’m fragile and you’ve shattered my self confidence so the answer is no

In post 659, Menalque wrote:Saudade were you saying that you thought teacher was scummy bc that’s not a read I’m getting at all

Yeah, he's being reactionary rather than proactionary which is explained by his lack of time to attend the game.
I didnt quite like it, pressured him into posting more.

I'm waiting for more from him but so far he's not looking good.
Kerset is worse though because he's been here more than teacher and haven't been solving anything.

In post 660, Ydrasse wrote:saudade please don’t yell at me i’m fragile and you’ve shattered my self confidence so the answer is no

What's your win rate as scum

how did I shatter your self confidence...
dont meme at me @__@

In post 659, Menalque wrote:Saudade were you saying that you thought teacher was scummy bc that’s not a read I’m getting at all

Are you getting the read now?

loud words on screen hurt me

1 win 1 loss so far i think

....

It's not often that I remain speechless, congratulations

In post 666, Ydrasse wrote:loud words on screen hurt me

1 win 1 loss so far i think

What's your read on me?

In post 614, Menalque wrote:@andres are you gonna be around more at the weekend?

Most likely so. Honestly during the week I try to keep up but some days I’ll have really busy days at work and can’t read at all. So that doesn’t help. But when things really do heat up I will almost try and make myself available regardless of work (and maybe even at random hours).

In post 617, Menalque wrote:Actually wait, another thing @andres, why do you like osuka so far? I feel like he has p good scum equity at this point in the game as someone not like trying that hard to solve but definitely trying to give of the impression of solving, and I kind of think hard pushing one person in particular is often indicative of that sort of fake scumhunting

If osuka had highlighted something silly about Kerset, then maybe I would agree with this. But osuka’s points seemed perfectly legitimate to me. It did almost seem like Kerset was avoiding commenting on what was going on, and kept deflecting in the face of pressure. And osuka had some of the same reactions I had about shellyc’s posts but expressed them in a way that is more sarcastic and unfriendly that I would have done. However, I fully expect to see some decent takes from osuka, and until I find myself disagreeing or feeling like I’m being led in the wrong direction, I’m not going to SR it.

i shall take this victory w pride

probably town based on the kerset push + general vibe. i’m on mobile so if you need more on that you’re gonna have 2 wait

I think my view of Saudade is somewhat similar. Except Saudade is far more active and has more of a thread presence, which makes me think they’re even more likely to be Town. And yeah, I’m one of those people that think that Scum like to avoid making mistakes or putting themselves in bad spots by posting less. Except when it’s all convoluted or involves a lot of attacking a few specific players which is much easier to hide behind despite posting a lot of content.

Also, I do have a hard claim I should make early - I’m a Miller.