TemporalLich's Grand Idea [Game Over]

[Rebel Radio]

ok i didnt word it well , you are attaching to technicalities.

it is that i did not think have anything scummy in their limited post to be confident enough to scumread while hayker's actiosn more line up to a scum meta i have seen in a game i was in with them recently -koba

I'm trying to get more out of you other than "Hayker is scummy because he's scummy and Vax is townie because he's townie".

What game are you referencing? What are the similarities to his scum game? Do you have a town game to act as a baseline as well?

A recent large game - they were actually both scum together. https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=85512
-koba

[Rebel Radio]

hayker also had a very low post count that game
-koba

[Disney Princesses]

hayker also had a very low post count that game
-koba

Hayker seems to have a low post count in every game he plays. Are you sure that's indicative of his alignment?

[Rebel Radio]

can you link a town game?
-koba

[Disney Princesses]

Otherwise, I'm sitting here, as my role requires people to be dead to do anything.

And this is not the right mindset to have.

Presumably, your role requires all threats to the town to be dead, which you can't get by nightplay alone. You're also playing a game with a high concentration of scum (1 in every 3, with a high likelihood that 2 townies are dying every night), meaning that it's important that townies find each other early and that we make smart lynches early.

So maybe you feel overwhelmed and like you don't have a lot to contribute, but the beauty of this game is that you don't need to be right, you just need to

try

; the more vocal you are, the more other players can see where you're coming from and the higher the chance that you pick up on something that others missed, but if you just sit on your laurels all game because you're waiting to use your role then you'll just be mislynched or roleblocked by scum.

[Disney Princesses]

can you link a town game?
-koba

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

Mind you this game is from 2011, he ended up replacing out, and he's rolled scum seven times in a row between this game and the one I'm linking you, but it just seems fairly obvious this guy doesn't post a whole lot.

[Disney Princesses]

And from a quick skim of Cook's other games he's very capable of posting as either alignment so I'm expecting a lot more from him next time I pop into thread.

[Toogeloo]

I want to vote one of Hayker, Guillotina, Bell, Magnus, Raya, or NDMath.

Someone tell me who.

[Disney Princesses]

Bell is the best out of that group but your reads seem kinda kattywhompus to me.

[Toogeloo]

VOTE: Bell

The game is kattywhampus. My reads are my own.

[Rebel Radio]

VOTE: Bell

The game is kattywhampus. My reads are my own.

and what are your reads?

[Hayker]

can you link a town game?
-koba

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=12809


Here you go.

[Magnus V]

It feels like scum!Koba to me too mainly because they aren't making much sense and I know town!Koba makes sense. But 560 felt very genuine and like they want to solve the game. Not that scum!Koba can't make that post though.

This reads off and fence-sitty. Get down from there before you fall off, Raya, come sit on a high horse like the rest of us normal people.

[Magnus V]

I appreciate the deep pocket, Disney Princesses, and will readily climb in and make myself cozy

Now that we've successfully pocketed you if you could also sheep us in destroying Vaxkiller that would be SWELL.

While I'm not the biggest fan of Rebel's posting thus fa

r I think that the Vax entrance was both bad and substantial enough to give me confidence that it's an alignment-indicative type of bad.

Hmm

That said, I'll join the campaign against Vax. Players should really think twice before they obvscum.

Spiffey still hasn't joined our cult

very susp

We are very very town.

I don't understand your vote on Rebel.

I don't understand why you're not joining hands with us to crush scum currently; we will not be long for this world and so it only makes sense for us to unite on this, if only for a day.

[Rebel Radio]

magnus, whats ur feel about my personal reads list and how i sorted the blocks?
-koba

[Magnus V]

I dont really think "this is multiball" is something scum says be abuse they're on a small team. I also think raya is scum, so I dont care about them being voted. But sure, who cares?

VOTE: vax

So terrible it's towny (this post)

[Magnus V]

magnus, whats ur feel about my personal reads list and how i sorted the blocks?
-koba

It's quite decent save for some placements. Unsure why you're confident about Nono/Korina particularly.

[Magnus V]

magnus, whats ur feel about my personal reads list and how i sorted the blocks?
-koba

It's quite decent save for some placements. Unsure why you're confident about Nono/Korina particularly.

[Magnus V]

Hayker actually feels a tiny bit different to that large game ISO you linked, Rebel. More empty questioning there.

VOTE: Vaxkiller

[Raya36]

o7 okay Raya wrong place at the right time for me.

explain yourself because I don't really believe you but I want you as my new partner

I assume you're referring to thinking Koba could be scum?

They feel way off tonally for one and they're also typically someone who plays quite aggressively but also generally well thought out.

Implying it's within Pooky's scum-meta to claim a confirmable tpr makes no sense and when asked about it responding with "k whatever" doesn't tonally sound like town!Koba. Saying that the confirmable tpr claim won't amount to anything also makes absolutely 0 sense coming from Koba who was just a few pages ago pushing for a mass claim to sort people. Someone with the mindset of solving based off of claims shouldn't be brushing off a claim and saying it won't amount to anything. Also posts like 462 feels so off. They say it like Pooky is trying to hide "being cult" but their behavior is so obvious cult-like. But what really happened is Pooky essentially states that he is cult and Koba is like wow Pooky is so bad at this, it's so obvious they're cult.

Samantha also claimed to be a confirmable tpr in their first post and was not long after called not town by the rebel radio hydra. Again, makes no sense from someone who is supposed to be claim/mech oriented.

[Magnus V]

Okay, Raya back to town for that post. Or at least scum who has a genuine scumread on Rebel. Agreeing with the thoughts there.

[Raya36]

It feels like scum!Koba to me too mainly because they aren't making much sense and I know town!Koba makes sense. But 560 felt very genuine and like they want to solve the game. Not that scum!Koba can't make that post though.

what?

i never make sense

get outta here.

but maybe u are town for this observation bc u were scum twice against me so maybe now without being informed u think i dont make sense lol
-koba

I mean maybe but I'm really struggling to see your thought process and make any sense of it looking at your pov as if you were town.

[Raya36]

If I had to dabble in meta I would say that you're more reliant on the game reacting to

your

content but it seems to be the complete opposite right now.

Actually this might be part of what was raising red flags tonally for me

[Magnus V]

Raya, they make me work 70 hour weeks at the cult and I don't get paid for overtime. It's a really sweet gig and I think you should look into submitting your application to join.

[Raya36]

This is multiballs BTW

VOTE: raya

So general pieces on his entry is that it was bland as hell - there's nothing he did to stick his neck out at all, nothing mildly controversial. Next, I'm squicked out by the multiball declaration. Like, hell yeah, fairly obvious that it's multiball based on 7 scum, but Vax is the type of player that would miss the mod declaration at the beginning, but would know that it was multiball because he was sitting on a smaller scumteam. Finally, I don't like the Raya vote here - Raya wagon was a larger one and he just kind of slides on without giving any reason why - I kind of get why you and samantha and whoever else voted Raya but I don't see why Vax would make that vote.

I was kinda lost on the vax push up until now since he barely posted anything and just looked like an inactive player push but this makes sense and I'm kind of agreeing.