Everything he wrote is exactly what I thought in real time.
Do you think that makes them more likely to be town?
Yes, because I know I am town.
(Sidenote: I "fixed" the quotes)
Do you think people who ride a different train of thought from you could be town?
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 10:44 am
by Titus
In post 645, Roden wrote:And did anybody else see the Cop fishing?
Where?
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 1:02 pm
by Roden
Titus wrote:
In post 645, Roden wrote:And did anybody else see the Cop fishing?
Where?
In post 637, KidAmn wrote:Roden's posting on P9 re: still trying to push "DGB as traitor" and then creating associatives that are backwards at best is real off for me. Only redeeming feature is that presumably scum!Rodan is smart enough to understand they're not going to get chain MLs if the first link in the chain fails, and wouldn't actually go through with yeeting DGB if they're the
droids
traitor they're looking for. Christ, now you've even got me talking about traitors. Stop traitor speccing, just hunt scum FFS. End of P9 Roden going REAL hard on this traitor bullshit. Real solid scumvibes. Gonna be awkward if I get to page 18 and they out themselves as a cop or something.
Trying to see if I'll claim Macho Cop to save myself here after going hard at me for "looking scummy". Doing this right after complaining about speculation (in a game that had literally nothing going on in it) doesn't sit right.
I was town leaning Bug so it's weird that I'm getting completely opposite vibes from they're replace in.
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 1:09 pm
by Roden
Like why complain about tunneling and speculation then do exactly that? And again,
literally nothing was going on in the game when the Traitor speculation happened.
There wasn't much to work with at the time and it was the only vaguely interesting thing to even discuss. I'm pretty sure I just shut up and don't bother trying to out a Traitor if I'm actually scum. I don't see why KA seems to be ignoring that I said this earlier too, or why he isn't questioning why his slot and I shared scum reads at the time.
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 1:32 pm
by Rannygazoo
I really don’t see what any of that has to do with a cop.
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 1:37 pm
by Jake The Wolfie
In post 654, Rannygazoo wrote:I really don’t see what any of that has to do with a cop.
+1
They mentioned how it wouldn't sit right if you claimed to be the cop, not that you should claim to be the cop now to save your ass.
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 3:19 pm
by Umlaut
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 3:25 pm
by Jake The Wolfie
Heads up to all you players who are playing Mini Normal 2215: Deco, I changed my Avatar. Thought I should mention it, in case you get confused about it.
In post 627, geraintm wrote:not much to say until everyone of interest says what happened....
Who is of interest?
CW
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 8:10 pm
by T3
In post 645, Roden wrote:KA's analysis sounds like it was ripped straight from a "how to trick people into thinking you're town" guide. There's very little actual content in it and DGB liking it sounds even worse.
Also don't like that he thinks the Traitor thing is a waste of time but then wants to bring back the Miller policy elim shit. The Traitor thing only even came up because DGB went ful anti-town over a Miller claim, yet KA doesn't even comment on that at all.
And did anybody else see the Cop fishing?
I am bad at this game *thinking*
Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2021 8:12 pm
by T3
Roden is town I think either way here.
Posted: Thu Jun 17, 2021 12:24 am
by VFP
So I like T3, Jake, and cw as town.
DGB and Titus town lean too.
I'm trying to work out Gera here, and if their new style either align is this or not.
I just don't see the gain as scum Gera though.
In post 454, T3 wrote:VOTE: DGB
Cadtsting doubt on the ce claim for no reason.
VOTE: T3
There's no real scum motivation for shading an outed doctor claim, while honestly assessing his content. If DGB is believable that she might vote cw at some point, then it could keep a doctor alive. If she's right, she undermines scum credibility.
If DGB is scum, why shade a town cw with a short shelf life? They could just kill it and no one is the wiser. If it's scum, why attack her teammates credibility which only shortens the lifespan?
You could argue wifom but attacking an outed doctor claim rarely comes from scum.
In post 515, T3 wrote:Tr on jessica for now, her points about cw I agree with. Titus fails to mention that there is no town motivation behind dgb still not believing cw so I think I'll keep my vote there.
I got my second shot yesterday and as a result of it my JIA is acting up again so I'm just stuck on the couch feeling like shit on the first day of sumer break
I literally just mentioned the town motivation. There's no way you're this dense.
In post 582, Titus wrote:I still feel like T3 is the best vote here. Nothing about these subs changes my mind.
