Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[NanceFloor]

you actually don't have to convince me rlly

I'm on board w the current plan and I'm always gonna let Nance have the final decision on our vote tbh

- dann

[Nancy Drew 39]

You want to kill TD today? Sure. But Moongrass shouldn't be alive for this long

yeah let's powerlynch Moongrass.

VOTE: Lynch

idk if we should call oka or PB (succinct is too early) yet

-TL

VOTE: lynch

moongrass needs to be sorted asap

Who is Moon’s partner and why didn’t scum!Moon kill me?

[NanceFloor]

You want to kill TD today? Sure. But Moongrass shouldn't be alive for this long

yeah let's powerlynch Moongrass.

VOTE: Lynch

idk if we should call oka or PB (succinct is too early) yet

-TL

VOTE: lynch

moongrass needs to be sorted asap

Who is Moon’s partner and why didn’t scum!Moon kill me?

[chennisden]

I trust your PoEs and if Moon is scum I can see TD scum

Scum moon didn't kill you to get rid of the conf town; the conf town kill gives least info

[RadiantCowbells]

I really don't see why you think anyone would have killed you over succinct

[NanceFloor]

I really don't see why you think anyone would have killed you over succinct

Why wouldn’t you? If my reads have been correct, aren’t I more of a threat to scum than a player, IC or not - who doesn’t even know what’s going on in the game?

I would think atp in the game, with the ratio of town-scum - the IC would not be the biggest of scum°’s worries. Obviously you disagree?

[NanceFloor]

I trust your PoEs and if Moon is scum I can see TD scum

Scum moon didn't kill you to get rid of the conf town; the conf town kill gives least info

So tell me then how you think they’re alligned. I thought after TD made the comment about a town double flip making Moon scum, he would now say that Creature scum = Moon town but obviously that wasn’t the case.

I don’t know, maybe RC is right and I’m just overthinking this?

But TD wanted the protect to be on me, specifically. Only one who wanted to reveal me was Moon but that was pre-Creature flip.

My head is hurting. :/

[RadiantCowbells]

I think TD wanted you protected so that I would be open

Nancy scum aren't scared of you, no offense

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm not saying they're right to not be

But I don't think any possible combo of players kills you last night. People have been pushing reveal into you all game. You're only throwing your reads off by treating 'i wasn't nightkilled' as a meaningful data point.

[NanceFloor]

I think TD wanted you protected so that I would be open

Nancy scum aren't scared of you, no offense

Yes, I think that blatantly obvious.

[NanceFloor]

I'm not saying they're right to not be

But I don't think any possible combo of players kills you last night. People have been pushing reveal into you all game. You're only throwing your reads off by treating 'i wasn't nightkilled' as a meaningful data point.

So, you’re saying it shouldn’t affect my reads at all.

Well, my POE is still those 3 and you say, that Moon/Chenn are never SvS but TD/Moon or TD/Chenn, could be?

At any rate, I still think flipping TD is our best move.

[RadiantCowbells]

mafia is an awful game tbh

[NanceFloor]

It still doesn't make sense to use 1 of 4 when you're convinced I'm scum.

It doesn't make sense to use Treestump either in that case.

-TL

yeah let's powerlynch Moongrass.

VOTE: Lynch

idk if we should call oka or PB (succinct is too early) yet

-TL

Lynch/Treestump both flip. I’m fine with either, so long as you’re the flip de jour.

[NanceFloor]

mafia is an awful game tbh

It’s bearable when you’re right and I think we win this.

Flip TD/vote 1of4/Lynch.

Only question: lynch or treestump?

I actually disagree with Sky here. Treestump makes the most sense when you think you have a reasonable chance of mislynching but if you’re convinced the slot is flipping scum, then I think lynch > treestump.

[Time Devil]

Why TD over Moongrass?

I thought Moongrass was lockscum

-TL

[NanceFloor]

Why TD over Moongrass?

I thought Moongrass was lockscum

-TL

I—

lowkey it's like you want to be lynched

- Dannflor

[NanceFloor]

Treestump is literally always better than lynch right? unless I'm missing something.

RC, will you lead the lynch today?

I've reread and I don't scum read you anymore. And that's where I'm definitively locking in if that helps at all

- Dannflor

[Time Devil]

Treestump is literally always better than lynch right? unless I'm missing something.

RC, will you lead the lynch today?

I've reread and I don't scum read you anymore. And that's where I'm definitively locking in if that helps at all

- Dannflor

Lynch is better than treestump if you're 100% sure who you want eliminated is scum.

-TL

[NanceFloor]

also if NF gets killed tonight it will probably be used to frame RC which is ridiculous because I think we're one of the most widely town read slots in the game so we'll get NKed sooner or later based off that virtue alone (whether or not scum is scared of us, which they probably aren't)

so like

probably look hard at anyone who tries to push that agenda after I'm gone

- Dannflor

[NanceFloor]

Why TD over Moongrass?

I thought Moongrass was lockscum

-TL

Do you usually refer to yourself in the third person?

POE is you/Moon/Chenn and RC pointed out that Moon/Chenn are never SvS here but you could be with either, plus you’re objectively the scummiest player for pushing reveal on RC.

There’s also D1 BEF wagon which both you and Chenn were on but Mbaki wasn’t and he was on Creature lynch vote until he jumped on to RC.

Overkill11 was also on it but VCA spews him town for never jumping off Creature/Chemist.

[RadiantCowbells]

That Poe logic only applies if you think that Maria/Titus are never scum

[NanceFloor]

That Poe logic only applies if you think that Maria/Titus are never scum

Titus wants to flip TD and I can’t recall Maria ever being this disengaged as scum, plus I still think FL was really townie.

Then there’s Tohru who had both Chennis and Creature in her veto and correctly identified him as scum, like she did Succinct in Topaz, so yeah pretty damn sure that’s the correct POE.

Plus, I’m convinced like Ank, that scum were on D1 BEF wagon and both TD and Chenn were. Ank’s latest POE was Chenn/TD/Overkill11 for reference and of course we have determined that Ok is locktown for staying on Creature/Chemist wagon. So yeah, I’d bet money on it, like I did in Newsroom on Lion/SS.

[NanceFloor]

like I don't see how I can be very far off, like adding chennisden to my PoE list and confscumming him because of the coalition is literally where I'm at

chennisden + Time Devil + 0verki11

Here are the pairings for the Dance:

Player 1	Player 2
RadiantCowbells	0verki11
mbaki	NanceFloor
OkaPoka	BrightEyedFish
Time Devil	themilkcartonkid
Ankamius	Clemency
Creature	Chemist1422
Taly	JohnnyEnglish
chennisden	Titus

this fits like every criteria I have for what scum did for dance

Ank’s solve before she replaced out.

[RadiantCowbells]

Ok so what do you want to do

[NanceFloor]

Because she replaced out pre-Creature flip, she would have had her current POE: Chenn/TD/Moon probably but based on TD acting the scummiest: most likely TD/Chenn/Moon.

So, if we flip TD then do 1of4 - flip between Chenn/Moon. We either win that day or the next flip, so long as we don’t deviate from that plan.

TD again pushing RC reveal is making me lean Chenn over Moon, because RC has been heavily pushing for both TD/Chenn lynches. Since Creature flip, Moon has completely dropped his reveal request on either of us. TD still pushing RC reveal post-Creature flip is uberscummy, so I’m happy with that slot eating rope first.