Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[RCEnigma]

Here is a list of players who would be no great loss as town based only on their actions this game and putting aside my desire to include hero Caine and flavor leaf on this list.

01. Pine
03. Wooper
04. Firebringer
06. Iconeum
07. Korina
09. BBmolla
12. TrueSoulEnergy
18. Gamma Emerald
19. Pink Ball
20. Vorkuta
21. Dr Easy Bake
24. davesaz
26. Elements
28. pisskop, who replaced Hectic
31. Dongempire
35. Creature
36. Almost50, who replaced jadesmar
38. KidAmn

So again... why vorkuta? Why would I ever expect such a seemingly arbitrary choice from this list to flip scum?

Would you hard defend anyone else on this list?

[RCEnigma]

Bingle is coasting and going for low hanging fruit for fragile reasons.

I want to vote Bingle but that’s not viable right now. IN MY MIND I AM VOTING BINGLE.

Bingle has explained why he's taken a backseat and I found that explanation to be pretty townie tbh.

[Flavor Leaf]

It's completely reasonable for a mod to see something like FL posting 400 times in a row just to hear himself talk and say this is ridiculous

It was only 27, don’t exaggerate.

[Untrod Tripod]

...how do you people survive in the outside world. I'm not sure some of you have even met other people who arent your parents holy fucking shit just take the criticism and rule changes and make modest adjustments to your behavior it won't kill you

[Flavor Leaf]

If you’re talking about me, I’m extremely charismatic and social, so what’re you talking about?

I feel like it shows on site, I’m something else, but ya gotta love me

[Flavor Leaf]

What a discredit attempt

[Wooper]

There are people who aren't my parents?

[RCEnigma]

Dark self deprecating joke suppression complete.

[Menalque]

I don’t think saying to tse “who do you SR more out of vork/ele” is a good idea because then you’re giving the execute agency

The only reason to not lynch TSE is because there’s positive utility in not needing to fight to 18-19 votes for the next couple of days

Letting him choose defeats the purpose of that because if we have two wagons over threshold, one town one scum, he can execute town without repercussions

Tbh he’s probably a better lynch than ele (ftr: he completely ignored my mini case on him despite there being plenty of merit to it) but idk if we can get him done in time

[The Fonz]

Let's get the Elements claim already.

[BBmolla]

Flavor you couldn’t find the two times I claimed to know your flavor and you like literally just heard that gobble Friendly Neighbord me

Now imagine I had 250 more posts

That’s all I say regarding the mods update

Can I vote elements without hammering I’m on board

[BBmolla]

I trust that town wouldn't claim scum is a friendly neighbor.

Generally speaking; you are being naive. FL would do it!

But BBMolla is "old school", so he wouldn't fake claim to clear someone that way.

One time a player named Benmage faked a cop guilty. Years ago. On town.

He was not only lynched the next day but also lambasted for being such a toxic idiot.

Nowadays, that's just Tuesday. It's a real shame.

I’ve claimed Cop as a Jailkeeper in 2of4, Amn Cop receiver as a Cop, and Miller as scum

But that’s about the extent of claim crazy as town I get.

[BBmolla]

Last thing before I’m out I’m in the bottom 50% of posters so I think I get one multi post

Zoraster is probably scum

[Amrun]

Last thing before I’m out I’m in the bottom 50% of posters so I think I get one multi post

Zoraster is probably scum

What do you think of the hider claim regarding Zoroaster?

[BBmolla]

Didn’t see it link?

[Amrun]

I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN
I HID BEHIND ZORASTER
HE IS TOWN

[Pink Ball]

Lynch Elements. Elements flips scum. Lynch TSE for not executing. Then lynch Gamma for the lulz

[Menalque]

Lynch Elements. Elements flips scum. Lynch TSE for not executing. Then lynch Gamma for the lulz

+1

[Amrun]

In fairness, I asked TSE to wait for a claim.

[Pink Ball]

And he said he wanted to lynch Gamma trying to derail attention on the main wagon. The three are scum

[The Fonz]

Lynch Elements. Elements flips scum. Lynch TSE for not executing. Then lynch Gamma for the lulz

If TSE doesn't execute some specified period of time before deadline (probably 36 hours) we need to lynch TSE, since he's either lied about his role or isn't cooperating with town.

Claim first tho.

[gobbledygook]

...how do you people survive in the outside world. I'm not sure some of you have even met other people who arent your parents holy fucking shit just take the criticism and rule changes and make modest adjustments to your behavior it won't kill you

Let's get the Elements claim already.

+1

[Almost50]

5-9 Cult

Do you understand how Cults work?

[Almost50]

Also is FormerFish a Good Player?
If not, then the only reason I could see him as the Night Kill is if it was because mafia were trying to form a miss lynch on me but Fish would have defended me.
It’s also possible that he could have been killed because most of the strong players flipped mafia.

Can we talk about this from a purely neutral critical PoV? Or will you take it as a personal attack?? I'll take my chances.. here goes:

Is TSE a Good Player? If not, then why would Mafia ever care to mislynch him (or even NK him) at this point?
Mafia are in dire need of mislynches at this stage, and they cannot afford the day to end in a No Lynch because of the massive number of players. Even if they are 10 (I very much doubt it because one team of TEN players is too strong even if they were all Goons), they still don't want to gang up on the mislynch wagon. Solution? Get the wagon to just 25% of the living players and have you Execute the subject.

Even if it is multi-ball; neither team wants to be on the other's lynch to avoid being shot by the other team, so -again- get the wagon to 25% and have TSE do the job for them.

You only become dangerous if the numbers go down enough to make it both: (a) easy to get a mislynch, and (b) hard to prevent a correct lynch. In other words; when there are fewer than 20 players alive. Only then can the Mafia think "let's get rid of him to make it harder to get a lynch on any of us".

Basically, you are a "town controlled Day Vig", and Mafia almost never hit a Vig (or a SK) this early, because they need the extra kills.

[Almost50]

Lynch Elements. Elements flips scum. Lynch TSE for not executing. Then lynch Gamma for the lulz

You forgot to say: Not necessarily in that order.