Page 267 of 410
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:30 am
by Flea The Magician
Assuming shellys rule of 3 she was so keen on, it's either taylor or fidget.
taylors a pretty solid TR for the majority of people here.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:30 am
by MUSHSHAGANA
I trust UNOwen's judgement. I also think that Gloria is right and Shelly puts out town names in that list exclusively in this game.
Or do I? Mystery and intrigue, etc.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:33 am
by UNOwen
In post 6648, Gloria Cleary wrote:
Based off of meta, I’d say DGB is probably my strongest sr. Is it possible you have the correct solve here?
Anything is possible if it involves me being correct.
In seriousness, I don't completely discount the possibility. I lean towards agreeing with Fidget that DGB doesn't come out with a Titus bus if the situation is looking so dire though, but maybe she felt that a big play was needed. Pessimism also pushes me towards thinking I'm looking at the game wrong somewhere.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:45 am
by Hectic
MUSHSHAGANA
is the new
They now have 2 days to pick a player they'd like to pass the scroll to, using a
VOTE:
I'll allow placeholder votes using the
HURT: tags in the event the player is afraid they'll forget to pass it on. The person it's passed to will simply default to the placeholder they've put down earlier.
If no placeholder vote was used, I'll pick the last living/non-cursed player the scroll bearer has voted in the game to receive the scroll.
If the above is not applicable, I'll allow mafia to pick.
Timer:
(expired on 2020-11-14 18:45:49)
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:47 am
by Noraa
In post 6650, Flea The Magician wrote:Assuming shellys rule of 3 she was so keen on, it's either taylor or fidget.
taylors a pretty solid TR for the majority of people here.
NO. Taylor is town. Fidget is town. I will not have it otherwise.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:49 am
by Titus
In court via zoom, waiting on the bench. Ama.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:51 am
by MURDERCAT
Hope it goes ok Titus even if you are scum here
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:52 am
by Titus
Thank you. It should go well. Just using every spare second I can to engage until I get called.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:54 am
by Titus
So Ama?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:55 am
by Noraa
In post 6653, Hectic wrote:MUSHSHAGANA
is the new
They now have 2 days to pick a player they'd like to pass the scroll to, using a
VOTE:
I'll allow placeholder votes using the
HURT: tags in the event the player is afraid they'll forget to pass it on. The person it's passed to will simply default to the placeholder they've put down earlier.
If no placeholder vote was used, I'll pick the last living/non-cursed player the scroll bearer has voted in the game to receive the scroll.
If the above is not applicable, I'll allow mafia to pick.
Timer:
(expired on 2020-11-14 18:45:49)
The great mushroom hath arrived
less time with queen mush
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 11:58 am
by MURDERCAT
What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:00 pm
by Gloria Cleary
In post 6652, UNOwen wrote: In post 6648, Gloria Cleary wrote:
Based off of meta, I’d say DGB is probably my strongest sr. Is it possible you have the correct solve here?
Anything is possible if it involves me being correct.
In seriousness, I don't completely discount the possibility. I lean towards agreeing with Fidget that DGB doesn't come out with a Titus bus if the situation is looking so dire though, but maybe she felt that a big play was needed. Pessimism also pushes me towards thinking I'm looking at the game wrong somewhere.
Of all of the players that are considered questionable, I feel best about Flea. They just sound really sincere and Fidget has been genuinely sorting as well.
I do think that Shelley was trying to form a Tayl0r counterwagon to save Fred.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:01 pm
by Flea The Magician
In post 6654, Noraa wrote: In post 6650, Flea The Magician wrote:Assuming shellys rule of 3 she was so keen on, it's either taylor or fidget.
taylors a pretty solid TR for the majority of people here.
NO. Taylor is town. Fidget is town. I will not have it otherwise.
For sheer shiggles, pick 1, taylor, noraa, uno, fidget.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:01 pm
by Titus
In post 6660, MURDERCAT wrote:What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
My current solve is Taylor/DGB/Adorable/Plus one infecting the townblock could easily be Uno.
I expect some S v S somewhere.
I didn't have a strong preference for Uno, so it wasn't worth fighting. Either way, we get at least one scum. If I had a strong shelly TR, I fight it. I didn't though.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:03 pm
by Gloria Cleary
In post 6660, MURDERCAT wrote:What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
Owno is definitely town and not just because Shelley!scum because his solve makes the most sense.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:03 pm
by MURDERCAT
Who do you think MUSH will shoot Titus? Who should she shoot?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:07 pm
by Titus
She should shoot within my solve (minus the deep wolf theory as that is vague) but that's a little simplistic. I don't have a strong preference, but gtmh Taylor because she's the deepest.
As for who she will shoot, I'm uncertain. I halfway expect it to be me, which is why I am doing what I can with the limited reading I have done.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:09 pm
by Gloria Cleary
In post 6663, Titus wrote: In post 6660, MURDERCAT wrote:What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
My current solve is Taylor/DGB/Adorable/Plus one infecting the townblock could easily be Uno.
I expect some S v S somewhere.
I didn't have a strong preference for Uno, so it wasn't worth fighting. Either way, we get at least one scum. If I had a strong shelly TR, I fight it. I didn't though.
Owno is mindmelding with me on Flea/Fidget now, plus Shelley kept trying to kill him. Shelley jumped off Fred wagon several times and tried to push Tayl0r. I believe that was a serious push.
@Titus, some reason you have Tayl0r before your lock scumread DGB? Why isn’t she first?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:12 pm
by Titus
In post 6667, Gloria Cleary wrote: In post 6663, Titus wrote: In post 6660, MURDERCAT wrote:What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
My current solve is Taylor/DGB/Adorable/Plus one infecting the townblock could easily be Uno.
I expect some S v S somewhere.
I didn't have a strong preference for Uno, so it wasn't worth fighting. Either way, we get at least one scum. If I had a strong shelly TR, I fight it. I didn't though.
Owno is mindmelding with me on Flea/Fidget now, plus Shelley kept trying to kill him. Shelley jumped off Fred wagon several times and tried to push Tayl0r. I believe that was a serious push.
@Titus, some reason you have Tayl0r before your lock scumread DGB? Why isn’t she first?
Both of them are lockscum. This is exactly like The trials. They selectively ignore points on their buddies to go after town while keeping their hands clean. Taylor with Pooky and DGB with me. They like LHF but didn't expect Pooky to obvtown.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:12 pm
by Noraa
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:13 pm
by Gloria Cleary
In post 6282, Titus wrote: In post 6280, Gloria Cleary wrote: In post 6277, Titus wrote: In post 6276, Gloria Cleary wrote: In post 6256, Titus wrote: In post 6251, Noraa wrote:Fidget is not a lurker. Each post she posts has a large amount of content even tho she only has 100+ posts. Flea on the other hand, has 66 posts each with close to zero content.
I can't find a single post of hers without reading through hundreds of posts I don't have time for.
What's your Gloria read?
Why are you suddenly so interested in making me a focal point while we’re waiting to see who Shelley gives the scroll to?
I'm not. I'm trying to find a way to sort Fidget. I already sorted you.
How does getting Noraa’s read on me help you to sort Fidget when you’ve already sorted me? Shouldn’t you be asking her about Fidget or ISOing her?
I did ask her about Fidget. I got stonewalled. ISOing Fidget removes the context. So by having her explain her read on your 1 v 1, I might get a roundabout way of reading Fidget. Something to look for. As far as I know, Noraa is the only one TRing Fidget.
P.S.
DGB is scum. This is Trials DGB
.
@Titus
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:16 pm
by Titus
Yes? Not sure why you bolded that Gloria?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:17 pm
by MURDERCAT
Yeah this is useful intel that Titus/Goofball are together if Titus comes up scum
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:18 pm
by Adorable
In post 6639, UNOwen wrote:Town:
Bell
Taylor
MURDERCAT
Gloria ??
Fidget ????
Noraa ????
Pooky ????
Flea ??????
Scum:
DGB
Adorable
Titus
Preference is DGB. The solve is probably not those three, so I'd guess there is scum in my town group. I am not ambitious enough to attempt to figure out who I am misreading there without first sorting out the scum group.
Adorable is in there still because shelly going to the defense of Adorable with "Noraa/Adorable is not s/s" (which I remember her repeating a few times) is a pretty scummy way to defend someone while leaving plenty of room to back out if necessary. I also may be falling for the WIFOM of Fred's fake out, but it just seemed like the kind of thing designed to push a scum buddy into the green zone. I had a slight town lean on her way back because the "A -> B" logic of her posts read as earnest and sincere, but she has a bit of experience behind her and I don't think that is too high a bar for her to fake.
Seems like I'm getting scum read here because shelly town read me earlier and that's not how scum hunting works. After a player flips scum, to catch the next scum is to see what the living players would do next if one of them is going for a new agenda. Mafia's goal is to eliminate town and mafia will also try to make fake association with town to try to make it look like they are scum buddies with a town player when they are not and once when one of the scum players gets eliminated, they will try to take down a town player with them by making sure the town player gets eliminated next.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 12:19 pm
by Gloria Cleary
In post 6668, Titus wrote: In post 6667, Gloria Cleary wrote: In post 6663, Titus wrote: In post 6660, MURDERCAT wrote:What is your current solve Titus?
Why did you think uno was more likely scum than shelly and why isn't it that you wanted to test the waters with uno and, when it seemed like it wasn't working, switched to bussing shelly?
My current solve is Taylor/DGB/Adorable/Plus one infecting the townblock could easily be Uno.
I expect some S v S somewhere.
I didn't have a strong preference for Uno, so it wasn't worth fighting. Either way, we get at least one scum. If I had a strong shelly TR, I fight it. I didn't though.
Owno is mindmelding with me on Flea/Fidget now, plus Shelley kept trying to kill him. Shelley jumped off Fred wagon several times and tried to push Tayl0r. I believe that was a serious push.
@Titus, some reason you have Tayl0r before your lock scumread DGB? Why isn’t she first?
Both of them are lockscum. This is exactly like The trials. They selectively ignore points on their buddies to go after town while keeping their hands clean. Taylor with Pooky and DGB with me. They like LHF but didn't expect Pooky to obvtown.
Did you read Noir or Smoke Filled Antechamber, two of Tayl0r’s other scumgames? Tayl0r tried to save Hopkirk and Noraa. Where did Tayl0r do that? I think you’re misrepping her posting here.