The brand-spanking new KK is scum case
–
1. Terrible voting record
Here’s a summary of every one of KK’s votes this game –
Post 20 –
VOTE: theamatuer
1) OMGUS
2) policy
3) xRECKONERx-buddying
His only vote Day 1 is made in RVS.
Post 494 and
Post 565– His Day 2 votes for Magua, split up when I beat him about the head voting before all judging groups were complete.
Post 585 – Day 3’s herp-a-derp back on TheAm.
That’s it. Aside from Day 2 where he slid right onto the obvious choice for the day (and on Town FTR) his vote has been stranded on TheAm the entire game. This moves into the next point …
2. Complete lack of actual scum-hunting.
Let’s examine the scum-hunting that KK has done to support his TheAm votes.
I’ve already posted a link to 20 and his original RVS vote for TheAm. Clearly it’s RVS since none of the three points are actual scum-tells. So let’s examine the supporting scum-hunting he did to support keeping said RVS vote on TheAm and support making his Day 3 vote on TheAm again …
Post 153 –
theamatuer - has yet to post anything pro-town.
Yup, this is the next mention of his thoughts about TheAm as they related to TheAm’s alignment (not using TheAm to attack others like he did with Quilford in
Post 133). Yup, he’s saying absolutely nothing. And as already addressed he didn’t move his vote to either of the players (Quilford or Reck) he called scum in said post 153 (and we have already addressed how he back-tracked on those being actual scum reads which further demonstrates he’s scum).
Now let’s examine
Post 165. Why you ask? Because here he does an PBPA ISO of BBMolla to specifically show that BB is scummy. No vote for BBmolla or hint of a TheAm similar case. That’s of course because he’s scum faking it as opposed actually scum-hunting.
Now onto
Post 210 –
What? I uncovered theamatuer-scum & Quilford-scum. My efforts are not appreciated.
What a cheeky fucking scumbag we have here. Notice he uncovered TheAm ‘scum’ with an RVS vote and did nothing with it. And here he is calling obv-Town Quilford scum since his partner Ajax had yet to flip.
And that is the entirety of his scum-hunting on TheAm related to Day 1. What you say … there was none? That’s why he needs rope.
Post 429 – Now Day 2 we get the closest to actual scum-hunting from KK regarding TheAm in the following …
theamatuer is a wildcard. He's been absolutely useless. I mean, I know he's a VI, but 219 is ridiculously bad. Plus he's the only one that asked for a claim, then seems to honestly consider it to be valid (310). So it's the age-old question of "dumb or scum?"
And what’s most funny is that he’s not even willing to commit to TheAm as scum. He fence-sits calling him a VI and wildcard. Note that he calls
Post 219 ridiculously bad without bothering to actually explain why.
Then in
Post 471 we get KK asking TheAm to replace out. Here’s a question for you … if you think a VI player is scum do you ask them to replace out for a competent teammate to take the slot making the job of lynching scum more difficult? Mull that over while you read the rest of the case on KK …
And that’s it for Day 2. Where is that case again? No-where to be seen.
Day 3 opens with another vote for TheAm with no support at
Post 585.
He lays a ‘TheAm was lazy Day 2’ attack on at
Post 596 (that I agree with from the standpoint that TheAm was a useless bastard about the Magua lynch).
Yup … that is the absolute extent of his scum-hunting on TheAm. I’ll summarize his case for you …
1. RVS
2. TheAm is a VI
3. TheAm didn’t fight Magua’s lynch hard enough.
That’s it. Hard to believe Town-KK has parked his vote on TheAm for basically 2 full game days based on that.
I could do the same and analyze his ‘Magua’ suspicions if necessary. But I think this is enough for the moment. He’s not actually scum-hunting but instead flailing on defense.
3. Captain Ajax links (yes, this is copy / pasted from my first case)
From
Post 133 we have the following chainsaw defense of Ajax in attacking Quilford –
Well, the thing is. You mention that Captain Ajax is attempting to buddy to xRECKONERx by flattering him (Post 67) which is a hell of a stretch. But theamatuer blatantly states "OMG its reckoner. He's like a legend." but that gets no reaction from you at all. Except after the fact where you mention that pretty town due to the enthusiasm involved.
The rest of your analysis in Post 4033077 seems to just another episode in a series of "Let me interpret anything said as a sign of scuminess". For fun, could you analyze MLK Jr.'s "I Have a Dream" speech for scumminess?
Here he is trying to handwave away suspicion of Ajax by Quil as an effort to just find scummy things as opposed to specifically addressing why posts (such as 125) were wrong. He also tries to portray Quilford as inconsistent for his disparate treatment of Deas and Ajax ala buddying.
Next in
Post 153 we get the following read on Ajax –
Captain Ajax - His hitogoroshi vote was horrible. Both times. Overall though, he's not setting off any alarms.
The essence of fence-sitting. He points out behavior that he dislikes (the hito votes) but says that Ajax isn’t ‘setting off alarms’. No comment that he’s actually Town. It’s the perfect springboard to go any direction.\
That is the full extent of his Ajax interactions. Some attempts to defuse the wagon but nothing concrete at all regarding making an alignment commitment or showing posts from Ajax that showed Town / Scum intent.
As for Ajax’s interactions with him? None at all. KK does not merit a single mention in Ajax’s entire ISO.
4. His reactions to pressue and his reaction to being called out by my teammates –
Read points 3 and 4 from
Post 492 if you need this point to convince you.
