sup guys. /confirming in or whatever. i probably wont get around to reading the thread till tomorrow morning because tonight is a beer and george carlin night. i'm going to completely read the thread before the next time i post but it'd be great if anyone can fill me in on wtf is going on
Posted: Tue May 21, 2013 11:41 pm
by mrbungle
LOL @238
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 1:57 am
by mrbungle
i've just finished reading... fuck lol. some hilarious shit in there
first....... pope, vegito, and ghostlin are all fairly strong townreads for me. i want to include tomato guy in there but he hasn't posted enough for me to feel good about that read
pope as town because of two things which sorta come down to the same issue:
-his play is hilariously sloppy. i cannot imagine a scum letting themselves get into as much trouble as TIP has. that guy has absolutely no filter, just says whatever dumb shit as soon as it occurs to him to say it
-the whole evolution or progression of how his claim played out was also hilariously sloppy. in my experience scum don't handle fakeclaims so badly, or so emotionally
vegito:
-the dissonance between the heads seems more likely to come from town. sure scum can fake it but i think it looks pretty natural/convincing
-neither head is abstaining from contributing. since they've replaced in i think it's safe to say that their slot is responsible for most of the content in the thread. no fucking clue why anyone wants to lynch them.
-drp started off iffy, but actually started reading townie as hell once he began his martyrdom campagin. no clue how anyone can think this slot is maf
ghostlin:
-i started reading ghost as town towards the middle of the early game ghost vs pope fight and nothing has changed that
- also wanna sheep vegito's reasoning about those two particular posts that look townie as fuck. 215/216
bacde:
-not much to go on here, but my gut says town because his posting is fearless. he showed he wasn't afraid to pick a fight with vegito midway through the thread. but like i said, this is the weakest of my town reads cuz he's not posting enough
i've just read the thread through once as that was just now, all in one go so my thoughts about who may be scum are pretty scattered. i'm gonna sleep and then do some iso reading and meta research on all the people i don't have town reads on then i'll post who i want to lynch
fortunately i'm reading many of the active posters as town which means I get to do my favorite fucking thing in all of mafia which is VOTE FOR A P.O.S. LURKER
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 2:04 am
by mrbungle
oh, one thing that stuck out to me that I wanted to ask:
@VEGITO how are you so confidently reading hamlet as town?
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 2:21 am
by mrbungle
sword of omens, you got any scum games of yours that i can read over? i clicked like 10 links in your profile and couldn't find one. give me more than 1 please if you've got em
what do you make of 1 half of vegito reading you as scum and the other half reading you as town? it seems like your scumread on veg is mainly based on veg's scumread on you, but nacho is being quite outspoken about you being townie. also it seems like you're quite content to not call them mafia as long as they aren't actively pushing for your lynch which is really odd. can you explain all of that?
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 3:01 am
by fferyllt
I am insulted.
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 3:41 am
by Vegito
In post 682, mrbungle wrote:@VEGITO how are you so confidently reading hamlet as town?
Past experience, and the fuzzy head not being a useless sack of shit. In particular, the B head's Canadian politeness comes out most strongly when he's scum, but he's a little more willing to throw around snark and accomplish a lot of nothing as town. #374 and #394 are the best examples of him being his town as shit self.
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 3:42 am
by Vegito
There's also a lot of things that come across as really genuine; Fuzzy reading Jiffy as town but then trusting Beli's read over his own, and Fuzzy's "yeehaw Beli doesn't know shit about this game" posting spree. Beli is definitely the scum player of the duo, and I seriously doubt that he would let fuzzy play so loose unless they picked up a town slot.
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 5:32 am
by sword_of_omens
Hey all, I’m here …
Doing some work today, but I am aware of the dealine approaching, so expect some input from me….
saw Bungle’s question to me:
In post 683, mrbungle wrote:sword of omens, you got any scum games of yours that i can read over? i clicked like 10 links in your profile and couldn't find one. give me more than 1 please if you've got em
Sorry, but you're going to be SOL on that one...i am always town for some reason : (
i was a scum GF once in Rolling in the Deep , but that was waaaay back, and i had to replace out in the first day or so due to not being able to keep up with 20 pages a day...so don't expect to find too much there..if anything...
the only other one i have that comes close is a cult leader where i kicked ass...
I take it you don't often interact with Canadians who are still alive.
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 7:12 am
by Vegito
In post 688, sword_of_omens wrote:Sorry, but you're going to be SOL on that one...i am always town for some reason : (
The explains the rolling V/LAs, then.
In post 689, Hamlet wrote:I take it you don't often interact with Canadians who are still alive.
Never. I didn't even know what a Canadian was until recently.
Posted: Wed May 22, 2013 7:13 am
by Vegito
In post 681, mrbungle wrote:fortunately i'm reading many of the active posters as town which means I get to do my favorite fucking thing in all of mafia which is VOTE FOR A P.O.S. LURKER
Guessing Omens and Hamlet are your two biggest scumreads, then?
Why in this particular game would nacho be trying to kill you? Also can you guys actually...... give your reads? Looking at your iso I have no idea what position either of your head is taking on most of the players.
@PIMHEL
Why is has your vote been so uselessly parked on the vegita slot all game long? Yeah so you thought DRP was scum, but what are you seeing in the replacement that has made you content with keeping your vote where it was since like 2 weeks ago?
@SWORD same question as above. Actually I like your vote even less, as you've completely neglected to say ANYTHING about vegita so far. Do you think vegita is specifically scummy notwithstanding DRP?
if you're referring to me not mentioning you in my first real post..... i wasn't quite sure to place you after the first read through. you posted a lot but you never really seemed all that outspoken or forceful... your impact on the game was much less than I'd expect to see out the 3rd highest poster. Right now you're kinda nullish for me, but leaning a little town because when it came down to business when you guys thought the deadline was almost up, you seemed pretty interested in the lynch. and then there was some post about you asking someone if they can call nacho and that seemed really townie.
lol i think i just talked myself into placing you above bacde in my town list
