Mafiascum.net

I don't understand the purpose of the question.

↑ Persivul wrote:@grand cayman (or anyone else who wants to answer): Who are/were the best players in this game in your opinion? What skills make them good?

What? Why are you asking this? Definitely post game talk that's distracting from the game. for 1, it's been one day. You couldn't possibly know who's been best, but I'd say me.

But what?

P-edit: yeah Me either

Persivul wrote:

↑ You Got Schooled wrote:...pers, meta me.

Why - don't you mix it up just so that people can't reliably read you?

I love this VCA nonsense. This is pure!town-bella, sorry.

VCA?

Also, did you not read the game overnight?

Yes, but not too closely, as I didn't see the purpose in formulating a plan before the night flip. Also, I get the feeling that Anti can likely push what he wants through for another day, and a newbie isn't going to have much say.

VCA is vote count analysis. Also, you know who else doesn't re-read games closely?

Telling me to mix up my meta in the same post you declare you are gonna let anti do the heavy lifting for you kinda sucks, just so you know. Unless you know anti's alignment 100%, that is...

-bella

Just trying to learn about the players, and generate some discussion so I have more to analyze.

P-edit: I meant best overall players considering all their games, not just this one.

Interesting that people are watching the thread but not participating.

↑ You Got Schooled wrote:
Telling me to mix up my meta in the same post you declare you are gonna let anti do the heavy lifting for you kinda sucks, just so you know. Unless you know anti's alignment 100%, that is...

-bella

I didn't tell you to mix up your meta. You told me to check your meta. I noted that you could certainly have manipulated your meta, so there's no point in me checking it.

But I suppose my question on best players is an attempt to get summaries of metas from the rest of you, as I'm not able to read enough games myself.

Dammit Persivul what is the meaning of this question?!?!? AAAAARRRRGGHHHHH!

Also I've been in two other games during this one. One has ended, one's in night phase. So...wassup bitches?

<jeopardy theme>

Pers has dodged the important bit of my post and is now spamming. Interesting.

Obvious bit is obvious, and spamming beats lurking, as you guys are apparently doing.

who is scum?

who is scum?

who is scum?

who is scum?

tee hee

@GC: Currently I lean scum on YGS. I find anti questionable. You I have leaning town. I know that's not much, but I don't have much to go on. There's an awful lot of one-line posts in this thread. It's tough for me to get reads. That's why I'd like to see more talk from everyone.

GC, what's the significance of your signature?

Persivul, can you state your case for us being scum please?

A nice concise summary of your thoughts would be much appreciated.

~BBT

↑ Green Crayons wrote:

@snscompt:

who is scum?

↑ You Got Schooled wrote:Persivul, can you state your case for us being scum please?

A nice concise summary of your thoughts would be much appreciated.

~BBT

OK

- Throwing too many votes around after the first couple of pages

- As someone else noted, you're way too defensive when someone puts you in their scum group, even if you don't have votes. You're too concerned with personal survival. I understand defending when the votes mount, and I do it myself, but you seem too concerned with preempting a possible wagon on yourself.

What is scummy about throwing votes around?

Why is being defensive scummy? Why would we not want to survive as town? Why is it scummy to try and understand why someone is scum reading you?

~BBT

↑ You Got Schooled wrote:What is scummy about throwing votes around?

It sows confusion instead of cohesion in the collective scum hunt.

Why is being defensive scummy? Why would we not want to survive as town?

Undue defensiveness takes the focus off the scum hunt.

Why is it scummy to try and understand why someone is scum reading you?

~BBT

A townie who doesn't feel an imminent threat doesn't worry about a few pokes at them. They figure that if they keep scum hunting people will see it and the pokes will pass.

BBT, can you explain the bit between you and anti regarding ika and white flag?

↑ Persivul wrote:GC, what's the significance of your signature?

Did you have a full and fair trial?

WELL GOOD.

STOP COMPLAINING.

NO YOU CAN'T GET HABEAS RELIEF JUST BECAUSE YOU'RE "ACTUALLY" INNOCENT.

THE SYSTEM WORKS.

I think it's rather appropriate for the game of mafia.

So everyone agrees Persv v. YGS for today, right?

Pile onto your racehorse, folks!

Let's not drag today out.