Mafiascum.net

In post 426, Leodanny wrote:Vorkuta you should vote!

In post 606, Leodanny wrote:Hey I’m caught up now.

What about inbetween these two posts?

ill also take a leodanny lynch

Right ok- what did I do that's scummy this time?

and @mbaki- is #666 a readlist with townreads on top? or a 'would not lynch' list? Because the two can be quite different.

no response to 661?

all my townreads scumread my other townreads

can you guys place nice

play nice* even

Vork is your town read?

I only feel good lynching DrDolittle rn

every other lynch has a high chance of turning out to be a terrible mislynch

Oh wow- that's how you get people to reply to you?
We still have 4 days left- that's enough time to start an NC wagon, don't you think?

I don't think you approach of herding votes by deciding what wagons can or can't go through on D-1 is very town friendly.
It's narrow in scope and it feels like an anti-town thing to say.

I mean sure- you can go down the entire player cast and give a reason for why a wagon on the SHOULD exist, or why a wagon on them WON'T go through today, however urging 4 lurking players to explicitly PICK one of the 4 'NC-approved-wagons' still strikes me as scum. Like they see the VC and the general state of town. Why the herding?

In post 103, rb wrote:every post someone makes that isn't voting the wagons i'm on is a shitpost tbh

I'm still dying from this quote- is it a shitpost if I defend myself?

In post 674, Leodanny wrote:also, NC is right, so I’m gonna say:
666 combined with mbaki’s Vorkuta vote is weird, and I still have

no clue how scumhunting works

trust in you(NC) and still want to vote DDL.

What is weird about my Vorkuta vote?

In post 678, Vorkuta wrote:Right ok- what did I do that's scummy this time?

and @mbaki- is #666 a readlist with townreads on top? or a 'would not lynch' list? Because the two can be quite different.

Yes, overall a reads list.

In post 684, Vorkuta wrote:Oh wow- that's how you get people to reply to you?
We still have 4 days left- that's enough time to start an NC wagon, don't you think?

I don't think you approach of herding votes by deciding what wagons can or can't go through on D-1 is very town friendly.
It's narrow in scope and it feels like an anti-town thing to say.

I mean sure- you can go down the entire player cast and give a reason for why a wagon on the SHOULD exist, or why a wagon on them WON'T go through today, however urging 4 lurking players to explicitly PICK one of the 4 'NC-approved-wagons' still strikes me as scum. Like they see the VC and the general state of town. Why the herding?

It is enough time, sure. I thought Nero Cain was scum at this point, I would happily start it, the consolidation point is a good guideline but 4 days is plenty of time for new wagons if and only if cased (a naked vote now is not good enough).

That said, the key word is underlined. In reality, 684 is a scummy post that made me feel better about my vote being on you.

Nero, that post that creature pointed out showed his mindset in a way I haven't really seen from anyone else in this game.

checking in.

top three wagons are Yyotta, DDL, and Vorkuta?

yeah ok.

reasons for the wagons if im not mistaken.

yyotta- useless troll who is either scum troll or town liability.
ddl - lurking?
vorkuta - lazy?

that's what i've gathered. free to supplement.

Yyotta has done some things that blatantly show a "lynch anyone but me" mentality. The "why me" post, the suka vote "for no reason", and the OMGUS vote on mbaki immediately come to mind.

In post 666, mbaki wrote:I am not willing to lynch rb, Kmd4390, OkaPoka.

I probably would not lynch Creature, Nero Cain, Suka.

I would be okay with lynching Varsoon, Leodanny.

Ideally, we lynch in DrDoLittle, Vorkuta, BrightEyedFish, YyottaCat.

For me, I townread the top two groups to varying degrees and scumread the bottom two to varying degrees. It is more PoE at this point for me, as I townread half of the playerlist and therefore it is a 50% shot of hitting scum if this is a 10:3 game and I'm right about all of my town reads (a big assumption for day 1 of course). When games have a lot of townie players and minimal outright scummy players, those are where the lurkers and null slots tend to flip scum. Vorkuta's last post on Nero Cain also happens to be his scummiest post in the game in my opinion.

I don't like how these three votes

Suka, DDL, Yyotta

are the "undecided" votes
none of these guys are that well townread/trusted. two of them are in the top two wagons. one of them was just a top wagon that got dissolved for others. more importantly i dont like their slots.

maybe that's too confusing

i just don't like that them three have the wagon deciding ability and not others

I don't actually know if this is Creature's town game, but I suppose now is not the time to open up that can of worms.

-

-

-