Newbie 2004: Trash Panada Hour. Redux! GAME OVER


Forum rules
User avatar
Elmo TeH AzN
Elmo TeH AzN
Jack of All Trades
User avatar
User avatar
Elmo TeH AzN
Jack of All Trades
Jack of All Trades
Posts: 5288
Joined: November 2, 2011
Location: Up In A Tree Somewhere.

Post Post #675 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 12:53 am

Post by Elmo TeH AzN »

Image


Votecount 1.09
Osuka (1)
- lilith2013,
CopyKat (2)
- Brassherald, votato,
Freddiethelady (1)
- osuka
Brassherald (1)
- Formerfish,


Not Voting (4) -
Nasi, gibus, CopyKat, Freddiethelady,

With 9 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2020-05-21 11:05:00)
Stats not in the wiki. I'm That Crazy Panda.
I Speak Engrish Not English Leave My Grammar Alone.


Permanently V/LA
User avatar
Formerfish
Formerfish
Busboy Revolutionary
User avatar
User avatar
Formerfish
Busboy Revolutionary
Busboy Revolutionary
Posts: 12855
Joined: July 1, 2013
Location: Pittsburgh, PA

Post Post #676 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 1:28 am

Post by Formerfish »

In post 670, brassherald wrote:As to Gibus, I feel he's shown some good thoughts and his posting has actually improved since the end of RVS. You know? Like a town.
This is very vague, and not at all made up sounding at all. I'm convinced that you care about this read and aren't just making shit up.
Show
"Getting lost in the details of nothing..."

"FF, you're a dick, but you don't hit below the belt. So you're a dick about finding scum, not hurting the people who are playing the game. That's acceptable dickary." MaryJoLisa

Need advice? Ask a Fish.
User avatar
Nauci
Nauci
Mafia Scum
User avatar
User avatar
Nauci
Mafia Scum
Mafia Scum
Posts: 3631
Joined: October 10, 2017

Post Post #677 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 2:10 am

Post by Nauci »

Oh boy oh gee a Formerfish game! I swear that wasn't sarcastic I am legit twice as excited now

I swear the number of times that people who self voted turned out to be scum...

Lord almighty I haven't seen a cringey newbie screw up this bad since when I did that in my first game on this site oh jeez excuse me I must cringe out of existence for a hot minute

I like this kid's style. Cheeky bugger

No

THREE DAYS to get to page 5?!? Y'all am I gonna have to give this game mouth to mouth

WOOHOO! Real content!

Look, I was giving you hella leeway because this is a newbie game and the exact place for advice, but this is an awful lot of posts from votato that are just teaching feathers. That amount of IIOA is lookin' real suss.
In post 116, Freddiethelady wrote:I’m suspicious that Lilith is a little more experienced then she’s letting on.
Huh? All of her posts seem like they're coming from an experienced player? I don't understand what you meant by this?
In post 124, Freddiethelady wrote:
In post 121, lilith2013 wrote:
In post 119, Freddiethelady wrote:And @lilith you are posting only a little more then @iamironcat. It might not be AI but it seems interesting to me you jumped to protect ironcat so quickly.
I mean, we’ve both posted so I don’t really think you can say either of us were lurking. And regardless, this early I don’t think it’s AI. The only reason I didn’t include formerfish in this is because he hasn’t actually posted.

Can you answer my question about me being “more experienced than I’m letting on”? Why is that something you are suspicious of?
You aren’t posting much, casting votes and defending someone. Not trying to sort out the rules, clarify things or understand people better. It seems a little sus to me, and I could be wrong but it feels lurking to me....That’s why I asked you to explain your vote and your defending.
Okay see several people asked the same question I just did but he totally avoided answering it even when it was repeated at him, versus the rest of the questions. ¿Por que?

that logic is wild lmao

ironcat pls what are u evn doin

what is this, LaL?

oh so now we're pretending Lynch All Lurkers is real knowledge?

Oh thank god that's a lot easier to read/type and I can stop getting the slot confused with Lilith

I should start a counter for freddie's misinterpretations

@ironcat: I didn't get your logic in 159 and I don't get it here either. Can you type it out more explicitly?

@formerfish: BDE?
In post 195, Formerfish wrote:
In post 18, brassherald wrote:Yo, what up?

VOTE: Former Fish

I was town PR before!
You're the only person I know here and this is my rvs thing.
In post 19, lilith2013 wrote:VOTE: formerfish mafia addicts should be quicklynched so they become less addicted
Decently obfuscated vote on me. Probably scum.
Literally in the same post you dismissed something as a thing you did because RVS, and then cast suspicion on Lilith for something she did during RVS? This smells so scummy

Brass, it seems you need to use /s tags

AGAIN with the IIOA!

I legitimately can't currently tell if Formerfish is misrepresenting or actually can't detect sarcasm/facetiousness.

why can't the people in my never-lynch pile ever be more helpful :facepalm:
In post 204, Formerfish wrote:
In post 168, votato wrote:Paranoia, poor logic, a scum list that's too long, no reasoning. You can scumread me for that if you want
I like you. You could still be scum and ill cry a single tear when you die, but i like you.
This is how I feel about you, Formerfish
In post 208, Formerfish wrote:Pushing to lynch any of the SEs is not a good look on you.
The way you keep collectively assigning quality to SEs for the sole reason that they're SEs ain't no good look either buddy

& Sweetie don't worry your pretty little head and just let us adults take care of the scum hunting, okay?

now that's a darn dirty misrep sir

:facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm:
In post 236, CopyKat wrote:16+48+49 <-- I think he's genuine about having wanted to play scum
Those so WIFOM that it's NAI.
In post 237, feathers wrote:I think Votato is a townsperson as well since pretty early on. They've (what pronoun do you use btw, votato?) been very active, giving pro-town advice (personally they really helped me know how rvs/voting should be done and to form my thought processes), not afraid to make clear stances, and I don't really feel like they're pushing any kind of agenda - they've mostly been helping clarify stances/thought processes or resolve disagreements.
I have the opposite read to my predecessor and their naiveté. I think votato has gone out of his way to post without stirring up anything. Clarifications and helping is great, but it makes for the vast majority of his content because it's hard to make up genuine thought processes of read progression as scum.
In post 261, brassherald wrote:
In post 260, CopyKat wrote:
In post 259, brassherald wrote:Outing PRs is never a good idea as town, and is a scum move.
agree 100% but doesn't scum post "votato and copycat are masons" in their scum PT and not here?

I think there is a difference between scum play and poor play.
Its real easy for scum to hide behind bad play if you let scummy plays go as just bad play
Brass you're going to have to explain to me how that would be a viable scum strategy instead of a bad anti-town move? Because I feel like the only options are bad move all around
In post 265, gibus wrote:If it doesn't make them more accurate, the mafia would waste night kills
Image

& are more IIOA or fluff posts

you're killin' me Smalls
In post 302, CopyKat wrote:So now I'm in a catch-22

gibus clarified + for me and Its not the scum slip I thought it was but if I unvote I'll probably be scumread for it
brassherald wrote:There are two people who the scum do not want lynched. Otherwise, the only reason they want a slot to keep around is if they think they've got them pocketed.

You clearly do not have anyone pocketed.
So am I scum in this or is scum trying to keep me around? I genuinely confused
This level of self-consciousness only comes from scum I swear
In post 314, brassherald wrote:THE POINT IS COUNTING TO TWO! Can you do that?
I've never in several games seen Brass break like this before but here it is entirely warranted and I applaud you good sir

I missed you buddy it's good to be back

I've only read through page 14 but here's my game solve via a classic:

Nauci's Listicular Spectacular Numero Uno


Never Lynch But Maybe Also Never Read Either

  • Iamironcat
  • Gibus
These Scummers A'ight

  • Brassherald
  • Formerfish
Insufficient Data, We Require More Pylons

  • Freddiethelady
  • lilith2013
Mmmm, Ionno...

    To the Stocks With Thee!

    • CopyKat
    • Votato
    CopyKat because of a few things Brass said and because post 302 quoted above SMELLS SO BAD

    I think Votato is scum because he's very active but SO. DANG. MUCH. of his content is either fluff or IIOA that, while the information posts are very helpful, he's coasting through on those instead of scum hunting and analysis contributions.

    Votato's Fluff Posts:

    , , , , , , , , , , ,

    Votato's Information Instead of Analysis Posts:

    , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    I'm stopping at page 14 because holy shit it's 6:03 AM what the fuck am I doing

    @formerfish hey can I get in on that rehab
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 3631
    Joined: October 10, 2017

    Post Post #678 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 2:12 am

    Post by Nauci »

    Part 2 will come after I wake up but part VOTE: CopyKat can come right the heck now
    User avatar
    votato
    votato
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    votato
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4028
    Joined: April 17, 2020

    Post Post #679 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 3:38 am

    Post by votato »

    that puts copykat on L-2. Nauci how do you reconcile your top 2 scum reads scum reading each other? Are we just bussing hard? Pretty meh catchup, speaking of iioa
    "It is not our ignorance that will kill us, but our arrogance"
    "I expect that 90% of what you say to me is one form of trickery or another" - a friend irl
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #680 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 3:42 am

    Post by brassherald »

    In post 676, Formerfish wrote:
    In post 670, brassherald wrote:As to Gibus, I feel he's shown some good thoughts and his posting has actually improved since the end of RVS. You know? Like a town.
    This is very vague, and not at all made up sounding at all. I'm convinced that you care about this read and aren't just making shit up.
    I'm not making a wall post so that's what you get
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    osuka
    osuka
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    osuka
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4678
    Joined: July 2, 2017
    Location: with my scumpartners

    Post Post #681 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 4:01 am

    Post by osuka »

    In post 679, votato wrote:that puts copykat on L-2. Nauci how do you reconcile your top 2 scum reads scum reading each other? Are we just bussing hard? Pretty meh catchup, speaking of iioa
    this is completely out of touch with reality and the fact that his two scumreads scumread each other means nothing. Her post was pretty okay and yours is a sad accusation based on a fabricated premise

    i liked you for town before but now I'm not so sure
    "I would also like to reiterate my claim that Osuka is sort of obviously town" - rc about scumsuka
    "don't tell anyone, but there's a reason why you're one of my favourite people to mod for" - datisi
    User avatar
    osuka
    osuka
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    osuka
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4678
    Joined: July 2, 2017
    Location: with my scumpartners

    Post Post #682 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 4:01 am

    Post by osuka »

    In post 680, brassherald wrote:
    In post 676, Formerfish wrote:
    In post 670, brassherald wrote:As to Gibus, I feel he's shown some good thoughts and his posting has actually improved since the end of RVS. You know? Like a town.
    This is very vague, and not at all made up sounding at all. I'm convinced that you care about this read and aren't just making shit up.
    I'm not making a wall post so that's what you get
    can we get
    something
    that isn't completely bland?
    "I would also like to reiterate my claim that Osuka is sort of obviously town" - rc about scumsuka
    "don't tell anyone, but there's a reason why you're one of my favourite people to mod for" - datisi
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #683 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:26 am

    Post by brassherald »

    I'm sorry that Nauci replaced into a Scum slot.

    VOTE: Nauci

    We're still buds outside of the game
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    User avatar
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    Spice of Life
    Posts: 7170
    Joined: September 22, 2015
    Pronoun: she/her
    Location: New York
    Contact:

    Post Post #684 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:30 am

    Post by lilith2013 »

    Explain please?
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #685 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:35 am

    Post by brassherald »

    In post 684, lilith2013 wrote:Explain please?
    I said before that people were trusting feathers way too easily. That catch up post where Nauci claims on day 1 to name the Scum team doesn't seem right. As votato said its a lot of IIOA and she's trying to pocket me by pointing out me being upset was justified. Which I already knew, but whatever.

    I don't think Town!Nauci feels a need to point out that as the only bit about me, too. Overall, I didn't like that after she already replaced into a slot I had heavy suspicions of
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    User avatar
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    Spice of Life
    Posts: 7170
    Joined: September 22, 2015
    Pronoun: she/her
    Location: New York
    Contact:

    Post Post #686 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:40 am

    Post by lilith2013 »

    In post 600, lilith2013 wrote:
    In post 549, lilith2013 wrote:
    In post 540, brassherald wrote:Ironcat and Lilli is my best guess at a TvT argument if there is one.
    Can you explain why you think this?
    Also can you answer this question
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #687 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:42 am

    Post by brassherald »

    In post 686, lilith2013 wrote:
    In post 600, lilith2013 wrote:
    In post 549, lilith2013 wrote:
    In post 540, brassherald wrote:Ironcat and Lilli is my best guess at a TvT argument if there is one.
    Can you explain why you think this?
    Also can you answer this question
    I already did. You guys displayed reasoning that I think town uses. I think you were both wrong but the process was there.

    I will not be answering the same question a third time
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    User avatar
    User avatar
    lilith2013
    she/her
    Spice of Life
    Spice of Life
    Posts: 7170
    Joined: September 22, 2015
    Pronoun: she/her
    Location: New York
    Contact:

    Post Post #688 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 5:43 am

    Post by lilith2013 »

    Oh sorry I must have missed it
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Posts: 12855
    Joined: July 1, 2013
    Location: Pittsburgh, PA

    Post Post #689 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 9:20 am

    Post by Formerfish »

    In post 677, Nauci wrote:Oh boy oh gee a Formerfish game! I swear that wasn't sarcastic I am legit twice as excited now
    Have we played together before?
    Show
    "Getting lost in the details of nothing..."

    "FF, you're a dick, but you don't hit below the belt. So you're a dick about finding scum, not hurting the people who are playing the game. That's acceptable dickary." MaryJoLisa

    Need advice? Ask a Fish.
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Posts: 12855
    Joined: July 1, 2013
    Location: Pittsburgh, PA

    Post Post #690 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 9:37 am

    Post by Formerfish »

    In post 683, brassherald wrote:I'm sorry that Nauci replaced into a Scum slot.

    VOTE: Nauci

    We're still buds outside of the game
    Since when are you sring feathers slot?

    Did you screw up the chart you made to help you keep all your "reads" in order?

    First you forget how you're reading Gib, and now feathers slot. I think you need an assistant as scum to play well. CAN WE GET THIS SCUMMER SOME ASSISTANCE?
    Show
    "Getting lost in the details of nothing..."

    "FF, you're a dick, but you don't hit below the belt. So you're a dick about finding scum, not hurting the people who are playing the game. That's acceptable dickary." MaryJoLisa

    Need advice? Ask a Fish.
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #691 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:01 am

    Post by brassherald »

    In post 540, brassherald wrote:
    In post 539, Formerfish wrote:
    In post 538, brassherald wrote:I'm cool with where my vote is. I feel like there's lots of noise from Kat but not much else. Feeling good about it.
    Ok, you care to comment on anything else, or are you good with that being your contribution given everything else that has been going on?
    I feel like people might have been a little too fast to trust Feathers. Still not sure about you.

    Ironcat and Lilli is my best guess at a TvT argument if there is one.

    Votato I'm comfortable saying he's either town or got me pocketed hard.

    I don't know about Freddie at all legitimately forgot he was in the game
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #692 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:02 am

    Post by brassherald »

    In post 690, Formerfish wrote:
    In post 683, brassherald wrote:I'm sorry that Nauci replaced into a Scum slot.

    VOTE: Nauci

    We're still buds outside of the game
    Since when are you sring feathers slot?

    Did you screw up the chart you made to help you keep all your "reads" in order?

    First you forget how you're reading Gib, and now feathers slot. I think you need an assistant as scum to play well. CAN WE GET THIS SCUMMER SOME ASSISTANCE?
    Can you read?
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    brassherald
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    brassherald
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 4964
    Joined: December 21, 2017
    Location: New York

    Post Post #693 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:06 am

    Post by brassherald »

    Just to be clear, I'm not asking if you are able to read but like if I say something that's been clearly stated can you all please just read what I've already written rather than wasting my time with inane questions
    I've only made one good post, and don't you dare accuse me of doing it again.
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Posts: 12855
    Joined: July 1, 2013
    Location: Pittsburgh, PA

    Post Post #694 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:08 am

    Post by Formerfish »

    In post 540, brassherald wrote:I feel like people might have been a little too fast to trust Feathers.
    I can read. The above sentence says that you feel people might have been quick to trust feathers.

    I think what you meant to say is that "I (brass) have a scum read on feathers based off the following reasons, and supported by this evidence."

    Instead you are just changing your reads with little to no reason given and then you are being a snarky shit when people ask you to explain basic principles of the game and your stances in it.

    I mean if you want to just be a pedantic fuck then I can just not give a shit about you until I have to.
    Show
    "Getting lost in the details of nothing..."

    "FF, you're a dick, but you don't hit below the belt. So you're a dick about finding scum, not hurting the people who are playing the game. That's acceptable dickary." MaryJoLisa

    Need advice? Ask a Fish.
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Formerfish
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Busboy Revolutionary
    Posts: 12855
    Joined: July 1, 2013
    Location: Pittsburgh, PA

    Post Post #695 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:13 am

    Post by Formerfish »

    In post 685, brassherald wrote:heavy suspicions
    I'm having a hard time reconciling your current read on feathers with what youve said about them so far.

    Like the only mention you make of them really is that you think that people are trusting them too quick, but you arent giving any reason for us to not trust him. Like do you have specific posts of his that look fabricated and made up? If you do, by all means lets see them and discuss, because I can't argue against a point that is only hinted at being made and never followed through on.

    You know how this game is played and you are playing it in a way right now that is going to be detrimental to town. So you have a choice, dont do that and live, or continue to play the way you are and ill make sure to get you lynched today.

    Deal?
    Show
    "Getting lost in the details of nothing..."

    "FF, you're a dick, but you don't hit below the belt. So you're a dick about finding scum, not hurting the people who are playing the game. That's acceptable dickary." MaryJoLisa

    Need advice? Ask a Fish.
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 3631
    Joined: October 10, 2017

    Post Post #696 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:41 am

    Post by Nauci »

    In post 679, votato wrote:that puts copykat on L-2. Nauci how do you reconcile your top 2 scum reads scum reading each other? Are we just bussing hard? Pretty meh catchup, speaking of iioa
    Did that start as of page 14?

    I don't count anything as bussing unless there was a viable lynch wagon on it—did they successfully get each other to -2?
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 3631
    Joined: October 10, 2017

    Post Post #697 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:43 am

    Post by Nauci »

    In post 685, brassherald wrote:she's trying to pocket me by pointing out me being upset was justified.
    Actually I was just saying you were justified as an indirect dig at the post you were talking about because I had run out of direct ways to express it
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 3631
    Joined: October 10, 2017

    Post Post #698 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:44 am

    Post by Nauci »

    In post 689, Formerfish wrote:
    In post 677, Nauci wrote:Oh boy oh gee a Formerfish game! I swear that wasn't sarcastic I am legit twice as excited now
    Have we played together before?
    I don't think so; the reaction was by reputation
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    User avatar
    User avatar
    Nauci
    Mafia Scum
    Mafia Scum
    Posts: 3631
    Joined: October 10, 2017

    Post Post #699 (ISO) » Sun May 17, 2020 10:46 am

    Post by Nauci »

    In post 693, brassherald wrote:Just to be clear, I'm not asking if you are able to read but like if I say something that's been clearly stated can you all please just read what I've already written rather than wasting my time with inane questions
    ლ(ಠ益ಠ)ლ WHAT DID Y'ALL DO THAT BROKE BRASS , GAME ლ(ಠ益ಠ)ლ
    Locked