Mafiascum.net

Do we think there could be two mafia teams in this game? All of the confirmed townies and the cop means this game would be hard for only one mafia team.

lolno.

I'm gonna be honest. I don't feel like dredging through 20 pages. This ended up getting me lynched last game as town so I'll do it if I absolutely have to but I'm just not having a good time doing it. I can get reads without it.

In post 675, Truth wrote:Do we think there could be two mafia teams in this game? All of the confirmed townies and the cop means this game would be hard for only one mafia team.

Multiballs aren't allowed in minis

In post 674, Truth wrote:I am quite suspicious of chkflip because Psyche said he wanted to execute him and then he died. Some people are saying this means chkflip is town as this play would be too obvious if chkflip was mafia. But I think because people will think that, it is actually the perfect play to make for him without getting any suspicion.

VOTE: chkflip

Do I claim now, or...?

Better question: when are you going to stop purposefully playing newb cards?

Hey yall sorry but i think im gonna have to I’m skimming and keeping up with stuff but won’t really be able to do much else besides keep up with reading and general thoughts.

In post 675, Truth wrote:Do we think there could be two mafia teams in this game? All of the confirmed townies and the cop means this game would be hard for only one mafia team.

Who said anything about a cop? What is their result? What are the current claims so far? Who is conftown and why?

The worst is a cop IC with an inno on me
Walter is an IC
Psyche was an IC

I'll make a bigger post in ~1-2 hours

so, i don't really know what to say now that i've made my re-read of this thread

We have good wagons though, let's stop horsing around town VOTE: titus

and chkflip lmao no, u don't need to claim

I would vote overkill but they just replaced so i think I will first

VOTE: looker

In post 674, Truth wrote:I am quite suspicious of chkflip because Psyche said he wanted to execute him and then he died. Some people are saying this means chkflip is town as this play would be too obvious if chkflip was mafia. But I think because people will think that, it is actually the perfect play to make for him without getting any suspicion.

VOTE: chkflip

Truth. Read my posts today.

There's still probably scope to policy lynch this kittem and for town to win. Low-key I don't actually think they're very towny.

But much more important: VOTE: Dunnstral

In post 678, chkflip wrote:

In post 674, Truth wrote:I am quite suspicious of chkflip because Psyche said he wanted to execute him and then he died. Some people are saying this means chkflip is town as this play would be too obvious if chkflip was mafia. But I think because people will think that, it is actually the perfect play to make for him without getting any suspicion.

VOTE: chkflip

Do I claim now, or...?

Better question: when are you going to stop purposefully playing newb cards?

no

ideally yes but I don't think they're very self aware.

don't backread if you don't want. why don't you have opinions on things that are happening now?

Yes agreed,
VOTE: Dunnstral

In post 683, Gypyx wrote:so, i don't really know what to say now that i've made my re-read of this thread

We have good wagons though, let's stop horsing around town VOTE: titus

and chkflip lmao no, u don't need to claim

Titus has just entered the chkflip tier. Let her catch up, she's rewarding to have in the game.

May I interest you in murdering Dunnstral?

In post 684, superbowl9 wrote:I would vote overkill but they just replaced so i think I will first

VOTE: looker

Talk to me about why looker is scum please

the worst, I don't read on catch up remember? I get my reads based on in thread interactions and VCs.

Given the number of ICs I don't think scum will bus here.

I also can't see why town would need a roleblocker with the number of IC cleared power here.

In post 686, the worst wrote: no

ideally yes but I don't think they're very self aware.

don't backread if you don't want. why don't you have opinions on things that are happening now?

My attentions have been elsewhere recently. I'm still getting back in the swing of things here but you have my full attention now. What's the case on Dunnstral exactly?

In post 683, Gypyx wrote: and chkflip lmao no, u don't need to claim

I was being facetious.

Okay, so I don't see the Dunnstral stuff as being anything less than genuine scumhunting. I agree that there could potentially be a maf in osuka/looker, but gun to my head I don't think it's osuka off of today's play. Maybe it's the fact that he resembles my typical style but it reads town to me as well. So my surface level reads so far aside from the obvious IC clears and the cop inno I'm willing to town bucket Dunn and osuka so far. If Walter wasn't IC I'd town bucket him for his post about being disappointed in his D1 play. I'd also town bucket Gyp for a reason I already don't remember off my skim. I'll look back again to find that post if you'd like but you inno'd him, so, I don't think it matters that much.

The more I look at Truth the more I see newb!scum. The aversion to being "honest," the awkward 2-team question piling in with the other newb card self-awareness he keeps doing just isn't sitting well with me rn.

That may or may not be because he has had this fetish with my slot all game, apparently (I think I saw something at EoD1 where someone called him out for that), but I'd almost be willing to elim off that alone. I spent a lot of years in the newbie queue to develop a sense of what newb!town vs newb!scum looked like and I'm getting hard vibes of the latter here.

Decided to go back and give it another try.

In post 68, Truth wrote:I feel bad about my first game so I am trying to be open and transparent. If I was an important role, I would not have claimed, but because I am a vanilla townie, I claimed because I want people to see that I will not be lying in this game.

This is actually fairly redeeming in the newb!case. I'd seen it earlier but may have brushed past it. While incredibly wrong in its outcome I can actually see where newb!town is coming from here. I've seen it an absurd amount of times in the queue. Granted, this was years ago, but IME the newbie meta doesn't make incredible strides or shifts. My "honesty" read above was from his claim. I like this post a lot.

The redtea post above it is pretty wretching, though, in retrospect. Gonna wait for people who haven't showed up to chime in more there.

In post 672, the worst wrote:

In post 671, Dunnstral wrote:I said he was faking it for town points

and just... never reconsidered that anything in bugspray's iso might be earnest this game?

In post 671, Dunnstral wrote:I don't townread redtea

ok which of bugs' early reads struck you as disagreeable in a scummy way then

In post 671, Dunnstral wrote:His superbowl push was weak

please give me a comparably strong stance / read on superbowl.

In post 671, Dunnstral wrote:His play this game looks like his scum game here: viewtopic.php?f=83&t=83367

besides the fact it's bugspray and they're generally kinda cute/fluffy and whimsical i don't see the similarities at all. can you please explain what struck you as similar in a scum indicative way?

His reads as a whole were disagreeable, pretty much all except for redtea for me

superbowl had good content at the time that redtea was pushing him

His posts looked similar to me. You're looking at it in hindsight.

In post 678, chkflip wrote:

In post 674, Truth wrote:I am quite suspicious of chkflip because Psyche said he wanted to execute him and then he died. Some people are saying this means chkflip is town as this play would be too obvious if chkflip was mafia. But I think because people will think that, it is actually the perfect play to make for him without getting any suspicion.

VOTE: chkflip

Do I claim now, or...?

Better question: when are you going to stop purposefully playing newb cards?

He's not playing anything, this is just how he is

In post 687, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Yes agreed,
VOTE: Dunnstral

Agreed with ?

I'm willing to accept that for now. What happened to your redtea read?

The the worst post above mine,
Although truth is definitely on my watch list.

In post 689, Titus wrote:the worst, I don't read on catch up remember? I get my reads based on in thread interactions and VCs.

Of course, substitute that for "wait til she gets into the swing of things".