Mafiascum.net

how are you tonight?

In post 674, Lukewarm wrote:

In post 669, sang froid wrote:

In post 663, sang froid wrote:

In post 602, Bimblesticks wrote:You're more reasonable, so I haven't decided yet how I read you

this strikes me as a very odd thing to say

lukewarm, what do you think of this?

I took it at face value.

Looking over some other players isos (bulge, noraa, ydra (when she reached out to him)), and seeing the posts leading up to Roden's replace out, I get the feeling that he was getting frustrated and very well might have been unreasonable. -- I have actually avoided reading his iso for this very reason :/

right, but 2 things

(1) the idea of "deciding" how to read someone is uh, odd to me

and (2) a read in terms of town/scum being based on reasonableness also seems strange. town are often unreasonable, scum very often try hard to be reasonable. why does the read depend on this?

@Ydra -- Prior to the cc fiasco that just happened, who was your top choice for elim?

Has the cc fiasco changed that?

mood as follows.

that's not ideal

fuck if i know who i would have elimmed i haven't kept up much.

I am excusing ydrasse for the evening, but I uh, do have some concerns about that slot

In post 680, Ydrasse wrote:fuck if i know who i would have elimmed i haven't kept up much.

I guess seeing as how you were currently voting for me, I hoped you had some new thoughts lol

if you have concerns about my slot refer to the fact that i repped in solely on the strength of noraa's towniness

I maaaaaaybe lied when I said I didn't read any noraa posts; I did, and I didn't uh, like them much but was hoping that ydra would change my mind, but I don't wanna ask her to play if she's not feeling great

oh so are you just lying about being a cop.

i would never

debatable.

regardless, i would not have taken this slot if i thought anything she did was scummy. she was doing her classic tunnel onto town gimmick. don't want to angle shoot either but i dont think she leaves in that fashion either.

as scum, that is.

In post 676, sang froid wrote:right, but 2 things

(1) the idea of "deciding" how to read someone is uh, odd to me

and (2) a read in terms of town/scum being based on reasonableness also seems strange. town are often unreasonable, scum very often try hard to be reasonable. why does the read depend on this?

I think that I have zero thoughts in regards to (1)

As for (2) -- I have not read Bimble's iso yet. That is what I had planned to do tonight, until I ended up with meta homework instead, so it makes it hard for me to really know how I feel about their read on Roden. I will say, that Bulge seemed to be scumreading Roden for for a similar reason, and even appears to have encouraged Bimble to read him using this metric in post 420, blaze it

In post 687, Ydrasse wrote:debatable.

regardless, i would not have taken this slot if i thought anything she did was scummy. she was doing her classic tunnel onto town gimmick. don't want to angle shoot either but i dont think she leaves in that fashion either.

okay, but uh, you might've been wrong, no? either way I want bimble more today so this is maybe a conversation better had tomorrow if there is a doc and if they correctly save me from my otherwise inevitable doom

In post 691, sang froid wrote:

In post 687, Ydrasse wrote:debatable.

regardless, i would not have taken this slot if i thought anything she did was scummy. she was doing her classic tunnel onto town gimmick. don't want to angle shoot either but i dont think she leaves in that fashion either.

okay, but uh, you might've been wrong, no? either way I want bimble more today so this is maybe a conversation better had tomorrow if there is a doc and if they correctly save me from my otherwise inevitable doom

not on noraa coming off of a scumgame i was in/spectated where she played the polar opposite to here.

In post 689, Lukewarm wrote:until I ended up with meta homework instead

skip it, homework sucks and (secondhand) meta is trash anyways

For what it is worth, I read Ydra's (short) iso as townie. Specifically 356 -> 358, when she appears to be reaching out to Roden to pull him out of his own frustrations -- when scum would have benefitted for him to remained there.

In post 692, Ydrasse wrote:

In post 691, sang froid wrote:

In post 687, Ydrasse wrote:debatable.

regardless, i would not have taken this slot if i thought anything she did was scummy. she was doing her classic tunnel onto town gimmick. don't want to angle shoot either but i dont think she leaves in that fashion either.

okay, but uh, you might've been wrong, no? either way I want bimble more today so this is maybe a conversation better had tomorrow if there is a doc and if they correctly save me from my otherwise inevitable doom

not on noraa coming off of a scumgame i was in/spectated where she played the polar opposite to here.

which game was that ? forest fire?

In post 691, sang froid wrote:I want bimble more today

LLD-Deal level of want it?

In post 695, sang froid wrote:

In post 692, Ydrasse wrote:

In post 691, sang froid wrote:

In post 687, Ydrasse wrote:debatable.

regardless, i would not have taken this slot if i thought anything she did was scummy. she was doing her classic tunnel onto town gimmick. don't want to angle shoot either but i dont think she leaves in that fashion either.

okay, but uh, you might've been wrong, no? either way I want bimble more today so this is maybe a conversation better had tomorrow if there is a doc and if they correctly save me from my otherwise inevitable doom

not on noraa coming off of a scumgame i was in/spectated where she played the polar opposite to here.

which game was that ? forest fire?

ya

I can also compare her brief scumstint in Yggdrasil favorably.

I'd be interested in hearing what parts of the Noraa ISO you dislike.

In post 696, Cabd wrote:

In post 691, sang froid wrote:I want bimble more today

LLD-Deal level of want it?

I'm not at that level of confidence yet, assuming my memory is correct on what you mean

incidentally, don't elaborate, I don't think anyone benefits from you making this clearer today