Mini 1310: I Got My Eye On You Mafia (Game Over!)

[Om of the Nom]

Because I am not voting her now.
UNVOTE:

[Korlash]

This was fun... We should do this more often...

[Amrun]

oh my god

i don't even

what

[Om of the Nom]

@Korlash: Agreed. Except don't be so dickish next time :P

ALright, what we gained from this:
-I am a town cop
-Amrun is a town cop
-Korlash is either a Godfather or town (most likely V.T.)

That is 3 essentially confirmed town already.

[Amrun]

Om of the Nom, why would you investigate Korlash?

[Om of the Nom]

I already mentioned it. I figure most cops would investigate the scummier people. Also I've lost many times to a scum who appeared to be town.

[Amrun]

Yep, finished skimming the cache. I'm happy with my current reads for now.

Town (no particular order):
POW WHAM ACTION DAN
DW
iStark
Lopsy
malthusis
Otto von Clark

Null:
MB
IceGuy

Leaning Scum:
Rylai Crestfall
kondi

Scum:
Luckyjt
v2v

I'll get round to reading the current thread later today.

You read Korlash's predecessor as town and never mentioned Korlash's alignment.

@RD: No, I'm not saying Dan is def. scum. I'm just saying maybe we should look into him later. Also why did you start a wagon on me if you wanted it on someone else instead?

Why wouldn't you investigate Dan, then?

@RD: It dissapears if the only people who support it are already on the wagon. It basically means the wagon will probably never get hammered.

I would probably pick Amrun anyway. I had suspected kondi beforehand.

Or me? Or lucky, your top suspects?

Last night I investigated Korlash and recieved "Not guilty". I think I may have seen Amrun around too, probably using some "Cop" ability. There wasn't much else around, except there appeared to be an ID card reading Vanilla.

This, however, is consistent with his later claim.

[Om of the Nom]

Because I wanted to choose someone who wasn't an obvious choice.

[Amrun]

Why?

Why wasn't Korlash an obvious choice?

[Om of the Nom]

Because he was thought to be town by the majority of the people.

[Amrun]

Excellent news, mein squares!!!

Voided said I wouldn't get anything in case of an RB (making sure this means no pm at all).

Om of the Nom, did Voided tell you if your sanity was guaranteed?

p-edit: BUT WHY would you think that makes a good investigation target? Did you not read him as town yourself?

[Amrun]

Wait, your pm says Mafia or Not Mafia, but you got a Not Guilty result?

If so, can you ask if this is a mod error?

Also, please answer this.

[Voidedmafia]

YES, he did, Korlash.

Whoa, settle down kitty. If the mod doesn't want to play by his own rules regarding voting then fine, I'll take my foot out of my mouth.

I am playing by my own rules. Unless there's some hidden distinction between "Lynch: X" and "Vote: X" that I'm not aware was in my own game, there's no problem.

Though, I WOULD prefer if people used "Vote: X", all things considered.

Also, yes, that is a mod error. Should be Not Mafia. Was thinking of my newbie games where it's Not guilty instead.

[Amrun]

...

VOTE: Ice Guy

WELP

Om of the Nom is mod confirmed.

[Amrun]

I was trying to bait Om, but Voided said my sanity is guaranteed. So I'm assuming Om got the same answer.

[Om of the Nom]

I don't know if my sanity is guaranteed yet. I never got an answer.

[Voidedmafia]

Wait up, people, wait up. I'm doing too many things at once. Just hold on.

[Amrun]

I definitely wouldn't get a PM.

But Voided just confirmed that Om got a result PM, which I think makes him town. So yeah.

[Rainbowdash]

Maybe tomorrow I will understand what just went down.

[Amrun]

You won't.

You definitely won't.

[Voidedmafia]

First things first, VC. I might've missed something in the last couple pages, so double-check me.

Votecount 2.5:

IceGuy - Amrun
Amrun - IceGuy
BBmolla - ActionDan
Om of the Nom - iStark, Korlash
luckyjt - luckyjt

Not voting- Lopsy, BBmolla, Feirei, RainbowDash, Om of the Nom

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch and to no-lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2012-04-28 17:48:11), or on April 28th, 2012

ActionDan is V/LA for about 4 days

[iStark]

@Korlash: Agreed. Except don't be so dickish next time

ALright, what we gained from this:
-I am a town cop
-Amrun is a town cop
-Korlash is either a Godfather or town (most likely V.T.)

That is 3 essentially confirmed town already.

I'm very confused about argument on last page, but this pleases me. Finally we can concentrate on doing actual scum hunting instead of running in circles & tunneling *looks at Korlash*

UNVOTE:

But having said this I'm basically clueless as to who we should lynch now.
By PoE I would rather lynch Ice/lucky today.

[Amrun]

Om of the Nom is confirmed town, and our sanities are confirmed town, thus Korlahs is confirmed town (or godfather, but whatevs)

I'm obvious town by virtue of being obvious town re: claim wars that just happened.

RD is obvious town re: his claim etc.

SWEETNESS

[Voidedmafia]

And, nitty-gritty.

1.) As stated, Korlash, Lynch X and Vote X mean the same thing. UNTIL I have a game where Lynch X means something ENTIRELY different from Vote X, they will continue to mean the same thing. Also, iStark did that in his first game (newbie 1194, sadly lost in the crash), so I've had this problem before.

2.) Please stop WIFOMing the flavor. We did anticipate that it would happen, but flavor DOES NOT and SHOULD NOT affect gameplay at any level beyond enhancing your experience in the game. I write the flavor because I enjoy writing it and I want you to feel more immersed in the game, not because I want to laugh evilly as you people kill each other over semantics in this (though, should I ever run a game where this may or may not apply, don't take that as being set in stone).

3.) The RB problem should be in your Role PM. That is all I will say about that as it should be self-evident.

4.) In hindsight, that shouldn't have been something to say in-thread, but I will confirm the "Not X" debacle was from a mod error.

If there are any further questions, please tell me via PM. But, in some better news:

RBAN28 replaces BBmolla. Yes, it is an alt (I would expect people to tell that by looking at the join date), but out of respect and trust I will not disclose the actual owner unless either of us slip or the owner decides to out him or herself.

[Amrun]

Which leaves...

1. ActionDan
3. IceGuy
4. iStark
6. Lopsy
7. Luckyjt
9. CSL
11. BBmolla

Of these, CSL is almost definitely town.

iStark, luckyjt, and Lopsy are town via my reads.

Therefore, scum is in {ActionDan, IceGuy, BBmolla}.

HOT DAMN.

Game in the bag.

Lynch from that list of 3, and I'll check ~someone~ and Om will check ~someone~ and at least one of us is likely to survive, so this game is looking good right now.