Newbie 1,276 (Game over!)

[JasonWazza]

There was a possibility he was scum still, then i don't want him to possibly be let off.

There is more, it wasn't a lie.

[CityElectric]

Well, if there is, show me.

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

CityElectric (1): JasonWazza
JasonWazza (1): CityElectric
Not voting (1): HerrRudi

With

3

players alive, it takes

2

players to lynch.

Day 5 ends in (expired on 2012-11-10 18:12:51).

[HerrRudi]

Starting to think scum thought I was JK or some other power role, that's why they targeted me on N2. This is not very helpful in determining who to vote

[HerrRudi]

VOTE: CityElectric

Jason if you are scum then bravo, I just couldn't find the heart to vote you even though i had some reasons backed up.

Anyways why I voted City basically has to do with from D1 City trying to push bad lynches. This is the most heinous offense:

If those town reads are correct, then you have determined the scumteam. I've been thinking about this a bit, and every piece of evidence I have come across is either confirmation bias or paranoia, and I'm unsure how to distinguish between the two in this particular game. I am a bit uncomfortable with Johnny. I would expect a town player to be more paraniod about Cheery at this point. For that reason, in addition to the reasons I have given previously:
VOTE: Johnny

How much would you oppose a Dog-lynch right now? Because this day has been dragging on for far too long now, and, face it, lynching Dog is a good way to end it. According to me at least. I declare intent to hammer Dog. If you've got something you want to ask/do on this day, please say so. (Of course, if you're really against a Dog lynch, you should totally speak up as well.) I'll be out again for most of tomorrow, so it's not like you won't have time to do so.

On the one hand, I am fine with a Dog lynch. On the other... did that look like City/Johnny to anyone else?

Yes, Yes it did. Expressing impatience all the time is scum-venient. It happened throughout the game in very subtle ways. I've looked through this game a bunch and I can't not vote City. I can talk more about it post game.

Either way, this game is one hell of a learning experience and a lot of fun too. Well played, everyone. Sorry if I messed up!

[CityElectric]

Well done, you lost. Jason is the last scum.

[CityElectric]

Not that I didn't see it coming after Cheery's flip.

[JasonWazza]

Johnny i just won us the game, bravo

[JasonWazza]

City i am sorry you did play well, i was just stuck in a LYLO with you.

And i have to say, i am surprised i came from my scum buddy being lynched to here, i thought i would be screwed the day before today.

[JasonWazza]

Also herr, we didn't kill night 2 because no-one sent it in before the deadline, johnny was gonna send it in the next day and failed, LOLS

[HerrRudi]

Hey well played, Jason. Sorry City!

[Paschendale]

Pasch is disappoint.

[JasonWazza]

Sorry Pasch, but i had to win it for me and johnny

[Paschendale]

It was well done. I had a hard time the whole game getting really solid reads.

[JasonWazza]

I actually earlier in the game thought if one of us was gonna win it, johnny would make it the whole way and win it for us, but no town was really good.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Jason. Beautiful. Easily the best scum partner I've had in a newbie game, probably one of the best I've had on the site.

You just won us the game after a successful doc night 1, an accidental no kill night 2, me dying day 3, and 3 confirmed townies. Pat yourself on the back sir.

Edit: Yeah, the reason this game was so tough for everyone was because we all played really well. City, I'm thinking you just never recovered from that post D1.

[Cheery Dog]

Arggh! We could have had it yesterday.
And I was right the day before that the scum team would not have bussed at all.
Damn doubleguessing my reads after venrob replaced out
And m now I wish o had notstopped the possible hammer of nekpko
Though I think johnny would have got to endgame if we had lynched venrpb.

[JasonWazza]

oh johnny you cool with posting our QT?

[JohnnyFarrar]

s'fine. It's mostly me posting tips and forgetting to do important things.

[JasonWazza]

Scum QT

Note the plan for N2:
Kill pasch
rolecop city

Had that happened i think we would have been in a much better position.

Been better to have pushed hard in that case lols.

[nhammen]

Well, congrats. Everyone in this game played really well. It made finding scum very difficult, but it also made the game quite fun.

[HerrRudi]

Yeah scum team, you were fantastic. We got lucky that we caught you so early Johnny and Jason was an all-star

Lesson learned: discussing optimal play, no matter how fervently, is never gonna be a town tell again

[JasonWazza]

Kills after Johnny was gone:

N3: Pretty obv doc kill
N4: nhammen said he had a set in rock read that city was scum, so i figured it wouldn't be prudent to keep him alive, not to mention that herr wasn't fully cleared after a lot of debate

P-Edit: Lols

[JohnnyFarrar]

Good towntells are hard to find and often subtle.

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

CityElectric (2): JasonWazza, HerrRudi

JasonWazza (1): CityElectric

With

3

players alive, it takes

2

players to lynch.

JasonWazza got HerrRudi's help to hang CityElectric... then proceeded to slit HerrRudi's throat. Rome belonged to the Mafia now.

CityElectric, who was a

vanilla townie

, has been lynched on Day 5.
HerrRudi, who was a

vanilla townie

, has had his throat slit in the endgame.
JasonWazza, who was a

Mafia goon

, has survived the endgame.

CONGRATULATIONS JASONWAZZA AND JOHNNYFARRAR; YOU, THE MAFIA, HAVE WON!

Dead thread

NIGHT 1 ACTIONS

Paschendale protects nhammen.
JohnnyFarrar investigates Cheery Dog as a vanilla townie.
JohnnyFarrar attempts to kill nhammen, but nhammen gets protected.

NIGHT 2 ACTIONS

Paschendale protects HerrRudi.

NIGHT 3 ACTIONS

Paschendale protects nhammen.
JasonWazza kills Paschendale.

NIGHT 4 ACTIONS

JasonWazza kills nhammen.