was there any actual reason behind this list, btw? it looks like you just chose the top 5 posters outside of kaze and the ICvarsoon wrote:One of Lush Life, GCBC(previously morph), Kise, Pie, and zMuffin is scum, if not more. Just lynch that list and we'll be gold.
yeah; skip the first 10 pagesmc wrote:I am going first and will try to have observations and analysis from the first 10 pages. Anything I should know going into this?
Yes. It was a Zoroaster game, IIRC. Or was it an AngryPigeon... I forgot But I'm pretty sure they were there.In post 388, Remembrance wrote:
@Tsukasa, I like calling myself town as town. It's sort of bizzare, but I enjoy it. I'm town, I'm town.It's like I'm saying "hey guys, I'm over here". I'm not sure where you've played with me(rather, I do but I don't want you to replace out), but If it was a while ago I know I had no scum games where I called myself town as scum. it was a bit of a trust tell at the time. I one time denied being recruited as cult though.
No you are not. But I thought shit was gonna go down on me. Why didn't you?In post 402, dramonic wrote:Im not voting tsukasa am I?In post 383, pieguyn wrote:no I mean thishere you say Kise who is voting me, probably bc I'm stuck in RVS, is wasting his voteIn post 172, dramonic wrote:@kise: dat waste of a vote :/here you tell tTsukasa to get out of RVS. if staying in RVS is bad then why is the person voting me who's doing that same thing wasting his vote?In post 209, dramonic wrote:Ftr tsukasa better get out of rvs or shit will go down
You are trying to abuse a meta you and Tsu know about. Being self-aware of only calling yourself town as town? Yeah I've seen scum do that.In post 388, Remembrance wrote:@Tsukasa, I like calling myself town as town. It's sort of bizzare, but I enjoy it. I'm town, I'm town.
One thing I hate are trust tells.In post 411, Kagami wrote:^might have a point here. If rem is telling the truth, it would be a trust tell, no?In post 407, Kise wrote:...You are trying to abuse a meta you and Tsu know about. Being self-aware of only calling yourself town as town? Yeah I've seen scum do that.In post 388, Remembrance wrote:@Tsukasa, I like calling myself town as town. It's sort of bizzare, but I enjoy it. I'm town, I'm town.
Unvote;
Vote Remembrance
Are you always this unreadable early game? ;w;In post 424, Varsoon wrote:Ctrl+F: VarsoonIn post 26, Remembrance wrote:Time travel, it is the year 2014.
@Lushlife what is it like?
VOTE: Varsoon
2 results: A vote on me and a joke about what I'm about to do
I'm town, confirming that now.
Also, OMGUS, BITCHES
VOTE: Remembrance-slot
In post 441, bubbajack8 wrote:I don't consider my play scummy. Maybe you should except MY play is MY fucking play and move on.
Majiffy. Aren't you just abusing your "I am Majiffy" Status?
No it doesn't. It's the girl's INTUITION that rules her. But never her hormones.In post 476, Jaqen Hghar wrote:A girl's hormones rule her thoughts. That which is petty is best left ignored, yet every game a girl loses herself to the most innocuous of japes. Those buttons will continue to be pushed for as long as a girl allows them to be pushed.In post 327, morph the cat wrote:So, you wanna bitch at us and take potshots at us? Fine. Aim at me. I'm right here, be as much of an asshat as you want towards me.
Are you rolefishing?In post 481, Kise wrote:If I'm cop or vig, I will target bubba tonight. You have my word.
/offIn post 500, Yukari Yakumo wrote:
Wait who's the replacement?In post 562, Kagami wrote:Still town every game. Rem's replacement probably proves her town.In post 552, Kazekirimaru wrote:Lack of nothing?In post 530, Mac wrote: The severe lack of nothing in Kagami's ISO is alarming. I think the vote on Remembrance is bullshit given Rem can't defend himself. And poor, considering it doesn't really make sense.I do see your points and agree. I'm wary of her, too. Mainly because I don't know what scum-Kagami looks like yet. This might be her scum debut.
Xenoblade AGAIN?In post 610, Lush Life wrote:Read Xenoblade for the scum version of this trope, btw.In post 608, Lush Life wrote:I do - being tunneled on when town by someone who she has a history with.
Just so I understand everything before I get into this,In post 582, Jaqen Hghar wrote:A man will break this down a little more thoroughly for MuffinIn post 302, morph the cat wrote:My initial thought was that town was more likely to skip over the posts form the modwhereas scum was more likely to read it thoroughly, but that theory was clearly flawed.You all ought to be ashamed of yourselves.
-cabd believes town would be more apt to skip the mod opening sequence
-cabd believes scum would be more likely to read the opening lest they miss something that could screw up
their game
-cabd says "You all ought to be ashamed of yourselves."
-as cabd believes town less likely read the opening, he would have nothing to be ashmed of for town missing
the IC
-as cabd believes scum should have read the opening, and aparently didn't, the statement of shame can only
be applied to those he's shaming. The scum.
-this leads a resonable man to ponder,why wold a town cabd be motivated to help scum?
-since cabd took the chance to do this ITT, it further implies the lack of day talk.
Wait... Is he Rem's Replacement or something?In post 624, pieguyn wrote:holy wow I completely forgot you replaced inIn post 619, GoodCop_BadCop wrote:So in case anyone was confused about where the scum on my wagon is, it's pieguy for starters.
BUT I WORKED SO LONG ON DOING THIS ;w;In post 631, zMuffinMan wrote:i refuse to read those fucking giant quote walls. go fuck yourself if you're planning to do any more of them
Yeah dude I don't see how a completed game with the same players where we all know their alignment (and are acting somewhat differently from here!) could possibly help.In post 703, Tsukasa wrote:Xenoblade AGAIN?
It's like... The whole mafia universe just switched it's center to xenoblade.
If you're basing on xenoblade again
It's not going to help.
And if it's not going to help, then that means you're not to help town
Which means, you're not town.
I am curious - how can you tell that this is scum-Rem subverting his self-meta rather than town-Rem adhering to it? Cause being self-aware of his meta doesn't necessitate that he be scum when he bring it up, considering that both alignments wish to be read as town.In post 407, Kise wrote:You are trying to abuse a meta you and Tsu know about. Being self-aware of only calling yourself town as town? Yeah I've seen scum do that.
Unvote;
Vote Remembrance
for now, I'll townread Tsukasa. he's being proactive early and there's also a ton of defiance in his posts that I tend to attribute more to a town mindset. I especially noticed it here
I don't like the "for now" in the first post, because it looks to me like he's shaping up change his mind later on in the game, OR doesn't have confidence in his read. If it's the former, he's probably scum and if it's the latter, why the fuck is Tsu in his townbloc? Lush Life I wouldn't mind being in the townbloc - but he quotes the "townslip" which is totally bullshit because the townslip wasI'll also townread Lush Life for being obvtown and legitimately townslipping re: Jaqen. also bubbajack for being proactive early. I'll also townread Kaze bc I can't read him for shit and I tend to pick up on a lot of shit from him and I get the feeling if he was scum he'd be more careful and I'd pick up less
morph's frustration re: mollie feels town but idk if they'd get frustrated as scum plus I'm paranoid as fuck about them for practically no reason =.=
townblock: me, Kaze, Lush Life, bubbajack, Jaqen, Tsukasa
I mean I'm pretty sure pie is pretty fucking logical in games, yet this is what he comes up with? Not pushing his own reads, and pushing morph based on a slipIn post 617, pieguyn wrote:vote: morph
still not sure about the "slip" but oh well I'll bite for now
Shweetums, you know I wouldn't town you for a while. I was being pieguy for a second - if you'd read the post, you would've understand. Why didn't you read the whole post?muffin wrote:interesting. i thought you'd be a lot more wary about putting me anywhere near your town reads, not the first person you call town
Hey V, you're town but hoping one from a list of five is scum is not a good return.In post 694, Varsoon wrote:Kaze, I feel like you're the only dude who knows I'm here so I'm gonna just chat with you and stuff.
I don't have any good reads. I haven't been giving this game much attention. If I rolled scum, this wouldn't be a problem, since, y'know, this game can ramble on without me.
Pieguyn is not on the usual town ball. That's important to notice.
Then again, neither am I.
One of Lush Life, GCBC(previously morph), Kise, Pie, and zMuffin is scum, if not more. Just lynch that list and we'll be gold.
Easy fuckin' peasy.
VOTE: GoodCopBadCop
*cough* Bullshit. I've made it clear I'm not voting right now. I'm about to ISO everyone in a minute, then I'll most likely vote.In post 655, Kazekirimaru wrote: pieguy, Remembrance, bubba, Kagami. How's that sound? Those are my scumreads. And you know what? Many of them all decided it'd be a novel idea to vote Cabd within a span of like three fucking hours! Dat wagon. How's that for you, eh?
My words to you.In post 662, Kazekirimaru wrote:The answer is yes. I suggest you find the time to read those aforementioned posts, because I don't intend to stop making them.
That's part of it. I also had some questions to the mod to make sure I was within the rules.In post 672, Jaqen Hghar wrote:A man wonders why town would need a 'rough draft' of a claim?? A man thinks town just need a role pm to paraphrase.In post 609, bubbajack8 wrote:Patience my young padawan. I'm not as pissed off about to do stupid things right now. I have a rough draft saved of the claim though.
I respond to everything as I see fit. It's my way of playing. I do not use spoilers unless for cases because I don't want people skimming over it. I'm not trying to create a well built case. That's not my purpose. My purpose is to make my stance and opinions known, not to build a case.In post 689, Katarina LeBlanc wrote:Also yeah, fuck your giant quote walls and shit. It's so easy to condense a point without being a fool about it. Or use spoiler tags so I don't immediately lose will to read it. Most of the reactions you have don't even contribute to the actual read, you're just adding more to make it seem like you have a well built case on someone when you're just kind of trying your best to disregard their posts by giving horrible replies that don't contribute or just plain piss them off. It's working too!In post 638, bubbajack8 wrote:I warned you pre game it was my thing.In post 631, zMuffinMan wrote:i refuse to read those fucking giant quote walls. go fuck yourself if you're planning to do any more of them
If I somehow tarnished a friendship I am sorry. I would like to know why you want Kise gone.In post 689, Katarina LeBlanc wrote: I still want Kise gone, but bubbajack is much worse. I'd be happy with either of them gone. At least calm dis thread down a bit. Friendships have already been tarnished
Did Kaze contradict himself in the last game as well? Also if you don't mind me giving an out of game suggestion, I think you shouldn't let others' reads on a player discourage you from having an opposite read. No need to have a big 1v1 with Kaze. If you think he said something scummy, ask him about it to find the motive, inspiration, etc.In post 613, pieguyn wrote:ok let me try to explain thisIn post 406, Kise wrote:I don't see how Kaze's "sour" attitude & contradictions make him a townread for you. Isn't that how we catch scum, when their logic is flawed, when they lie, when their inconsistent, etc.?
Sakura Hana is a friend of mine and we play a lot. whenever she's town, everything she posts pings me and we always get in 1v1s a lot. however, when she's scum her posts are like 9000x more logical and I hardly pick up on anything from her. the last time I played with Kaze (AA:MFA), we got in a massive 1v1 and he was town. this feels like it could end up being the same thing, plus he's being townread by a lot of people. I get lost enough in large games as it is and the last thing I need is to do a 1v1 that probably won't get me anywhere. also, in AA:MFA everyone besides me read him as town, so I kind of feel like trusting the majority on him is better in this scenario. I can revisit the possibility he's scum later but it's prob better to write him off as town and see what happens atm
nah they're both in an ongoing
NP, we can lynch pie.In post 694, Varsoon wrote:Pieguyn is not on the usual town ball. That's important to notice.
Then again, neither am I.
Never played with Rem but the fact still remains he wants town status > finding scum.In post 706, Lush Life wrote:I am curious - how can you tell that this is scum-Rem subverting his self-meta rather than town-Rem adhering to it? Cause being self-aware of his meta doesn't necessitate that he be scum when he bring it up, considering that both alignments wish to be read as town.In post 407, Kise wrote:You are trying to abuse a meta you and Tsu know about. Being self-aware of only calling yourself town as town? Yeah I've seen scum do that.
Unvote;
Vote Remembrance
How did you get rolefishing from me saying what I would do if I'm the cop or vig?In post 703, Tsukasa wrote:Are you rolefishing?
Are you?
Please tell me you are.
It'd be easier if you do.
Not really sure what you're saying in this post but I'll kindly disagree that GCBC is town.In post 713, Mac wrote:morph's posting about the townslip made sense because there's no way scum would all post 3 in a row questioning cabd have an IC they all missed on his reads list. especially if he's hard townreading Lush/maybe kaze. move along, thank you.
A man hopes you and Kagami end up on the right wagon by day end.In post 715, Kise wrote:Not really sure what you're saying in this post but I'll kindly disagree that GCBC is town.In post 713, Mac wrote:morph's posting about the townslip made sense because there's no way scum would all post 3 in a row questioning cabd have an IC they all missed on his reads list. especially if he's hard townreading Lush/maybe kaze. move along, thank you.
Immediately a horrible scumlist.In post 712, Kise wrote:NEW!
Katarina:
"Kise don't wanna argue. I'm not arguing either, nor am I contributing. But hey I still think Kise should be the lynch today lol kawaii desu uguu"
A man is being hypocritical as fuck.In post 718, Jaqen Hghar wrote:A man hopes you and Kagami end up on the right wagon by day end.In post 715, Kise wrote:Not really sure what you're saying in this post but I'll kindly disagree that GCBC is town.In post 713, Mac wrote:morph's posting about the townslip made sense because there's no way scum would all post 3 in a row questioning cabd have an IC they all missed on his reads list. especially if he's hard townreading Lush/maybe kaze. move along, thank you.
