Flipping Awesome
- I've only seen this level of scummitment from a small handful of people who are playing their first game on this site, and Adel (please don't be Adel). We feel slighted that we are not on their Town lists.
Zdenek
- This seems like a pretty obvious one to me. If not, both halves of this puppy have meta coming out our long ears that points this way. If that doesn't make it obvious to you then I don't see why; plenty of people are saying "this person is actually Town because
meta!
" or other handwaving and we see no reason to be left uninvited to the party.
Cerulean
- Presented as Town without elaboration. -tyhalf continues to insist this is the case and doing more with it would involve :effort: that I don't care to expend.
sangres
- Their posts are better than I remembered. ffery is doing a pretty good job holding the slot down.
ChannelDelibird
- Not a solid Town read, but good enough.
Shadoweh
- Reasons for and against already stated. Bickering with the -tyhalf eventually resulted in her getting put up here - her read being the one keeping the 'weh up so high. Seriously, though, lrn2puppy - When I throw you a ball to play with, the optimal response is not to
look forlornly at it like I've coated it with medicine.
Venmar
- Yeah sorry Empire. This is either some of the better fake RAGE I've seen or you're getting hung up over someone who doesn't make the perfect logical sense you seem to be asking for.
Nobody Special
- On another look, not the solid read I remember, but not anything I would class as particularly unusual for NS.
Lady Lambdadelta
- Pragmatically speaking there aren't many good reasons to say that she's Town, and I'm not up for trusting a smiling cat, but she's that
friendly, benign, non-frustrating
kind of null that's so much better than the actively unfriendly, bad-voting, frustrating kind of null. (and of course we know she knows that, etc.)
(9/17)
(\U^_^U(\ (\U^_^U(\ (\U^_^U(\ ~intermission for
puppy parade - would not lynch above this line~ /)U^_^U/) /)U^_^U/) /)U^_^U/)
(8/17)
Katsuki
- I have no compelling reason to go either way with Katsuki, which is probably just how he likes it and actually better than how I like it.
chamber
- So, if you really, really,
really
don't want to be voting Shadoweh... why
are
you? Normally when you're pursuing someone you don't literally plead with them to make this one post make sense. Especially since I actually
can
see someone posting an I.Child as a different color in a vote count. Nonetheless, would hold final judgment until later in the game.
|
kaneykowsbets
- Voting for us is a scumtell. Other than that, etc.
|
Tim Howard
- Let the record reflect that the only reason the Tim Howard wagon died was because I am gullible and buy into the reads of some kinda Town-looking lurker who refuses to explain how he can get his read from five posts. I mean look at this.
Tim Howard 375 wrote:Zdenek is trying to be all town-leadery, from my pov, and I don't think he has the skill to do it, so it strikes me as odd.
Tim Howard 381 wrote:You've not got us on your Town-pile, and that doesn't bode well for your alignment either! Although, Quadz is pretty insistent you're town, and given he's probably played with you more recently, I'm inclined to agree with him.
On behalf of everyone in this game I would kindly request that quadz do literally all the posting from this point on. With all that said, just barely enough of their posting has seemed unintentionally genuine enough to warrant this spot.
Nero Cain
- You asked for it; I read your posts. Nothing looks particularly Townish and your scumlist just happens to match up with all the easy targets (Katsuki, sangres, Shadoweh, Venmar). It's pretty obvious that you and Venmar have related roles but it's clearly not something that reflects on your alignment, so you can take your spot on the rope list.
Untrod Tripod
- Zdenek and Katsuki defenses are nice but not enough to give a Town read. Votes are bad all the way down - even the Tim Howard vote because of the "good cop bad cop" explanation (see
post 415). The discrediting of our slot in particular is actively anti-Town (neither pro-Town nor alignment-unrelated like generic complaining).
xRECKONERx
- Reasons already given (backpedaling, convenient votes, what exactly
was
that Zdenek/Shadoweh reasoning supposed to be anyway, etc.). Placed this high because Tammy said so.
Plum
- Someone appears to have taken our fruit and replaced it with a wax version of itself. It's a decent representation of someone who has an idea of how to look generically Town, but forgot to say or do anything that's actually indicative of a Town alignment. I can tell she's looking hard at our list because she's referred to it twice and is generally assuming that that's how the game state
is
without actually holding reads inside it or merely considering it the opinions of Our Canine Majesties until she later thought about the hole she's getting into. And, seriously, if you're going to try to "do your part" to make the game make more sense, starting a wagon on some easy target when there are already votes on like half the player list isn't actually going to cut it. CAVEAT: If Shadoweh actually has something useful to say about Plum then
hurry the eff up
already; I've seriously debated the joys of massclaiming at this point and considering you're the largest wagon I'm not sure how much it would hurt you.
---
Now if we could kindly break this godawful ten-people-who-have-votes stalemate it would be rather wonderful.
