Mafiascum.net

Why is everybody downplaying me like I haven't made this game much easier than it would have been without me here

you haven't shown the slightest interest in scumhunting and have clogged up the game with a lot of useless posts, like that one

In post 698, Parama wrote:

In post 689, Dunnstral wrote:I'll copy my thoughts over just for you:
{reads list that totally misses the point of my question}

i'm not asking for this. i'm asking for why sick is your top scumread in the guys and why i'm your #2 in the girls.

I townread dave

poe down to dig and sickofit. It's more likely sickofit than dig. I don't want to lynch dig because that's lynching my second scumread in gents and a townread in ladies

Asking me to explain my reasoning is a weird thing to do regardless

In post 701, Parama wrote:you haven't shown the slightest interest in scumhunting

Dare I say I've scumhunted the most in this game

you're still missing the "why".

i know it's hard but you gotta do it bro

Parama wrote:you're still missing the "why".

i know it's hard but you gotta do it bro

prod dodge

(expired on 2016-12-01 23:03:25)

Because I think he's scum.
And I don't think Dave is scum.

The way I see it, Sickofit has a roughly 65% chance of being mafia, while DIG is at 25% and dave is at 10%

None of that answers your question though

I scumread all these posts:

I realize that I've quoted a bunch of posts without any commentary of my own. Just know that it is hard to put my reads into words but I still have strong townreads at the moment

Note an unsubstantiated townread on mariaR as well, which really means nothing since he was pushing our lynch anyway

The gamma vote looks more like bussing than anything else. This is further theorized from Gamma completely ignoring sickofit and his vote

i appreciate that you're trying

You should appreciate that I'm obvious town and sacrifice yourself

I'm ignoring it because I'd rather focus on the more substantative votes.

So you don't care that sickofit has no substance?

In post 710, Dunnstral wrote:So you don't care that sickofit has no substance?

They're a null read because of that.

Alright, I'm here. Also wow you all post a lot...

I'm going to go through my reads on each person.

Ladies:

Human Sequencer:

407 looks town to me. I feel like scum is more worried about who is proposing to who in order to look natural as they avoid pairing with each other, and town is more likely to miss the fact that two of the proposals went to the same person.

636 is also town I think. At this point it would be easy enough to transition to sick and get an easy (and apparently agreeable) lynch there, but she keeps pushing for a different read which seems super unnecessary if she is scum (also at this point it looks like if we were to go for gamma/dave first and they both flipped town, sickofit/parama would probably be the next lynch anyway so I doubt human sequencer is partners with sickofit).

In general the style seems to be pretty good to me (although this is probably the easiest thing to fake). Very interactive, and very focused on making sure there is a strong scum hunting presence within the thread.

She also seems to say things that sound kind of risky that I wouldn't expect from scum, like pushing for a lynch on dave saying that he's not an asset even if he's town so it's not a loss (when its pretty easy for someone to claim this is scum and that mislynches are always bad), and repeating the line 4 times (which was sure to bring scrutiny to herself which I assume is something scum tries to avoid.

In case you missed something, I read human sequencer as: TOWN.

Gamma:

I don't like 323. Saying "ftr I'm not a fan of Vedith's push on DIG rn." doesn't really help anything. If you're not a fan, you should discuss the reasons why not. Also why do you want this on record so much? Are you afraid I might get lynched and you want to be on record having the right read on me?

404 gives me a slight town read. Waiting for a second invitation from Dave is probably not worth reading into, since it's probably the better way to play the game, but 404 seems rather carefree about the pairings (although they were pretty well determined at this point, since neither Dave or I was going to invite Vedith, and Human sequencer and I were each other's top picks).

525 I don't really like. It seems like the sort of scum hunting that can be claimed as scum hunting later, but really nobody is going to pay any attention to. There's so much non-substantive stuff in this thread that pointing out one post in particular is sort of ridiculous.

Overall, I would be fine with lynching this slot.

MariaR:

75 says "dislike para's push on dave more to come," but apart from defending her view that it was in fact a push, "more" never actually came.

Don't really understand the point of 336. You were also okay with Vedith's death, right?

365 I don't like, I thought Gamma's post was completely fair, and Maria just discredits without any explanation.

Overall, I don't really see many strong reads coming out compared to the massive number of posts.

This is probably my top pick for lady scum.

Parama:

No posts in particular stand out, but in general, Parama seems to be doing a lot of scum hunting (and staying on track pretty well).

I do like the fact that she continued to push on Vedith even after it was evident that Vedith would be the pre-dance lynch. I feel like scum would have probably backed off at least a bit.

Overall, this is my second pick for town from ladies.

Gentleman:

Dave:

473 is ridiculous. We know there's only one lady scum, why would you want two left out?

A lot of the posts are actually ridiculous. Pretty much nothing seems to be a read backed by a reason. Also even if there was, it doesn't seem like its possible for those reasons to be out of this thread since Dave doesn't seem to have read/understood much of it.

I don't like this slot, but really there's not much to read unfortunately.

Dunn:

Some wise words of advice in 25.

Seems like he's trying way too hard to be in control of everyone's thoughts and actions.

Does seem like he's way more interested in how seriously people take his reads than how much people like him.

His reads don't seem to have changed over the course of the game, which I find sort of unlikely.

Overall, kind of null on him, leaning towards town though.

Sickofit:

Wow, the gentleman are harder to read than the ladies.

Overall nothing here really stood out to me, and I don't really want Parama lynched, so I'm going to give him a pass for now.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

My top pick for the lynch would have to be VOTE: gamma/dave but I would also be willing to go Maria/Dunn.

(Sorry Parama (and everyone else) about the wall of text, but I don't like posting a bunch in a row, and I had a lot to say)

Ewwwww

323 was me trying to segway into another opinion, that's why it says ftr

you see nothing wrong with gamma's 365...
VOTE: Dig/Human
If dunn has a partner in Ladies it's Human if human flips town so is dunn
if human flips scum so is dunn to me
dig can just die regardless of what side he's on for me.

Yeah we're not lynching that.

No matter how bad dig is

In post 717, Dunnstral wrote:Yeah we're not lynching that.

No matter how bad dig is

BUT IT'S SO BAD

actually he's not that bad sorry was preemptive

Trust me maria's town

Why are you "giving sickofit a pass"

maria that's absolutely awful reasoning tbh. and probably the worst pairing to lynch rn

He's not unreasonable but he has only really given big walls of reads and the plan and not much other interaction

PsychoticDave, what is your read on Gamma right now?

Hm.
I can see HS having convinced DIG to give Sick a pass in the Lover PT.

In post 720, Parama wrote:maria that's absolutely awful reasoning tbh. and probably the worst pairing to lynch rn

you think it's awful I think it's good to me *shrug*