Enter, EspeciallyTheLies, town doctor, ArthurConyl, town cop
, and the
vanilla townies: CheekyTeeky, Farren, Mitillos, Ph0enix, Aloratom, Pine
have won Newbie 1973 | Mountain!
PenguinPower, mafia roleblocker
and
chazary, mafia goon
have been defeated. Congratulations!
Both town PRs should have claimed earlier but Ph0enix and Aloratom did a good job of recognising each other as town in LYLO. We had a lot of great newer players this game. I hope all of you enjoyed yourselves and will stick around.
[/area]
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:33 am
by Plotinus
Game Events
Links
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:35 am
by Plotinus
This thread is now open for postgame discussion. You can post here even if you were dead and even if you didn't play.
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:37 am
by RadiantCowbells
dang
i thought PP townclaimed in twilight
i really did think he was the scums until then :v
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:37 am
by PenguinPower
RC - I always troll as scum in twilight. You know this.
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:38 am
by PenguinPower
In post 701, Plotinus wrote:We had a lot of great newer players this game. I hope all of you enjoyed yourselves and will stick around.
I hadn't played in a while on a forum (which I wanted to do, cause, in my opinion, playing on a forum is the best Mafia experience, as opposed to playing IRL, for example) and I stumbled upon this site.
Last, but not least, thank you, Plotinus, for the great modding <3
And thanks for a great game everyone. And happy new year!
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 1:41 pm
by Mitillos
I made most of my comments in the dead thread already.
Everything I said about Farren basically also goes for Ph0enix. Good play, all around.
@Penguin: I believe that you should have killed Ph0enix overnight, instead. I think I would have been a better choice for taking to LyLo, this game, as there would have been a higher chance of me making the wrong choice in the end. If you had done this and also not engaged in active lurking through most of the game, you likely would have given yourself a victory here.
Alora was unlucky enough to be put in a cursed slot that had been all lurk until he took it. He started doing a good job redeeming his slot; it's just unfortunate that he only had a short time to do this.
Well, I found out I apparently don't know what "bring around" means. I guess you are referring to why I ended up voting PP. To be honest, my job would have been far more difficult (cause there were stuff that bugged me about you both) had it not been for PP's opening vote. I didn't see a reason for it whatsoever (provided PP was town, that is; I explained in a previous post why I find the vote only makes sense for PP to make if he's scum).
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 1:55 pm
by PenguinPower
In post 717, Mitillos wrote:@Penguin: I believe that you should have killed Ph0enix overnight, instead. I think I would have been a better choice for taking to LyLo, this game, as there would have been a higher chance of me making the wrong choice in the end. If you had done this and also not engaged in active lurking through most of the game, you likely would have given yourself a victory here.
Maybe - You had relatively few posts and I couldn't really know where you stood on me, plus I thought I could push an empty slot better than I did today, especially with Alora's lack of voting and read on Ph0enix. I wasn't active lurking btw - the holidays and Team Mafia stuff really did pull me away more than I wanted.
The plan was always to win in 3v2 but that got messed up by Arthur being the cop - the one person we had to have
Well, I found out I apparently don't know what "bring around" means. I guess you are referring to why I ended up voting PP. To be honest, my job would have been far more difficult (cause there were stuff that bugged me about you both) had it not been for PP's opening vote. I didn't see a reason for it whatsoever (provided PP was town, that is; I explained in a previous post why I find the vote only makes sense for PP to make if he's scum).
I would have made the same vote as town in that situation (with the same read strength).
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 2:17 pm
by Mitillos
Fair enough.
Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 2:18 pm
by ArthurConyl
Great job at the end guys.
This being my first game on Mafiascum, any advice for playing better next time?