Mafiascum.net

Sure, sure, but let's pretend for a moment that I'm not going to be modkilled. Who's your top town rn?

In post 699, Luca Blight wrote:Even if you’re Town you have to be modkilled, you realise that right?

You can’t do something that would result in a modkilled as one alignment and not another. Either way the game is compromised.

I actually agree. I had reported the post but he has compromised his slot. If scum mod has to modkill. If town, mod confirms he’s town by not modkilling

Mod does not have to modkill someone that breaks no site rules. Claiming scum is neither against the specific rules of the game nor site rules.

Conversely, discussing moderator actions is against the rules of the game.

In post 1, gobbledygook wrote:4. Rule violations will be dealt with based upon severity at the sole discretion of the Mod or in conjuction with the relevant Listmod.
5. Any situation not specifically covered in the above Rules is subject to Mod discretion and will be handled as the Mod sees fit to address. Live with it.

So, you can continue discussing a moderator action that is not actually going to occur, or you can play according to the game rules and not discuss moderator actions.

In post 701, Wimpy wrote:I actually agree. I had reported the post but he has compromised his slot. If scum mod has to modkill. If town, mod confirms he’s town by not modkilling

this is probably also town but an incredibly bad post

As Obvs said, there's no rule about claiming scum that I see. And if there was, I wouldn't consider that to be one since it's obviously not serious and a part of his theme that he's used in every game.

Onward with thee lynch!

Ame can you snapshot your Egix case for me?

I didn’t realise he does this every game. He probably won’t be modkilled, then, but I still believe claiming scum should be against the rules unless you are in an unwinnable situation, or are posting in twilight having been hammered.

I agree with Ame’s OS/Egix theory.

VOTE: ObviousScum

In post 700, ObviousScum wrote:Sure, sure, but let's pretend for a moment that I'm not going to be modkilled. Who's your top town rn?

Ame and Insomnia.

Why insomnia?

Is there any consensus on which of the two kills was likely vig vs scum?

@Obvs https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p11531677

Alch was vigged. Chara was killed for fake crumbing PR.

ok that changes things for me a little bit, thanks

Ame do you have a backup scum?

I think you're 0/2 actually so maybe could I just get a readslist from you?

SKs aren't allowed in 13p norms so Vig is IC right?

I don't have any back ups, no. I have a town read on everyone else. Your best option would be to push for profii or Macabre. Maybe wimpy? Insomnia and Luca are more or less cleared from the Aaron wagon. Honestly you replaced into quite a tough spot. (Also thank you for doing so and putting in the effort. It would have been cool to see you play from the beginning).

The vig is not claimed right?

Why are Looker and ELA cleared?

In post 715, Ame wrote:Maybe wimpy?

Don’t be throwing me to the wolves. I’m town and everyone should know that.

VOTE: ELA
Wimpy where are you on this slot?

Luca / egix / looker towncore
Wimpy -- 701 more likely to come from town imo
Birb-- terrible iso but aaron's early townread looks like a transparent pocket attempt at a glance. Not fully exculpatory tho
ame -- still thinking about this


Profii / insomnia / ela

I am absent reasons to townread these three atm so if anyone wants to enlighten me I'm all ears

Part of me thought of a reason profii might be scum but its probably too dumb to put into words lol

I am the most town

I don’t think you believe that

I am scum here

Scum also want to town read me, they can’t help it

Stop lying to yourself

Id uh...like to apologize for being more absent than usual alot has happened irl and ive been in just a very bad situation thats only been getting worse.

But anyway why would town ever advocate a modkill in any situation. If the person is town we risk killing 2 town in one day. If they are scum we lose information that a lynch would have gained.

Though scum also wouldnt push a modkill if it was their partner.