Mafiascum.net

Hey folks, quick skill testing question

do you think scum get to see what the mechanics of the 2 artefacts they have to choose between are before they ship them?

If yes, is there any downside to me hardclaimign the full effects of the artefact?

If no, is it worth hardclaiming it in certain circumstances anyway

It is unclear but I am leaning towards them not knowing.

I would ~assume~ they did get to see the mechanics of both artifacts, and would ~hope~ they had to make the choice blind.

And from there, I'd decide whether to hardclaim based on if I think the value of town having the info outweighs the downside of scum knowing.

With a mason buddy, it seems like the full info gets to town by day 2 either way? So, weigh the value of knowing now vs knowing tomorrow, too?

I don't think you should claim what the artifact does. I can think of better plays to make

Glorified prod dodge. Most likely won't get a chance to post again until tomorrow evening.

Kinda read some bits here and there in between grading today, but not really.

Don't have a read on Dunnstral. Gonna be a bit more careful with that read after popcorn.

Do like some of the bell posts I read today.

Agree with 702's take on the artifact.

Oh Prism - I like mechanics, but I do not always really understand mechanics or the best ways to use some roles, especially ones I'm unfamiliar with.

okay tomorrow tomorrow

Rules are pretty clear they don't know what an artifact does until they receive it.
Being given a choice among two is not likely to meet the definition of 'received'
My guess remains that the scum team had to wiki the two artifacts and decided based on speculation on what they do which would be best to pick.
It's also more fun that way and fits the flavor.

In post 697, sangres wrote:Pooky, you worry me.

I shouldn't worry you unless you're scum

in which case

you should be very very worried.

but not really cuz I am a lazy bear who is going to take it easy in his semi-retired old age

What Bell said, really doubt they get more info about the artifacts than we do.

Keeping the mechanics of your artifact secret vs. making it public is very dependent on the artifact itself and I don't think anyone else can make that call.

The "factions" casting was also weird given that most of the LLD voters were more anti-Prism than pro-LLD, but there was plenty of crossover between the "factions" to begin with. Me being anti-LLD lasted like 40 real time minutes. We're also spread pretty evenly on Dunnstral, I'm skeptical but neither me nor LLD are voting there.

I don't think Bell is scum and I guess thinking in groupings can be a tool but seeing clearly is important.

In post 174, Dunnstral wrote:The townreads on Sangres feel weird

Dunn I've asked before -- please elaborate.

Specifically, whose reads, and what makes those reads weird?

-------------------

Bell wrote:Rules are pretty clear they don't know what an artifact does until they receive it.
Being given a choice among two is not likely to meet the definition of 'received'
My guess remains that the scum team had to wiki the two artifacts and decided based on speculation on what they do which would be best to pick.
It's also more fun that way and fits the flavor.

Thinking more on this game as possibly being in part an evolution of the midscummer night's dream game, scum knew no more than town did about the three dreams presented as choices each day. Maybe the artifact design of this game doesn't change that.

This speculation is probably just about worth what you paid for it.

PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 697, sangres wrote:Pooky, you worry me.

I shouldn't worry you unless you're scum

in which case

you should be very very worried.

but not really cuz I am a lazy bear who is going to take it easy in his semi-retired old age

I'm going to need more from even a semi-retired bear to have a comfortable read.

In post 709, sangres wrote:I'm going to need more from even a semi-retired bear to have a comfortable read.

I'm waiting for our delinquents to post b4 I present my hero solve

and by hero solve I just mean shamelessly sheeping LLD

In post 225, Tammy wrote:Except, the sculpture that Prism photoshopped their laptop into is Myron's Discobolus, an ancient Greek sculpture of a discus thrower.

It's not Atlas.

nerd

In post 303, Tammy wrote:Not sure what to think of titus and interaction with math bland there :/

could you talk to me about this?

i'm townreading too many people and i liked titus's interaction there but titus could very well be a weak spot.

In post 359, Tammy wrote:Oh nachgres do you have any thoughts on spiffeh?

pretty firmly townreading him at this point in the read.

In post 709, sangres wrote:

In post 174, Dunnstral wrote:The townreads on Sangres feel weird

Dunn I've asked before -- please elaborate.

Specifically, whose reads, and what makes those reads weird?

In post 106, Prism wrote:Spiffeh needs to do something that isn't shitposting, sangres is a townlean mainly because it's Nacho specifically voting to give me the artifact.

P-Edit: speak of the devil

In post 141, Prism wrote:Thought about it more, haven't read last page and can't atm but zero chance sangres is scum here

VOTE: Sangres

In post 153, Prism wrote:I'm on my phone so pretty limited, but the short of it is that sangres would make a bigger show of paranoia here, which hasn't happened yet. They also respect my towngame too much to fight on my behalf out of the gate like this, let alone give me the artifact. Hard town.

Playstyle it's nice to have diversity.

This read because it seemed like townreading someone too fast

I think I thought more people towned you because Prism kept bringing it up

In post 714, sangres wrote:

In post 359, Tammy wrote:Oh nachgres do you have any thoughts on spiffeh?

pretty firmly townreading him at this point in the read.

I feel unfairly persecuted by this

maybe you just like spiffs more than me

Why go after the sangres townreads in aggregate as opposed to going after me specifically?

716 kind of explains the "aggregate" element but it's clear you didn't like my read specifically so the fact it took sangres asking to get you to pursue this concerns me

I don't think the read is scummy, I just think you're jumping to conclusions too fast.

Why don't you find that scummy?

FWIW My read on sangres is a very specific bet on ffery as a reaction to two recent games with me-one that she modded, and one that we played together.

In post 720, Prism wrote:Why don't you find that scummy?

Because it's something town do a lot too

In post 717, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 714, sangres wrote:

In post 359, Tammy wrote:Oh nachgres do you have any thoughts on spiffeh?

pretty firmly townreading him at this point in the read.

I feel unfairly persecuted by this

maybe you just like spiffs more than me

obviously!

LLD if you move to Titus I'll sheep but I'm not killing Mathblade this game.

PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 714, sangres wrote:

In post 359, Tammy wrote:Oh nachgres do you have any thoughts on spiffeh?

pretty firmly townreading him at this point in the read.

I feel unfairly persecuted by this

maybe you just like spiffs more than me

I think he's jealous of your avatar, too.