Price is Right... Mod abandoned

[Empking]

DGB, what do you think of those voting you?

[iLord]

@Empking:

How was that post indicative of scum?

In Post 683. Answer.

[Empking]

I thought I had.

Its saying someone is scum for the reason that I didn't vote her. Nobody could actually use that argument and believe it. Scum say arguments they don't believe, town doesn't.

[Kinetic]

I almost never agree with BM but ribwich is like one of the top people for being scum; how on Earth could anyone vote him?
This game is not vote the people who are typing the most words, it's vote the people who are town.

Two possibilities.

Either ribwich is town, and the SCUM knows this, and they're pretending to not find him scummy to get later town cred,

or

ribwich is scum, in which case I can't possibly imagine the scum having the gall to vote FOR each other, and thus ribwich's supporters are townies with defective scumdars.

o.O False Dilemma much?

BTW, the scum voting townie ribwich argument is flawed.

We will never know if someone is town or scum, at any point, until the game is over. Thus, why would scum purposely go "against the flow" as you say, in order to "reap the benefits" when ribwich is "confirmed town" unless somehow ribwich will be revealed?

I'm sorry, but your entire argument, in this case, is ludicrous. If this was a normal game your argument might hold water, but you fell into the game trap again and your entire case is full of gaping holes because of it.

[StrangerCoug]

BTW, the scum voting townie ribwich argument is flawed.

Which is another reason why I'm not voting DGB. Take

THAT!

[xyzzy]

votecount 2-2

DrippingGoofball: iLord, ShadowLurker, Battle Mage, qwints
ribwich: ribwich, Kinetic, Empking, StrangerCoug

Not voting: DrippingGoofball, SensFan, DrippingGoofball, ZONEACE, DragonsofSummer, Max, populartajo, RossWilliam

Since it's been nearly two weeks since DoS said he was V/LA, I'm replacing him. Will try to get that done quickly.

[populartajo]

WTF? Why does DGB and ribwich have more votes than Kinetic, Ilord or me?

[Kinetic]

I can't be voted on for one...

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB, what do you think of those voting you?

These are obviously super-intelligent beings that look forward to some goofballery on the stage. They know no player will jump up and down higher and squeal with delight with more enthusiasm.

[DrippingGoofball]

If this was a normal game your argument might hold water, but you fell into the game trap again and your entire case is full of gaping holes because of it.

Gah! Banana peels again.

[ribwich]

A lot of the fallacies in DGB's logic actually make her look more town to me. Particularly how she seemed unaware that scum would only know two of their scummates. Everyone should know that's how the game works, but scum definately would. However, there is obvious WIFOM in that. This is my first game with her though so I'm unaware of her playstyle, would it be likely for DGB to fake ignorance for the sake of looking pro-town?

[StrangerCoug]

This is my first game with her though so I'm unaware of her playstyle, would it be likely for DGB to fake ignorance for the sake of looking pro-town?

I think this is my third game with her. Both other games are still ongoing, but she is known for her sense of humor, and she has a distinctive playstyle that I can't exactly describe.

[ShadowLurker]

WTF? Why does DGB and ribwich have more votes than Kinetic, Ilord or me?

scummy scummy scummy post

screams of scum being contributive and wondering why it isn't getting them votes

also shows them not paying attention to the game at all

[DrippingGoofball]

SL may be town after all.

[Kinetic]

A lot of the fallacies in DGB's logic actually make her look more town to me. Particularly how she seemed unaware that scum would only know two of their scummates. Everyone should know that's how the game works, but scum definately would. However, there is obvious WIFOM in that. This is my first game with her though so I'm unaware of her playstyle, would it be likely for DGB to fake ignorance for the sake of looking pro-town?

The mistakes, maybe, but the fallicies, not so much, I get the opposite reaction with something like that.

I've recently finished a game with DGB as scum, so I'm going to have to compare some of her play here with there and see if anything jives.

I'm still undecided on her overall.

[populartajo]

WTF? Why does DGB and ribwich have more votes than Kinetic, Ilord or me?

scummy scummy scummy post

screams of scum being contributive and wondering why it isn't getting them votes

also shows them not paying attention to the game at all

How old are you? Nine?!
Let me catch up with this game. I sincerely dont like it and has the potential of being treated like traitor, but Ill give it a try.

[Kinetic]

WTF? Why does DGB and ribwich have more votes than Kinetic, Ilord or me?

scummy scummy scummy post

screams of scum being contributive and wondering why it isn't getting them votes

also shows them not paying attention to the game at all

How old are you? Nine?!
Let me catch up with this game. I sincerely dont like it and has the potential of being treated like traitor, but Ill give it a try.

Despite the way he put it, I agree with the sentiment. Don't ignore it and try to pass it off.

[populartajo]

What should I do? Get into your heads and steal the idea you have about that post? I am not paying this game the attention it deserves and I was shocked when ribwich and DGB were getting more votes than you and Ilord. The "me" part was an obv joke.

[StrangerCoug]

WTF? Why does DGB and ribwich have more votes than Kinetic, Ilord or me?

scummy scummy scummy post

screams of scum being contributive and wondering why it isn't getting them votes

also shows them not paying attention to the game at all

How old are you? Nine?!

If you look at his profile, you'll see that he's 11.

[Battle Mage]

What should I do? Get into your heads and steal the idea you have about that post? I am not paying this game the attention it deserves and I was shocked when ribwich and DGB were getting more votes than you and Ilord. The "me" part was an obv joke.

why would Ilord and Kinetic be getting votes? You clearly AREN'T paying attention to the game.

BM

[iLord]

DGB being illogical is not indicative of scum in the slightest. In fact, her colorful disregard for seriousness is one of the certitudes of mafia. And that’s why we all enjoy her presence.

Separately, I’m voting DGB because I find her more town than the other two candidates.

Tajo just seems confused.

[Battle Mage]

ribwich is scum, in which case I can't possibly imagine the scum having the gall to vote FOR each other, and thus ribwich's supporters are townies with defective scumdars.

Given the strength of ribwich's few suporters' conviction, I lean towards ribwich being town, and his supporters being scum. I don't think townies would be so stubborn going against the tide for someone whose alignment they don't know, and that everyone else seems to doubt. But I can see scumbags wanting to make themselves heroes defending a townie everyone else finds scummy.

Why would scum not vote for each other? 0.o

BM

[DrippingGoofball]

Why would scum not vote for each other? 0.o

Inverse bus'ing. Think about it.

In other news, BM is town in this game.

[Max]

DGB is one of those players, ribwich, that you can only know when she is town based on later in the game, trust me here she's a useless lynch in all but near end circumstances

Vote: DGB

[DrippingGoofball]

Moar votes please... I can't wait to find out what the next step is!