Newbie 1378 - Game Over! (Town Wins)
Forum rules
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3127
- Joined: July 3, 2012
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Linxie
-
Linxie Townie
- Linxie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 80
- Joined: May 27, 2013
- Location: South Africa
Ok I get what you're saying, but you picked up on Mattel's crumbs before hand, that's why you unvoted Lucky and voted Jason instead. Your argument here is that "what if Uct died and couldn't tell anyone about the crumbs" so if he died, you'd still be alive to point it out. This also means that your second paragraph applies to you as well since you picked up on Mattel's claim first.In post 718, mastin2 wrote:
Linxie, you're applying future knowledge to the past.In post 711, Linxie wrote:I understand what you're saying but remember that A) Triton wasn't the only one to pick up on the Mattel crumb and B) you're focusing on a scenario which doesn't apply. Mattel was town and Jason was scum. The flip revealed that... also I'm pretty sure that had Jason flipped town and Triton died instead of Mattel, Mattel would have had major pressure from you since you picked up on Mattel's crumb as well.
Go back to that time period. Ignore the flip we had later. Think of that time.triton wouldn't know anybody else had picked up on the crumbs. (Almost) everyone said they picked them up on day three, but NOBODY had made it clear they saw the crumbs on day two.A triton-as-town at the time would have had no way of knowing he was not the only one to have seen them. That is something which was ONLY clear come day three.
And this is the more critical par you're missing.Triton-as-town WOULD NOT HAVE KNOWN that mattel was town and Jason was scum. The ONLY way triton would have known mattel was town and known Jason was scum is if he were scum with Jason. This is exactly what I've been arguing. Yes, as it turned out, mattel was town and Jason was scum. So yes, I'm arguing about a scenario which ended up not applying. But go back to the time--A TOWN TRITON HAD NO WAY OF KNOWING IT WOULDN'T HAVE APPLIED. That is somethingonlypossible from a scum-triton.- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
@Lucky: Then what was the point of that post. Obviously you posted it to do something. With some purpose.
I don't see any other purpose then trying to use it to earn town cred. And it poped out of no where when nobody even said you were town because there was no way Jason was "bussing" you.
And i see a lot of wrong things in your post.
1)You did not cause his death. You basically OMGUS and jumped on him after he vote you.
2) You screaming and pushing for Ucrit to hammer doesn't do shit. You think you screaming and begging him do anything?
3) You can't just let yourself die like that. You mean you push him all the way up to L1 and just say " OH jason is not scum, i am scum, lynch me!". How do you explain you do that?
4) In the case that you are scum, jason wanted to buss you to earn town cred. But in the unexpected sit of mattel copping on him, it turned out that both of you are wagoned. Thus to make full use of the sit, you two pushed each other wagon "fully" so that whoever is lynched, the other would have town cred.
I don't like talking about these scenarios as these are all hypothetical and is of little use. But i am using this to show that your defense is bullshit.
And all those sit, i don't like considering them because i find them of little use. I would rather see who is scummy.
I will try to reread now. Brb."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
@Ucrit: Mattel said the I know he is scum phrases so many times. Why did you only catch it at the last post?
@Lucky: It seems that now you think me and linxie is town.
I can't see the transition.
Explain how you went from:
Linxie scum --> Linxie town and me scum --> me town to mastin scum -->If mastin flipped scum, you think ucrit is scum."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Oh. Ucrit is most likely town.
due to this when isoing Jason:
I find it hard to believe that scum would look over their scum buddies past games in their first post.In post 11, JasonWazza wrote:VOTE: uctriton00
Because a quick look over your other games show's you RVS half the time and i don't like that, either RVS or don't man.
And ucrit, dont take this as a point to not answer my questions"you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Fk ucrit, what was that unvoting jason based on hunch thingy then wanting to hammer lucky.
First give me why you think jason is scum.
Second, give me why you unvoted jason.
Third, why was lucky scum at that time."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Hey Lucky, this is after you saw Mattel soft-claim cop. Wtf was this. You are lying. Hey guys, lynch him.In post 514, Lucky2u wrote:I still favor Jason."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Ok nvm. I never saw the back part. But why don't you want to rely on that? Isn't it obvious to you an obv cop claim? And why would you say out the obv cop claim if you saw it.(It would let scum kill him?)"you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3127
- Joined: July 3, 2012
If there were, I didn't see them.In post 729, enomis wrote:Mattel said the I know he is scum phrases so many times. Why did you only catch it at the last post?
And the one pointed out earlier (two pages back or something) looks like just someone talking out of conjecture, not as someone as proof. People say "i know he's guilty trust me" all the time in mafia.
But the claim that I saw from mattel was way in my face after I had been posting, with a genuinely serious appeal I felt, and I couldn't possibly miss that.- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Even after Lucky said that mattel hinted at cop and Linxie gave an "How do you know he is scum" reply?In post 734, uctriton00 wrote:
If there were, I didn't see them.In post 729, enomis wrote:Mattel said the I know he is scum phrases so many times. Why did you only catch it at the last post?
And the one pointed out earlier (two pages back or something) looks like just someone talking out of conjecture, not as someone as proof. People say "i know he's guilty trust me" all the time in mafia.
But the claim that I saw from mattel was way in my face after I had been posting, with a genuinely serious appeal I felt, and I couldn't possibly miss that."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3127
- Joined: July 3, 2012
I voted Jason on a hunch (mostly due to RC willing to die over something he felt that strongly about, even wasting his PR role). That and I seriously don't want him around in a situation where he's unreadable. His playstyle is to talk massive **** to cover up anyone picking up tells. (Seriously, this must be how he gets by in almost every game).In post 731, enomis wrote:Fk ucrit, what was that unvoting jason based on hunch thingy then wanting to hammer lucky.
First give me why you think jason is scum.
Second, give me why you unvoted jason.
Third, why was lucky scum at that time.
Then I started to listen to the Lucky naysayers, and to be honest he does have an awful scumhunting and awful posturing approach from Day 1. Do I really want to go on a 50/50 for Jason just because I find him insulting and hard to read, or use logical hunting on lucky? Mehhhh I better use logic.
****, Mattel is outright pleaing as if he's a cop with definitive proof. I'll take him up on his offer. If he's telling the truth, we kill a scum. If he's lying, I'll run him into a train. And bring along Lucky with it too, my original read.
YOLO: whack him.
Jason = you idiot you killed me i'm a cop
Me = **** dude I had to. ****. Alright, I'm knocking out Lucky and Mattel.
Jason = lol i'm scum
Me = HERO STATUS
mastin = WE MUST KILL TRITON NOW
Me = ...... hello, final scum.
Me = *reads evidence* still scum
Me = *more evidence* still scum
Mastin = Triton has holes in his story here, here, and here
Me = *shoots down every hole*
Everyone else = yeah mastin your case is actually pretty bad
Mastin = i'm emotionally drained- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3127
- Joined: July 3, 2012
Anyone who says "i know he's scum" can be talking with straight conjecture.In post 735, enomis wrote:Even after Lucky said that mattel hinted at cop and Linxie gave an "How do you know he is scum" reply?- enomis
-
enomis Mafia Scum
- enomis
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2406
- Joined: November 6, 2011
- Location: Singapore
Really, I get the feeling this is town v town. Lets wait for lucky reply."you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Homertve: "Oh, and by the way, your tail is on fire."- mastin2
-
mastin2 The Second Coming
- mastin2
- The Second Coming
- The Second Coming
- Posts: 14413
- Joined: October 8, 2009
- Location: Replacement Alley
- Contact:
For the first half--again, triton had no way of knowing I had picked them up. I had, but how would he have known that? He wouldn't have.In post 727, Linxie wrote:Ok I get what you're saying, but you picked up on Mattel's crumbs before hand, that's why you unvoted Lucky and voted Jason instead. Your argument here is that "what if Uct died and couldn't tell anyone about the crumbs" so if he died, you'd still be alive to point it out. This also means that your second paragraph applies to you as well since you picked up on Mattel's claim first.
For the second half--unlike triton, I had zero doubts on mattel's claim. Triton's claimed logic is, "oh, mattel claimed cop with a guilty, so let's lynch Jason; if Jason flips town, I can lynch mattel tomorrow".
My logic was, "derp, mattel has a guilty." I did have a brief thought about "how legit is it?", but it was just that: a brief thought. I checked his posting history on D2, and found literally every single post telling the same thing. I also thought about mindset (and, critically, newbie mindset--mattel's not a veteran player, and vets have a fundamentally different approach to the game), and that was the thought: "What's the scum motivation for heavily 'crumbing a guilty against a player, when it's not lylo and you're bound to be counterclaimed?" As a vet, I can maybe think of a reason or two. From the perspective of a newbie who has no on-site gaming experience, I can't. A newbie doesn't take that kind of gambit, at least, not when they're under zero pressure. Maybe,maybeif mattel were the leading lynch candidate, but he wasn't.
Enomis, you've got that backwards: Why would a scumbuddy look over a random townie's first post? He could just as easily look over the post of any other player; why single out triton?In post 730, enomis wrote:Oh. Ucrit is most likely town.
due to this when isoing Jason:
I find it hard to believe that scum would look over their scum buddies past games in their first post.In post 11, JasonWazza wrote:VOTE: uctriton00
Because a quick look over your other games show's you RVS half the time and i don't like that, either RVS or don't man.
Hint: he wouldn't. It's a very, VERY frequent part of scum QTs, to have the scum talk about some of their past games, past experience, past voting histories, and (this is the vital part) what to expect in their play, especially early in D1. "A quick look over your other games" was probably done, yes...but much earlier, after a scum-triton linked Jason to some of his past games.My academy.
"...You have a blog?!?" (Yes, I do. Click.)
Agnigi, 13p Mini Theme sequel to Gistou, is in design and could use reviewers!- Lucky2u
-
Lucky2u Jack of All Trades
- Lucky2u
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 6280
- Joined: April 5, 2013
I'll go through the posts one by one, excuse me if I miss something.
I disagree with 1 and 2, but these are matters of opinion on how you viewed yesterday. For 3: You really can't see a way I could have influence my own wagon to lynch me? Hell as town I got myself to L-1 without even trying, imagine if I WANTED people to lynch me. 4 is another possibility I suppose, but then why did I start bussing him from the get go? Hypothetically I am pretty quick on the improvisation.In post 728, enomis wrote:@Lucky: Then what was the point of that post. Obviously you posted it to do something. With some purpose.
I don't see any other purpose then trying to use it to earn town cred. And it poped out of no where when nobody even said you were town because there was no way Jason was "bussing" you.
And i see a lot of wrong things in your post.
1)You did not cause his death. You basically OMGUS and jumped on him after he vote you.
2) You screaming and pushing for Ucrit to hammer doesn't do shit. You think you screaming and begging him do anything?
3) You can't just let yourself die like that. You mean you push him all the way up to L1 and just say " OH jason is not scum, i am scum, lynch me!". How do you explain you do that?
4) In the case that you are scum, jason wanted to buss you to earn town cred. But in the unexpected sit of mattel copping on him, it turned out that both of you are wagoned. Thus to make full use of the sit, you two pushed each other wagon "fully" so that whoever is lynched, the other would have town cred.
I don't like talking about these scenarios as these are all hypothetical and is of little use. But i am using this to show that your defense is bullshit.
And all those sit, i don't like considering them because i find them of little use. I would rather see who is scummy.
I will try to reread now. Brb.- Lucky2u
-
Lucky2u Jack of All Trades
- Lucky2u
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 6280
- Joined: April 5, 2013
Hi, welcome to Mafia, where the views of people change and the points don't matter ("Who's line is it anyway?" reference!)In post 729, enomis wrote:@Ucrit: Mattel said the I know he is scum phrases so many times. Why did you only catch it at the last post?
@Lucky: It seems that now you think me and linxie is town.
I can't see the transition.
Explain how you went from:
Linxie scum --> Linxie town and me scum --> me town to mastin scum -->If mastin flipped scum, you think ucrit is scum.- Lucky2u
-
Lucky2u Jack of All Trades
- Lucky2u
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 6280
- Joined: April 5, 2013
Yea that summary sound about right...In post 736, uctriton00 wrote:
I voted Jason on a hunch (mostly due to RC willing to die over something he felt that strongly about, even wasting his PR role). That and I seriously don't want him around in a situation where he's unreadable. His playstyle is to talk massive **** to cover up anyone picking up tells. (Seriously, this must be how he gets by in almost every game).
Then I started to listen to the Lucky naysayers, and to be honest he does have an awful scumhunting and awful posturing approach from Day 1. Do I really want to go on a 50/50 for Jason just because I find him insulting and hard to read, or use logical hunting on lucky? Mehhhh I better use logic.
****, Mattel is outright pleaing as if he's a cop with definitive proof. I'll take him up on his offer. If he's telling the truth, we kill a scum. If he's lying, I'll run him into a train. And bring along Lucky with it too, my original read.
YOLO: whack him.
Jason = you idiot you killed me i'm a cop
Me = **** dude I had to. ****. Alright, I'm knocking out Lucky and Mattel.
Jason = lol i'm scum
Me = HERO STATUS
mastin = WE MUST KILL TRITON NOW
Me = ...... hello, final scum.
Me = *reads evidence* still scum
Me = *more evidence* still scum
Mastin = Triton has holes in his story here, here, and here
Me = *shoots down every hole*
Everyone else = yeah mastin your case is actually pretty bad
Mastin = i'm emotionally drained- Linxie
-
Linxie Townie
- Linxie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 80
- Joined: May 27, 2013
- Location: South Africa
Wall incoming...
Spoiler: Lucky post 724
What did I just read? It's not what you said, but the way you said it that has my brow raised here...
In post 732, enomis wrote:
Hey Lucky, this is after you saw Mattel soft-claim cop. Wtf was this. You are lying. Hey guys, lynch him.In post 514, Lucky2u wrote:I still favor Jason.
This isn't the first time you (Lucky) have ignored questions.enomis wrote:Ok nvm. I never saw the back part.But why don't you want to rely on that? Isn't it obvious to you an obv cop claim? And why would you say out the obv cop claim if you saw it.(It would let scum kill him?)
Spoiler: Mastin post 739
Brain fart, I understand what you mean. I think you're wrong about Triton though, and I think Enomis is right that this is town vs. town, I agree Lucky is the last scum.
To elaborate on why I've changed my mind about you. You've made a mistake and owned up to it and I haven't been able to find much fault or doubt in the rest of your replies either. The other thing is that you (and Triton) have fought for your cases, never letting up, never allowing someone to change your mind. I only hope that your minds aren't so set you aren't willing to hear the rest of us.
Spoiler: Massive Wall - Lucky's posts and interactions with Jason
Lucky has; A) jumped from wagon to wagon, all of his reasons have either been poor or borrowed; B) he's only given reads when asked; C) As a "vanilla towny" he was afraid to be noticed or lynched; D) his eagerness to get a lynch today; E) he has not scum hunted at all this game and only makes a feeble effort when this is pointed out, and there's a lot of random chatter in between (not scum or even town hunting for that matter)
In short:
Jason said a few things on purpose, I can only think they were said in order to throw town:
- One was that he NEVER coached scum as scum, but he would coach town as scum. (Did this to many people in order to cover his tracks: RC, Lucky, Linxie)
- The other was that he bussed his partners, especially if they were bad players. (He also did this to many people in order to cover his tracks, Uct, Paradigm, Lucky)
- His performance end D2. (Throwing focus on Triton for the Hammer, setting him up for a lynch)
this muchscumminess about you - and I've felt this way since I replaced into the game mind you - imagine what would be used against you tomorrow and possibly cause a loss to town. I would rather take my chances with you today and trust that I am right, than take my chances tomorrow and get it wrong.
VOTE: Lucky2u- Lucky2u
-
Lucky2u Jack of All Trades
- Lucky2u
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 6280
- Joined: April 5, 2013
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
- Lucky2u
-
Lucky2u Jack of All Trades
- Lucky2u
- uctriton00
-
uctriton00 Mafia Scum
- uctriton00
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
- Lucky2u
- Linxie
- Lucky2u
- Lucky2u
- Lucky2u
- mastin2
- enomis
- uctriton00
- uctriton00
- enomis
- uctriton00
- enomis
- enomis
- enomis
- enomis
- enomis
- enomis
- Linxie
- uctriton00