Mafiascum.net

I mean I don’t actually want to relitigate that game I was a goodish PR and a terrible scumhunter and I don’t think the town loss falls on either of our shoulders as much as the D1 fakeclaimer and I learned some things so yay
I’m just trying to be very honest about why I am likely to change my play now that you’re here, intentionally or not

I don’t remember the game too much, except I flip flopped on you a lot. I also think I hard town read TW, yet I made the classic FL town tell by going on and lynching him anyways.

Lol, was my slot already voting Irrelephant or did I vote and forget?

I think it was already voting me?

*sigh*
Care to explain your read?

In post 729, Irrelephant11 wrote:*sigh*
Care to explain your read?

You and Chara seemingly reacted in a specific way that i see scum do around me.

Vorkuta/HitAlt got hard WIFOM’d recently because I claimed Day 3 IC and did this cologne gambit, and it drove them wild.

I see similarities in yours and Chara’s play. These are my first impression reads.

In post 730, Flavor Leaf wrote:

In post 729, Irrelephant11 wrote:*sigh*
Care to explain your read?

You and Chara seemingly reacted in a specific way that i see scum do around me.

Vorkuta/HitAlt got hard WIFOM’d recently because I claimed Day 3 IC and did this cologne gambit, and it drove them wild.

I see similarities in yours and Chara’s play. These are my first impression reads.

Chara hasn't reacted to your claim yet.

In post 731, tris wrote:

In post 730, Flavor Leaf wrote:

In post 729, Irrelephant11 wrote:*sigh*
Care to explain your read?

You and Chara seemingly reacted in a specific way that i see scum do around me.

Vorkuta/HitAlt got hard WIFOM’d recently because I claimed Day 3 IC and did this cologne gambit, and it drove them wild.

I see similarities in yours and Chara’s play. These are my first impression reads.

Chara hasn't reacted to your claim yet.

I said my replacing in moreso than my claim.

Well, I meant my replacing in. Which chara did comment on.

For what it's worth, my reaction to the claim is similar to Irrelephant's. I can see what you are talking about with respect to Chara's reaction to your replacing in, but for the Irrelephant part, are you referring to the post claim reactions?

In post 734, tris wrote:For what it's worth, my reaction to the claim is similar to Irrelephant's. I can see what you are talking about with respect to Chara's reaction to your replacing in, but for the Irrelephant part, are you referring to the post claim reactions?

Again, moreso talking about the replacing in itself moreso than the claim. It’s the combination in their case

In post 724, Flavor Leaf wrote:Chara’s also probably scum.

Thoughts, Chara?

i'd tunnel you hard if you kept this read throughout the game, are my thoughts. i think my no-mislynch pattern can beat you.
i was worried, but since you've already claimed 3p, i don't need to worry about you being town anymore. now it's down to you actually being scum, vs. you being a 3p that may or may not help us. the eventuality of 1v1ing town Flavor is off the table. i don't think i'm that good at reading you, and the experience that sticks in my head is that scumgame where i figured out you were scum just in time to be nightkilled and for us to lose. the one with the inno mislynch.

but i am still pretty wary of scum you so i'll see where your content goes!

if you are on town's side i expect you to fix your reads at some point, but either way i don't think pressuring you to get a better idea will work, so it is a little annoying. :>
but i like playing with you! make no mistake about that.

In post 736, Chara wrote:

In post 724, Flavor Leaf wrote:Chara’s also probably scum.

Thoughts, Chara?

i'd tunnel you hard if you kept this read throughout the game, are my thoughts. i think my no-mislynch pattern can beat you.
i was worried, but since you've already claimed 3p, i don't need to worry about you being town anymore. now it's down to you actually being scum, vs. you being a 3p that may or may not help us. the eventuality of 1v1ing town Flavor is off the table. i don't think i'm that good at reading you, and the experience that sticks in my head is that scumgame where i figured out you were scum just in time to be nightkilled and for us to lose. the one with the inno mislynch.

but i am still pretty wary of scum you so i'll see where your content goes!

Why is me being town claiming 3rd party off the table here?

I’m not. I’m just 3rd party, but yeah. I’ll win with town, and you can lynch me later in the game to prove it.

In post 723, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m the one that was mislynched there, though, so i don’t understand this thought process.

i'm confused, what does you being mislynched have to do with your scumread on RC becoming a townread in that game?

I just came off a game where I claimed Day 3 IC Day 1, and everyone in the game knew it was BS, even scum, but it drove scum wild.

I got a Vig shot on the most dangerous scum that night instead.

In post 738, Flavor Leaf wrote:Why is me being town claiming 3rd party off the table here?

I’m not. I’m just 3rd party, but yeah. I’ll win with town, and you can lynch me later in the game to prove it.

because i wouldn't believe you if you claimed town later. even if i thought of the possibility i wouldn't take any actions that put faith into it.
unless you really really towned it up, i suppose?

In post 739, Chara wrote:

In post 723, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m the one that was mislynched there, though, so i don’t understand this thought process.

i'm confused, what does you being mislynched have to do with your scumread on RC becoming a townread in that game?

The game in question was Me, Irrelephant, RC, Gemeni, and...Srceenplay?

I don’t understand your question. That was in response to Irrelephant saying I’m the one who misread him when I’m the one that was mislynched.

I flip flop all over the place and if I town read someone that doesn’t mean I think they are town and vice versa.

Fork Mafia I specifically didn’t town read Flubber, so that’s how I knew he wasn’t scum and was actually town.

In post 741, Chara wrote:

In post 738, Flavor Leaf wrote:Why is me being town claiming 3rd party off the table here?

I’m not. I’m just 3rd party, but yeah. I’ll win with town, and you can lynch me later in the game to prove it.

because i wouldn't believe you if you claimed town later. even if i thought of the possibility i wouldn't take any actions that put faith into it.
unless you really really towned it up, i suppose?

Off of one entrance claim? Noted.

In post 742, Flavor Leaf wrote:I don’t understand your question. That was in response to Irrelephant saying I’m the one who misread him when I’m the one that was mislynched.

pretty sure he was talking about you misreading each other, to which you responded that you were misread because of your RC scumread (and not believed), but then later called RC town in lylo and got mislynched.

so unless elephant is lying about you two tunneling each other, i'm confused about the issue there.
but i also wasn't in the game, so.

In post 743, Flavor Leaf wrote:Off of one entrance claim? Noted.

i'm not really a gambler.

In post 708, skitter30 wrote:

In post 706, tris wrote:

In post 699, skitter30 wrote: tris - her play reminds me * a lot* of the scumgame we finished last week.

In what ways?

the questioning-but-not-really-engaging thing that you're doing, like right here
most of your questions don't seem to lead anywhere

this was my exact impression of tris from Anuket, and i'm not seeing a real difference. she was also pushed there for that, and i remember scumreading her for it.
are there any differences between the two?

In post 744, Chara wrote:

In post 742, Flavor Leaf wrote:I don’t understand your question. That was in response to Irrelephant saying I’m the one who misread him when I’m the one that was mislynched.

pretty sure he was talking about you misreading each other, to which you responded that you were misread because of your RC scumread (and not believed), but then later called RC town in lylo and got mislynched.

so unless elephant is lying about you two tunneling each other, i'm confused about the issue there.
but i also wasn't in the game, so.

I went after everyone in that game. He just went after me more than others, so he got more than others got.

I read him correctly at times as well. I flip flop. People just focus on the times when I didn’t.

I think it’s silly to not have evolving reads.

And how is that a gamble.

Do you think I wouldn’t do something like that as town?

I’ll quote Nero Cain “In my experience, gambity Boon is town Boon.”

In post 741, Chara wrote:

In post 738, Flavor Leaf wrote:Why is me being town claiming 3rd party off the table here?

I’m not. I’m just 3rd party, but yeah. I’ll win with town, and you can lynch me later in the game to prove it.

because i wouldn't believe you if you claimed town later. even if i thought of the possibility i wouldn't take any actions that put faith into it.
unless you really really towned it up, i suppose?

Why?

In post 745, Chara wrote:

In post 743, Flavor Leaf wrote:Off of one entrance claim? Noted.

i'm not really a gambler.

What are you saying here?

of course reads should evolve, your reads on each other were my point.
it's a gamble to me. you gambit as scum, too. is the value you have as town worth more than the risk of you being scum? is the loss of mislynching you scary enough that i'll hesitant to lynch there? that's the sort of thing i'd think about.

i could ask you a similar question. do you really think town me wouldn't react as i did upon you replacing in for a scumread? considering i don't read you well.

you'll notice i never said i was planning on lynching you. i don't even scumread you. but if you claim town i'll continue to treat you as a likely either 3p or scum, rather than town or scum, since this game is borderline bastard and it seems a likely enough role. it's just safer. i've been burned by "friendly" 3p claims before.