In post 721, skitter30 wrote:i think he was out late last week cuz of surgery, not sure where he's been since the day started tho
i hope it went well
you've played with him a lot, do you think you can read him?
Yeah.
I give Tchill and Robb both the same benefit. I usually wait til day 3 on them and I can read them 95% of the time.
They’re both very good players and I refuse to lynch them early unless I know for sure they are scum.
I’m sure that play style by me has helped form Lucas read on me.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 2:32 pm
by skitter30
robb i feel like gets into those shitty tunnels as both ailgnments, and sometimes becomes toxic
toghether it's like impossible for me to read him i feel like
tchill's tone is also p similar as both alignments
i think for him it's more useful to look at what his motivations are and what he's trying to accomplish
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 2:52 pm
by skitter30
i will be vla till wednesday night
Will prob be around tomorrow, wont be around wednesday really
In post 705, Luca Blight wrote:Your first question seems scummy to me - it’s like you’re trying to draw out whether I investigated you or something. I’ve said I’m almost certain you’re scum, so you can draw your own conclusions from that.
You also thought PM was Town yesterday. What’s changed?
I know I'm town. So I really just need one more person I'm comfortable not lynching to start thinking about this
why wouldnt you lynch me???
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 6:20 pm
by Tchill13
i'll do a deep dive into this game wednesday night more than likely.
i need better TR's.
I need to know why luca KNOWS havo is scum and PM is town.
skitter FOS'ing me could be a product of not having other SR's.
very odd theres no big suspicion of flubb yet.
luca's case on havo does make sense but idk if im willing to go havo scum yet. he needs to answer other questions first.
PM has done little to nothing. just like Flub.
scums gotta be in one of those slots.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 6:22 pm
by Tchill13
skitter/havo/luca is highly, highly unlikely.
which means flub or PM has to be scum unless robb is scum.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 6:28 pm
by Tchill13
In post 466, Luca Blight wrote:But no-one has been bothered about Vorkuta getting lynched. The only player who has been questioning Vorkuta’s Lynch recently has been me, and I obviously know I’m not his partner. In a game where there are so many dubious players it would be unbelievable for scum to sleepwalk into being lynched.
I guess it’s possible he could be scum, but I can’t remember scum ever being lynched in such an easy manner when a game has been in such a lifeless state. The current game state is the perfect environment for scum to stay in the shadows.
I agree that behavior wise there isn’t a lot to suggest Vorkuta is Town, but there’s not a lot to suggest he’s scum either. He’s edging closer to being lynched but doesn’t seem to be survivalistic.
In post 505, Luca Blight wrote:PM, Flavor never said he was going to defend the Fallsoul slot, he said he was going to defend Vorkuta. Read again...
In post 659, Luca Blight wrote:We have ten hours left and I’m soon to be V/LA. I think I’m sticking with my Tchill vote at this stage but hopefully we can reach a Lynch one way or another before deadline. My reads are currently as follows:
I TR Robb, because if I can’t Tr the only other player who’s been on a similar wavelength to me this game and tried to make stuff happen then I might as well throw in the towel.
PM’s recent suspicion of Tchill makes me feel a bit better about him, but still far from convinced.
The Flavor slot has been terrible generally this game and deserves to be lynched, but in a way it feels ‘too easy’ to be scum. Maybe worth looking into again on D3.
Flubbernugget is a null read and will probably remain that way. Just not enough content to get a clear read on him, but I would be inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt for now.
Havo has been rubbing me up the wrong way a bit. Probably because I disagree with a lot of what he says. I don’t likes his opinions on Skitter or Tchill, and his popping in and out feels like scum doing just enough to look busy.
Skitter has posted more than most but I can’t remember anything particularly meaningful she has said. I could definitely see this kind of playstyle (probing without actually doing much) coming from scum.
I don’t like Vorkuta’s content generally. I have a feeling he is Town based on the lack of general activity this day phase when he’s been the main wagon and his apparent lack of survivalism. I feel like he could have made life easier for himself here as scum.
In post 683, Luca Blight wrote:We know for sure all the scum were voting by end of day 1.
PM is Town so all the scum were on Town wagons.
I think it’s likely the entire scum team was on the Vork wagon, but Flubber obviously could be scum as well.
I think it’s highly likely Tchill is scum but I’ll have to go over the wagons again.
this does not line up.
no reason for TR'ing PM so hard.
no reason other than "vanity" for TR'ing Rob.
you have your eyes on a skitter/tchill/havo team, dropping suspicion of Flub for what reason?
In post 705, Luca Blight wrote:Your first question seems scummy to me - it’s like you’re trying to draw out whether I investigated you or something. I’ve said I’m almost certain you’re scum, so you can draw your own conclusions from that.
You also thought PM was Town yesterday. What’s changed?
you called for mass claim.
go ahead and claim.
Where did I call for a mass claim?
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 7:51 pm
by Luca Blight
I strongly believe Robb and PM are Town. I can reveal why after a mass-claim, but I’ll only agree to a mass-claim if it’s in a certain order:
Havo, Skitter, Tchill, Flubs, Robb, PM should be the order.
And if you’re Town then do not lie about your role.
I am on holiday now so will be V/LA until next week, but will still try to be as active as possible.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2019 7:58 pm
by Luca Blight
Sorry, including myself the order should be Havo - Skitter - Tchill - Flubs - Luca - Rob - Pm
Well, I don't want to beat around the bush with this one any longer, since people do want to know why Luca performed a 180 like that.
I am a Friendly Neighbor. I targeted Luca last night to show him I'm Town (which I can assume went through since he's now saying I am town), and on Night 1, I targeted Vork.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 4:11 am
by skitter30
Ok, makes sense.
I was kinda guessing something like that since the read flipped so drastically, didnt really want to probe there for that reason
I'm not going to have internet access tom, so if people dont want to wait for me i can claim now
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 5:42 am
by Tchill13
In post 739, Luca Blight wrote:I strongly believe Robb and PM are Town. I can reveal why after a mass-claim, but I’ll only agree to a mass-claim if it’s in a certain order:
Havo, Skitter, Tchill, Flubs, Robb, PM should be the order.
And if you’re Town then do not lie about your role.
I am on holiday now so will be V/LA until next week, but will still try to be as active as possible.
you refuse to go first? you demand that you're last?
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 6:42 am
by PMysterious
In post 739, Luca Blight wrote:I strongly believe Robb and PM are Town. I can reveal why after a mass-claim, but I’ll only agree to a mass-claim if it’s in a certain order:
Havo, Skitter, Tchill, Flubs, Robb, PM should be the order.
And if you’re Town then do not lie about your role.
I am on holiday now so will be V/LA until next week, but will still try to be as active as possible.
If I'm reading this correctly, Robb is also a Friendly Neighbor based on the belief that Robb is town. The other thought is that you are a cop and Robb is innocent. Whatever the case may be, it would be best to confirm this now and not later.