Mafiascum.net

In post 723, Vasex wrote: I have a ready post but the night victim is rather unexpected. This is good that one of the susps is dead and she is just a vanilla townie.

Please tell me why the Ydrasse-kill was unexpected? For me, it was the most obvious kill choice and basically guarantees we don't have a doctor.

I'd be surprised if both HUB and TRQ are town. It feels like 1 SE-1 newbie scum. But I have more confidence in flipping the newbie.

In post 724, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:What crumb?

probably 700

In post 724, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:What crumb?

the Ydrasse crumb? Ydrasse crumbed a PR yesterday, which was presumably the reason for the kill.

In post 726, Battle Mage wrote:I'd be surprised if both HUB and TRQ are town. It feels like 1 SE-1 newbie scum. But I have more confidence in flipping the newbie.

so your read on me is what exactly? null but mafia if happy unbirthday boon is town, just because?

In post 727, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 724, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:What crumb?

probably 700

actually no - it was the one which said something like "i can confirm myself as town if i need to"

In post 730, Battle Mage wrote:actually no - it was the one which said something like "i can confirm myself as town if i need to"

oh hm nah that's something ydrasse says has said before etc etc

In post 731, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 730, Battle Mage wrote:actually no - it was the one which said something like "i can confirm myself as town if i need to"

oh hm nah that's something ydrasse says has said before etc etc

but also maybe! since mafia killed her and you (maybe one and the same!) seem to think so

i've played many games with ydrasse. if i'm scum, i'm for sure killing ydrasse there, and if i'm town, i'm for sure elimming ydrasse on a vanilla-claim.

Joined:Wed

Jan 10, 2007

Total posts:21415

SIGNATURE
2020 Stats - 31 completed games:
Survived to the end and won - 11
Nightkilled - 10
Survived to the end and lost - 6
Day-elimmed by majority - 4

winrate as scum: 78%

winrate as town: 55%

We should be very careful with Battle Mage

In post 733, Battle Mage wrote:and if i'm town, i'm for sure elimming ydrasse on a vanilla-claim.

all by yourself?

i dont think it really helps sorting-wise, given I think everyone here would probably have done the same thing. I'm wary of you and HUB as SEs both playing it down.

In post 734, Vasex wrote:

Joined:Wed

Jan 10, 2007

Total posts:21415

SIGNATURE
2020 Stats - 31 completed games:
Survived to the end and won - 11
Nightkilled - 10
Survived to the end and lost - 6
Day-elimmed by majority - 4

winrate as scum: 78%

winrate as town: 55%

We should be very careful with Battle Mage

In post 735, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 733, Battle Mage wrote:and if i'm town, i'm for sure elimming ydrasse on a vanilla-claim.

all by yourself?

is that meant to be a joke or a serious question?

nah to say that was even the most likely crumb is a big stretch to me; could you answer my question about your read on me,

like there's a lot of content for it to be a flat null but mafia if happy unbirthday town for ??? reasons

In post 738, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 735, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 733, Battle Mage wrote:and if i'm town, i'm for sure elimming ydrasse on a vanilla-claim.

all by yourself?

is that meant to be a joke or a serious question?

more of a egocheck/reference to a song i like

In post 740, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 738, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 735, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 733, Battle Mage wrote:and if i'm town, i'm for sure elimming ydrasse on a vanilla-claim.

all by yourself?

is that meant to be a joke or a serious question?

more of a egocheck/reference to a song i like

i'll give you the benefit of the doubt then - elimination during the day is done by majority vote. But, and here's the kicker, with 4 to elim and 2 scum remaining, it could take as few as 2 townies to mis-step to result in a town elimination. claiming a power role when you're actually vanilla is rarely a good idea in newbies tbh, but here it paid off.

to insist that ydrasse saying something she has said before as vanilla town is claiming a power role...

when someone else in the game actually claimed a power role seems

kinda ... (dot dot dot)

In post 729, team rocket queen wrote:

In post 726, Battle Mage wrote:I'd be surprised if both HUB and TRQ are town. It feels like 1 SE-1 newbie scum. But I have more confidence in flipping the newbie.

so your read on me is what exactly? null but mafia if happy unbirthday boon is town,

just because?

yeah, null but scum if HUB is town is about right. i'm not sure why you say "just because" - are you trying to undermine me, instead of understanding my reasoning? would you describe your playstyle as confrontational normally? how does your approach differ between alignments?

i am trying to ask you why

like what is your reasoning behind that

In post 722, Battle Mage wrote:null: floo, team rocket queen

Why trq is null? Look at her again now.

In post 742, team rocket queen wrote:to insist that ydrasse saying something she has said before as vanilla town is claiming a power role...

when someone else in the game actually claimed a power role seems

kinda ... (dot dot dot)

what's your point? the other player who claimed a power role, also didn't have a power role. and that player got elimmed for it. Doesn't that illustrate my argument perfectly?

In post 743, Battle Mage wrote:would you describe your playstyle as confrontational normally? how does your approach differ between alignments?

yes to the first,

completely? i don't understand what you mean by approach,

In post 746, Battle Mage wrote:what's your point? the other player who claimed a power role, also didn't have a power role. and that player got elimmed for it. Doesn't that illustrate my argument perfectly?

happy unbirthday boon's mason claim just doesn't exist to you? or count towards this?

TRQ - your attempt to shade me here for nothing is both transparent and weak - I'm moving you up to scumlean.