Mafiascum.net

In post 724, Enchant wrote:After you did claim role, this turned moot.

I disagree(if this is even to me)

You can claim a role and and still not indicate your pre game preference. Thats why I asked, it's not consistent and it bothers me.

In post 713, Enchant wrote:I am not sure how many, but this reaction is unrealistic at all.

While it's possible moderator put up 8 MOTHERFUCKING PRs, i only can wonder how. I bet on atleast half of town being VT.

Thanks for posting the rules for my lazy ass. And I would not take your bet.

In post 725, Scorpious wrote:

In post 724, Enchant wrote:After you did claim role, this turned moot.

I disagree(if this is even to me)

You can claim a role and and still not indicate your pre game preference. Thats why I asked, it's not consistent and it bothers me.

Vanilla preference means you will roll Vanilla Townie for sure/Mafia Goon in most cases.

It doesh't give any intel for mafia and safe to claim along with role.

ANYONE UP TO MASSCLAIM D1 ONLY WINNING STRATEGY STRAT?

In post 726, Galron wrote:

In post 713, Enchant wrote:I am not sure how many, but this reaction is unrealistic at all.

While it's possible moderator put up 8 MOTHERFUCKING PRs, i only can wonder how. I bet on atleast half of town being VT.

Thanks for posting the rules for my lazy ass. And I would not take your bet.

I agree with this. I don't see a mod giving us a u pick game and making so many VT's.

Scorp, Enchant, Meg I now lean town on if I didn't already.

In post 727, Enchant wrote:Vanilla preference means you will roll Vanilla Townie for sure/Mafia Goon in most cases.

Where is this stated? you state it as an absolute so it must be written somewhere.

In post 729, Scorpious wrote:

In post 726, Galron wrote:

In post 713, Enchant wrote:I am not sure how many, but this reaction is unrealistic at all.

While it's possible moderator put up 8 MOTHERFUCKING PRs, i only can wonder how. I bet on atleast half of town being VT.

Thanks for posting the rules for my lazy ass. And I would not take your bet.

I agree with this. I don't see a mod giving us a u pick game and making so many VT's.

I agree with Enchant though.

In post 732, Galron wrote:

In post 729, Scorpious wrote:

In post 726, Galron wrote:

In post 713, Enchant wrote:I am not sure how many, but this reaction is unrealistic at all.

While it's possible moderator put up 8 MOTHERFUCKING PRs, i only can wonder how. I bet on atleast half of town being VT.

Thanks for posting the rules for my lazy ass. And I would not take your bet.

I agree with this. I don't see a mod giving us a u pick game and making so many VT's.

I agree with Enchant though.

have you much experience with u-pick? This is my first. Have you seen them loaded up with vanilla roles?

I've been thinking about doing this a long time ago, but I think it's time. They have been irking me from the very start of the game.

VOTE: Enchant

Here are some of 's reads:

In post 493, Enchant wrote:

In post 480, CheekyTeeky wrote:Enchant have you got any reads yet bruv?

Yes, i think Taly or Titus is good kill potentially. More dislike Titus though.

In post 605, Enchant wrote:What if team is actually Titus+Taly+House lol.

Like hm.

I doing it for points so when game ends and it actually happened to be this team, i could say "HA I KNEW IT FROM START".

In post 720, Enchant wrote:I am about Tyle+House+Titus btw, House still need to be tortured.

Like... why?! has been posting quite a lot this game, but among a lot of vibe posting, he's made numerous contributions to the game. I find his reads rather insightful and I'm willing to give a pass for them - at least for the time being. Even if these posts do turn out later to be easily manufacturable later on in the game, there's other players who are giving significantly less.

I had played with before, in my first game on this site actually - Newbie 2078, and in my opinion, she's being pretty towny.

Now, , is a different story. I also was voting , but it was more of a joke I couldn't resist making. I haven't made up my mind when it comes to that slot at all. I can see their posts as being made by both town and scum, so the only conclusion it's that they're NAI. I didn't like their sheeping of and buddying up to , but if that is where you got the conclusion of all three being scum, then I simply think it's a really lazy take. It would be way too blatant for it to be true. In my history of mafia games no mafia has ever played it like that. Perhaps, I am misrepresenting your point and got to the wrong conclusion, but this is where I think you got it from, as your posts suggest no other possible explanation.

____________

In post 543, Enchant wrote:Dwlee99 feeling self dirty after receiving PM, kinda sus

This never got a follow-up, but I'll assume that it was just a joke.

In post 728, Enchant wrote:ANYONE UP TO MASSCLAIM D1 ONLY WINNING STRATEGY STRAT?

As an actual strategy? No. As a joke? Also no.

____________

Sometimes it's just simple.

And as for them defending - I think that might be them anticipating a town flip of and trying to use this to look cleaner themselves. I'm leaning towards this being the explanation for their behavior as didn't really ping me hard as scum, and I would say that them reaching E-1 at an earlier point of the game made their elim look fairly likely.

And actually, here is another odd thing by themselves:

In post 604, Enchant wrote:Actually predicting Meg are town.

Or well, wanting get killed on purpose as bus.

This is a UPick game. Are you implying that picked a role that achieves their winning condition by getting voted out? Or that they're just trolling? Because the I know does not do stuff like that.

I think you just didn't think at all while writing the second sentence, and didn't see how this would stand confronted with actual game info and meta. I'm willing to assume that this was meant to be just a filler.

In post 734, Greeting wrote:I've been thinking about doing this a long time ago, but I think it's time. They have been irking me from the very start of the game.

VOTE: Enchant

Here are some of

Enchant

's reads:

In post 493, Enchant wrote:

In post 480, CheekyTeeky wrote:Enchant have you got any reads yet bruv?

Yes, i think Taly or Titus is good kill potentially. More dislike Titus though.

In post 605, Enchant wrote:What if team is actually Titus+Taly+House lol.

Like hm.

I doing it for points so when game ends and it actually happened to be this team, i could say "HA I KNEW IT FROM START".

In post 720, Enchant wrote:I am about Tyle+House+Titus btw, House still need to be tortured.

Like... why?!

Taly

has been posting quite a lot this game, but among a lot of vibe posting, he's made numerous contributions to the game. I find his reads rather insightful and I'm willing to give

Taly

a pass for them - at least for the time being. Even if these posts do turn out later to be easily manufacturable later on in the game, there's other players who are giving significantly less.

I had played with

Titus

before, in my first game on this site actually - Newbie 2078, and in my opinion, she's being pretty towny.

Now,

House

, is a different story. I also was voting

House

, but it was more of a joke I couldn't resist making. I haven't made up my mind when it comes to that slot at all. I can see their posts as being made by both town and scum, so the only conclusion it's that they're NAI. I didn't like their sheeping of

Titus

and buddying up to

Taly

, but if that is where you got the conclusion of all three being scum, then I simply think it's a really lazy take. It would be way too blatant for it to be true. In my history of mafia games no mafia has ever played it like that. Perhaps, I am misrepresenting your point and got to the wrong conclusion, but this is where I think you got it from, as your posts suggest no other possible explanation.

____________

In post 543, Enchant wrote:Dwlee99 feeling self dirty after receiving PM, kinda sus

This never got a follow-up, but I'll assume that it was just a joke.

In post 728, Enchant wrote:ANYONE UP TO MASSCLAIM D1 ONLY WINNING STRATEGY STRAT?

As an actual strategy? No. As a joke? Also no.

____________

Sometimes it's just

that

simple.

If someone's ideas sound just so wildly wrong then maybe they just don't see how wrong they sound for actual town because their POV is different?

And as for them defending

MegAzumarill

- I think that might be them anticipating a town flip of

MegAzumarill

and trying to use this to look cleaner themselves. I'm leaning towards this being the explanation for their behavior as

Meg

didn't really ping me hard as scum, and I would say that them reaching E-1 at an earlier point of the game made their elim look fairly likely.

And actually, here is another odd thing by

Enchant

themselves:

In post 604, Enchant wrote:Actually predicting Meg are town.

Or well, wanting get killed on purpose as bus.

This is a UPick game. Are you implying that

MegAzumarill

picked a role that achieves their winning condition by getting voted out? Or that they're just trolling? Because the

MegAzumarill

I know does not do stuff like that.

I think you just didn't think at all while writing the second sentence, and didn't see how this would stand confronted with actual game info and meta. I'm willing to assume that this was meant to be just a filler.

VOTE: Enchant
Good wagon and I agree that I don't find their defense of me likely to be genuine.

Also

Bruh

Bruh

Just bruh

Why i am again regreting not hammering.

Stupid town.

Also while this is "UPick", mod chooses PRs, so game will be balanced.


UPICKGAMEDOESH'TMEANTHERE'SFUCKINGPRSEVERYWHERE. Mod as well could add one or two and left mafia with just one PR as well.

It's basically "OH HEY MEG YOU ARE SUS
1. YOU CLAIMED VT WOW SO FITTING YOUR PLAYSTYLE I BELIEVE THAT!
2. WOW YOU CLAIMED PR WELL I QUESS YOU CAN BE KEPT ALIVE FOR A WHILE!

Literally it's so fucking lame unbelieving excuse even i can do better.

No just fuck, it's actually hilarious, can't believe you doing this. You probably can't see but every voice in my head laughs.

Also yes i expected it from start. Magician.

What, no more posts for you.

In post 699, Taly wrote:I'm okay. I just need to listen to Billie Eilish, put up this phone for now, eat, and do my virtual work.

Like there is a distinct lack of teamwork in this thread right now and that must be rectified.

Make a better townblock.

In post 739, Enchant wrote:Also while this is "UPick", mod chooses PRs, so game will be balanced.


UPICKGAMEDOESH'TMEANTHERE'SFUCKINGPRSEVERYWHERE. Mod as well could add one or two and left mafia with just one PR as well.

It's basically "OH HEY MEG YOU ARE SUS
1. YOU CLAIMED VT WOW SO FITTING YOUR PLAYSTYLE I BELIEVE THAT!
2. WOW YOU CLAIMED PR WELL I QUESS YOU CAN BE KEPT ALIVE FOR A WHILE!

Literally it's so fucking lame unbelieving excuse even i can do better.

No just fuck, it's actually hilarious, can't believe you doing this. You probably can't see but every voice in my head laughs.

Also yes i expected it from start. Magician.

huh? Also every voice here thinks you're scum, A, M, S and D. Even N and N doesn't play mafia actively.

When did we stop limming those who when forced to claim claim VT on Day 1 of a large especially?

In post 742, Flea The Magician wrote:

In post 739, Enchant wrote:Also while this is "UPick", mod chooses PRs, so game will be balanced.


UPICKGAMEDOESH'TMEANTHERE'SFUCKINGPRSEVERYWHERE. Mod as well could add one or two and left mafia with just one PR as well.

It's basically "OH HEY MEG YOU ARE SUS
1. YOU CLAIMED VT WOW SO FITTING YOUR PLAYSTYLE I BELIEVE THAT!
2. WOW YOU CLAIMED PR WELL I QUESS YOU CAN BE KEPT ALIVE FOR A WHILE!

Literally it's so fucking lame unbelieving excuse even i can do better.

No just fuck, it's actually hilarious, can't believe you doing this. You probably can't see but every voice in my head laughs.

Also yes i expected it from start. Magician.

huh? Also every voice here thinks you're scum, A, M, S and D. Even N and N doesn't play mafia actively.

Mafia NK this

In post 744, Enchant wrote:

In post 742, Flea The Magician wrote:

In post 739, Enchant wrote:Also while this is "UPick", mod chooses PRs, so game will be balanced.


UPICKGAMEDOESH'TMEANTHERE'SFUCKINGPRSEVERYWHERE. Mod as well could add one or two and left mafia with just one PR as well.

It's basically "OH HEY MEG YOU ARE SUS
1. YOU CLAIMED VT WOW SO FITTING YOUR PLAYSTYLE I BELIEVE THAT!
2. WOW YOU CLAIMED PR WELL I QUESS YOU CAN BE KEPT ALIVE FOR A WHILE!

Literally it's so fucking lame unbelieving excuse even i can do better.

No just fuck, it's actually hilarious, can't believe you doing this. You probably can't see but every voice in my head laughs.

Also yes i expected it from start. Magician.

huh? Also every voice here thinks you're scum, A, M, S and D. Even N and N doesn't play mafia actively.

Mafia NK this

please do, it means I'm on a streak <3

In post 699, Taly wrote:I'm okay. I just need to listen to Billie Eilish, put up this phone for now, eat, and do my virtual work.

Like there is a distinct lack of teamwork in this thread right now and that must be rectified.

Very interesting play shifts after the meg VT claim. It is probably best to eliminate Meg if they are VT tbh because it's better than limming a PR.

I don't like the shift onto Enchant, this is nothing like their scum games where they struggled to sync with the game. I agree with their push on house and see Taly as town now with that frustration hitting legit tones.

Didn't mean to quote.

In post 743, Galron wrote:When did we stop limming those who when forced to claim claim VT on Day 1 of a large especially?

Galron town too.

In post 739, Enchant wrote:Also yes i expected it from start. Magician.

I want this expanding on, it's the only reason G hasn't declared yet lol