Mafiascum.net

I cannot win--lol.

Post to much, post not enough.

Round and round we go. My guess is I am still a top poster. RIght now I am watching things and voting where I see fit. Hardly following a bandwangon. IN fact I was the FIRST to UNVOTE popsicle stick here.

Fine I guess we got all we will from BSS so I now

I'm not sure where to go on the recent events. blackshadowshade's "Gotcha! I knew somone would fall for that!"-line seems so cheesy. And he didn't even have a reason ready; he couldn't have assumed we'd all understand.

But I know we need to lynch someone and get it over with. I'm still happy with my PopsicleStix vote as I don't buy into his "guilt everyone into unvoting him" speech, but I don't really have any other reason to believe he is scum. Along those same lines, I don't have any reason to believe else is scum either, so he is still my prime suspect. That being said, I will consider picking a side on the blackshadowshade and PeaceBringer debate shortly.

Fish-- there is a debate?

Maybe a question--but harldy a debate...

Fishbulb wrote:

PopsicleStix wrote:I already said sorry for making a mistake by forgetting I was in this game. I'm not going to claim for people lurker hunting me, especially in the beginning of day one. Come back to me and ask me to claim when I've actually said something scummy. You all make me sick.

Yeah, you just said that you were sorry and left again. I wasn't voting to hear you claim, but to either get you active, or to replace you. Apathy is worse than lurking, in my opinion.

I never said wanted to hear a claim, I meant bloojay, back at post #40, I thought I already explained this but you must have missed

Me wrote:Actualy bss, Bloojay asked me to claim back at post #40.

Flishbulb wrote:

PopsicleStix wrote: If you don't like my attitude don't vote me for it, a lot of people don't like my attitude, they think I'm way too rebelious.

I really can't imagine who would think you were "too rebellious". Forgetting you signed up for a game, and even after realizing it, needing to be one away from a lynch before talking... How is that rebellious?

Uh, I didn't say was rebellious, I was talking about outside of the thread, in life, not the pot-filled one you live in.

Fishbulb wrote:

PopsicleStix wrote:This is your game, decide for yourself, but remember the conciquences.

Ooh, what profound wisdom from someone who can't even be bothered to pay attention to what is going on.

I'll say it for the fourth time, sorry for forgetting that I was in this game.
And don't give me any crap about how you were voting me to get me to talk, I did so maybe you should take the vote off me Mr. Pays attention too much to not even notice was the one who asked me to claim.

PopsicleStix wrote: I never said

you

wanted to hear a claim, I meant bloojay, back at post #40, I thought I already explained this but you must have missed.

Nope, didn't miss it. Just pointing out that while you were addressing those voting for you, you failed to address my points, the ones that I cared about.

PopsicleStix wrote:Uh, I didn't say

that

was rebellious, I was talking about outside of the thread, in

real

life, not the pot-filled one you live in.

Ooh, moving on to personal attacks.

Why relate how you act in "real life" to this game? I'd consider this a role-playing game, since none of us would act anything like we do in the game.

PopsicleStix wrote:I'll say it for the fourth time, sorry for forgetting that I was in this game.
And don't give me any crap about how you were voting me to get me to talk, I did so maybe you should take the vote off me Mr. Pays attention too much to not even notice

bloojay

was the one who asked me to claim.

HUGE FoS: Fishbulb

The whole point is, you forget you are in the game, but when you finally realize, you still didn't post anything worthwhile until right before lynching. I didn't want an apology, I wanted you to join in. Yep, you did join in, but in such a manner, as I pointed out recently, that puts you highest on my scum list. So, should I vote for someone who I think is scum, or just someone to get this game moving. That is my decision I have to make, and I don't like it. Hence the vote remaining on you for now.

I'd be playing super-careful.. posting plenty but not rocking the boat, unvoting to give people time to talk, like a good conscientious townie... if I lost my mafia buddy night 1.

I do what Tally says

that puts me at 4 i think

tell you what-- go ahead and lynch me and then you all can get the oh my god they killed kenny THE BASTARDS. cause I am kenny.

oh and a quick not that was sarcasm-- not suicidal but just wanted to let you know that I am kenny.

I would like to play and help figure out scum--but some of you may just have to kill me since I am after all kenny.

Now, wouldn't that be the ultimate sarcasm from Nanook -- kenny as mafia godfather.

I still haven't read anything to change my vote. As for your comment, Peacekeeper, about being the first to unvote PopsicleStix, wouldn't that fit if you were scum together?

PopsicleStix, your apology is accepted, at least from this player, although you're still high on my suspicion meter.

Lets lynch "Kenny" anyways and see what happens.

I assure you Kenny is not mafia!

I am not telling you what role Kenny was given.

Either you will choose to lynch me and the town gets to say OH MY GOD YOU KILLED KENNY YOU BASTARDS! or you don't kill Kenny and tried and kill scum.

My vote definitely stays on BSS cause after all he is very full of BS!

Fishbulb, on reading the thread again, I think that I should address your accusation in Post 76:



Did I not reply reasonably when someone asked me to explain? I always intended to explain my vote on Peacebringer, but chose not to right at that moment. Sure, it might have seemed a little out-of-the-blue, but it's simple psychology that surprising posts get reactions out of people. Otherwise, people simply sit around saying not very much. And after only one night, we all know that ALL the information we have to go on is people's reactions UNLESS a cop is willing to divulge information.

Of course, we can't even trust our cops at the moment due to sanity issues, especially in as wacky a world as South Park.

BSS your better off judging someones reactions based on knowing how they react- I would respond the same way to your crap in a majority of games and probably not as much if I was scum.

I am not scum.



I told you what will happen. You will get to say OH MY GOD WE KILLED KENNY WE ARE BASTARDS (revised for the accuracy of the action)

blackshadowshade wrote:Did I not reply reasonably when someone asked me to explain? I always intended to explain my vote on Peacebringer, but chose not to right at that moment. Sure, it might have seemed a little out-of-the-blue, but it's simple psychology that surprising posts get reactions out of people. Otherwise, people simply sit around saying not very much. And after only one night, we all know that ALL the information we have to go on is people's reactions UNLESS a cop is willing to divulge information.

Yeah, I understood your reasoning. But it seemed awfully convenient that as the pressure was building to lynch you, suddenly you caught PeaceBringer in a trap, that you couldn't even define right away. But, there's no way for me to know if it was you scrambling to get attention away from yourself, or a clever psychological ploy. For now, I will take your word for it.



Mostly because of his reactions claiming, and the fact that I could imagine Kenny as Mafia.

5 - Peacebringer (Talitha, Blackshadowshade, Internet Stranger, Bloojay, Fishbulb)
3 - Blackshadowshade (Popsiclestix, Peacebringer, Mr. Gnome it all)
2 - Popsiclestix (Jediknight, Tam)

I'm preparing to move my vote to peacebringer, but I thought I should wait and see if anyone would object to it at the moment (other than him)

I'll , in any case.

Kenny getting lynched Day 1 does seem quite appropriate. If he's town I will feel like a bastard, but no objections from me.

You mean bitch.

Talitha I am town and you will feel like bastards.

Nice work BSS you scum

You're hurting my feelings Pops.

But seriously, I take that to mean you don't want to lynch Peacebringer. Please state your position.

I still don't think that Popsicle has done anything that really convinces me to take my vote off him except deflect suspicion to someone else. But he has done that well...deflect suspicion that is.

PB is trying to figure out a middle ground from posting too much and not posting enough. I can respect that as it does need to happen. And his claim of Kenny should be able to be refuted if he is lying. This has not happened. Kenny is a role that would be in this game.

BSS is acting the most scummy in my mind. He's bandwagoning PB and his "gotcha target" in post 66 really concerns me.

Talitha wrote:I take that to mean you don't want to lynch Peacebringer. Please state your position.

Uh, I didn't say that.. But I just don't think he did anything scummy, if he does something truly scummy I'll vote for him, please inform me of what he's done and I'll respond.

jedi: Yes I think Peacebringer is probably Kenny.. but he could still be bad. Jesus was bad. Jesus & Kenny?? It's a possibility isn't it? My SP memories are too hazy to remember how likely this is.

And jedi, why are you not voting for BSS if he's the most scummy in your mind?

Popsiclestix: I said earlier that peacebringer was acting like I would be if I lost a partner on night 1. Nice and careful. Also some people have observed that he is acting differently in this game than he usually does.

well tally...i'll tell you why I'm not voting since you asked.

We've ran two bandwagons and gotten to the last vote on PB and then Popsicle. I am getting tired of running around. So I decided not to vote to see what would shake out.