So who, potentially, are my scumbuddies based on this approach?Zilla 73 wrote:I'm slightly concerned over the bravado behind Vi's actions. She's being quite proactive, but that's also a great spot for scum to be. I'm particularly interested in how she has been targetting certain players with certain questions. It gives the illusion of being really organized, or the appearance of having some kind of "master plan" for finding scum, which builds unwarranted town trust. Furthermore, the hyper-directed approach allows her to ask "safe" questions to scumbuddies while still appearing to grill them.
IGMEOY Vi
As for being "really organized" or having a "master plan", I think anyone who's been in a game with me knows that I basically play as I go, but the sense of knowing what I'm doing is a nice illusion to keep up
I think you're putting a bit too much stock in asking individualized questions.
Wait now. Nobody's said anything about Juls getting a free ride to endgame. Quite the opposite, most everyone has said that they're interested in judging Juls by how she acts.Zilla 60 wrote:I'm still mistrustful of something that potentially guarantees a free ride to end game, no matter what meta lies behind it.
The implication in the excerpt from PokerFace's quote is that Juls is lying aboutZilla 59 wrote:I especially don't like the underlined portion, where he says it would have been better not to provide another perspective and to agree that Juls wouldn't possibly lie.PokerFace wrote:A better answer would have been I don't think she would lie it's not in her character
(I'm also not sure if it qualifies as a chainsaw defense, though I'm sure you'll see this as one.)
-----
If you're in The Road to Rome, all of them.Gorrad 62 wrote:Serious question: How many setups with a cop do NOT have a GF role?
Otherwise... I've seen some. US Election 08 had two Cops and no Godfathers (though the Cops had strings attached).