Mini 247 - Zodiac Mafia - GAME OVER!
Forum rules
- GreenLiquid
- GreenLiquid
-
GreenLiquid
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: July 15, 2005
I'm confused as well, but at least it gives me someone to vote for
Seems rather scummy to just jump in and vote for someone without giving any reasons.
Vote: Yosarian2
Seems rather scummy to just jump in and vote for someone without giving any reasons.
Avatar courtesy of Chickadee! | GTKAL
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
Why is it scummy to vote without giving any reasons?
But if you want a reason, here is one.
When I voted for you, you had exactally 3 posts in the thread so far.
Second sentance is worse, especally the part where you declare yourself a pro-town player.
Out of your three posts, the first and third are filler at best and both are borderline scummy, and I don't like how you helped start the Phoebus bandwagon with a FOS...and then never even mentioned the bandwagon again, at all.
But if you want a reason, here is one.
When I voted for you, you had exactally 3 posts in the thread so far.
Not helpfull. At best, pointless chatter; at worse, you're playing guessing games with the doc. Either way, I don't like it.GreenLiquid wrote:So Tyfo is definately innocent? That role sounds sucky, it would make him a huge mafia target.
Quibbling about semantics to FOS Phoebus. And yet, you FOS'd him, but never voted for him.GreenLiquid wrote:Is anybody up for some role speculation?
Scummy as it may sound, it could be of use to us.
Libra is dead.
Virgo = innocent
The twins must be masons or we'd not have 12 players.
Cancer/Scorpio/Taurus = killers of some sort? Perhaps Leo along with them? He could be blocker/strong townie.
Aquarius = healer (water)
Sagi can also be killer.
Aries = blocker??townie??
Capricorn = copricorn?
For what it's worth, this were the lines along which I was thinking when I was contemplating a zodiac mafia.From my experience, and I've been scum a good number of times, speculation is one of the most used tactics by scum to appear pro town
Whaa?
FOS: Phoebus
First sentance makes little sense.GreenLiquid wrote:So it's a definate no-lynch at DL? Yikes!
I, as a pro-town player, still find speculation helpful. Remember that if the town uses synergy, it can do a lot better than scum.
Second sentance is worse, especally the part where you declare yourself a pro-town player.
Out of your three posts, the first and third are filler at best and both are borderline scummy, and I don't like how you helped start the Phoebus bandwagon with a FOS...and then never even mentioned the bandwagon again, at all.
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie
- GreenLiquid
- GreenLiquid
-
GreenLiquid
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: July 15, 2005
Good, that's all I wanted.
But...
2) I had no intention of starting a bandwagon, but it doesn't seem like it's going anywhere, so I see no need to try to get everyone to quickly stop it. I just found the Pheobus thing as something quirky.
Those last two post of yours seem quite very scum and reaching for some reason to vote for someone. I'm not going to vote you back just yet, but I think that there's something up with your desperateness to put on a vote.
Unvote: Yosarian
But...
Perhaps that's because I didn't think that was worthy of a vote, just worthy of pointing out.Quibbling about semantics to FOS Phoebus. And yet, you FOS'd him, but never voted for him.
1) First sentence makes little sense? I was simply commenting on the above post.First sentance makes little sense.
Second sentance is worse, especally the part where you declare yourself a pro-town player.
Out of your three posts, the first and third are filler at best and both are borderline scummy, and I don't like how you helped start the Phoebus bandwagon with a FOS...and then never even mentioned the bandwagon again, at all.
2) I had no intention of starting a bandwagon, but it doesn't seem like it's going anywhere, so I see no need to try to get everyone to quickly stop it. I just found the Pheobus thing as something quirky.
Those last two post of yours seem quite very scum and reaching for some reason to vote for someone. I'm not going to vote you back just yet, but I think that there's something up with your desperateness to put on a vote.
Avatar courtesy of Chickadee! | GTKAL
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
(shrug) We're going to lynch someone tommorow, at the deadline. When it comes to it, I'll change my vote to either of the leading bandwagons rather then have a no-lynch if I have to, but I don't feel very confident about either of them right now, and so I wanted to go back, re-check the thread, and see if I could find any thing else I could dig up in the 11'th hour, to see if I could generate a little more information and/or see if I could find a better lynch target before the day ends.GreenLiquid wrote: Those last two post of yours seem quite very scum and reaching for some reason to vote for someone. I'm not going to vote you back just yet, but I think that there's something up with your desperateness to put on a vote.
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie
After reading everything I think its best that I leave my vote where it is, even though I didnt put it there.
At the moment Phoebus seems to be the lesser of two evils, and sicne we dont exactly have much to go on anyway as it is day one, I cant see anything else to do as I dont think a no lynch will help at all.
At the moment Phoebus seems to be the lesser of two evils, and sicne we dont exactly have much to go on anyway as it is day one, I cant see anything else to do as I dont think a no lynch will help at all.
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
All right. I still don't really like the bandwagon that much, but it's better then a no-lynch, and the deadline is in a couple of hours so, as I promised to do
That should be 5 votes, which should be enough to lynch him at the deadline unless someone unvotes before then. If Armix has anything else to say, and if there's anyone else online right now, we could still theoretically stop the bandwagon before that or move it to someone else, but it dosn't seem likely.
Oh, and
unvote
vote:Armix
That should be 5 votes, which should be enough to lynch him at the deadline unless someone unvotes before then. If Armix has anything else to say, and if there's anyone else online right now, we could still theoretically stop the bandwagon before that or move it to someone else, but it dosn't seem likely.
Oh, and
FOS:everyone who's not voting
. Not voting for anyone when a deadline comes up like this is suspicious, I think, because only scum would want a no-lynch today.I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie
- GreenLiquid
- GreenLiquid
-
GreenLiquid
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: July 15, 2005
Deadline coming up. Looks like Armlx is going to be lynched regardlessly so
Vote: Armlx
Avatar courtesy of Chickadee! | GTKAL
If its not too late, I'll claim.
I am Leo. I am a jack of all trades. I have 1 RB, 1 doc protect, 1 vig kill, 1 cop investigation. There is flavor behind each, but I think some of it is kind of a stretch. Vig is obvious, RB is a lion's roar, and the others are related to some kind of sun god reference I do not understand.
I am Leo. I am a jack of all trades. I have 1 RB, 1 doc protect, 1 vig kill, 1 cop investigation. There is flavor behind each, but I think some of it is kind of a stretch. Vig is obvious, RB is a lion's roar, and the others are related to some kind of sun god reference I do not understand.
Away Wednesday the 24th through the 31st
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
Ummm...hmmm....
I wish you had claimed a little sooner.
As it is, there's got to be a way to test that claim...eh, screw it, I'd rather risk a no-lynch then lynch a confirmable townie, especally one with such useful abilities.
If you do manage to avoid getting lynched, armlx, you need to use your cop investigation tonight, and give us the results tommorow.
The way I figure it, if he's telling the truth, the town would be better off missing a lynch and getting losing a cop investigation.
I wish you had claimed a little sooner.
As it is, there's got to be a way to test that claim...eh, screw it, I'd rather risk a no-lynch then lynch a confirmable townie, especally one with such useful abilities.
unvote
vote:phoebus
If you do manage to avoid getting lynched, armlx, you need to use your cop investigation tonight, and give us the results tommorow.
The way I figure it, if he's telling the truth, the town would be better off missing a lynch and getting losing a cop investigation.
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie
-
-
Fuldu Mafia Scum
-
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: January 26, 2004
- Happy Scumday!
Umm...no. First of all, a one-shot cop investigation wouldn't confirm him, so you're suggesting giving him at least two extra days on the chance that this isn't made up. Secondly, this isn't as readily confirmable as you seem to think. One shot usages mean pretty much wasting one of them in an attempt to get a player confirmed. Cop and doc aren't confirmable in this way, so we're talking about a vig (always dangerous, and can be tough to disentangle from scum kills) or RB (runs the risk of blocking either someone without a night action or someone with an incentive to lie about having been blocked).Yosarian2 wrote:Ummm...hmmm....
I wish you had claimed a little sooner.
As it is, there's got to be a way to test that claim...eh, screw it, I'd rather risk a no-lynch then lynch a confirmable townie, especally one with such useful abilities.
unvote
vote:phoebus
If you do manage to avoid getting lynched, armlx, you need to use your cop investigation tonight, and give us the results tommorow.
The way I figure it, if he's telling the truth, the town would be better off missing a lynch and getting losing a cop investigation.
But more than that, you're getting bothered by the fact that this claim came so close to the deadline, but you move your vote to the other player who's likely to be lynched at deadline, making it highly unlikely that he'll have the opportunity to claim, if he feels it's necessary. That just seems inconsistent to me.
In any event, I'm content to leave my vote on armlx and if he turns up scum, I'll be taking a close look at you tomorrow. Probably even if he doesn't turn up scum.
It takes a village to raise a lynch mob.
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
No, it won't. But he's also claimed roleblocker and vig. THose are both easily confirmable claims.Fuldu wrote: Umm...no. First of all, a one-shot cop investigation wouldn't confirm him, so you're suggesting giving him at least two extra days on the chance that this isn't made up.
The reason I don't want to lynch him today is simple. He uses his investigation tonight, and tells us what is is tommorow. Eventually, we'll find out if he's town or scum, either through his death or through some other method. Once we do that, then if he is town, we know his investigation was correct, and at the very least he confirmes an innocent. That's a huge deal; at the very least, if we're going to lynch him, we want to wait until he uses his investigation and tells us the results first, just in case he is a townie.
Vig is easy to confirm. Roleblocker is often even easier, if there's either a pro-town vig or a minor pro-town role that dosn't mind being blocked. It's almost always a mistake to lynch a confirmable roleclaim on day 1.Fuldu wrote: Secondly, this isn't as readily confirmable as you seem to think. One shot usages mean pretty much wasting one of them in an attempt to get a player confirmed. Cop and doc aren't confirmable in this way, so we're talking about a vig (always dangerous, and can be tough to disentangle from scum kills) or RB (runs the risk of blocking either someone without a night action or someone with an incentive to lie about having been blocked).
(shrug) I realize that what I'm doing might make me look suspicious, but I think that it's also the right thing to do for the town. I suppose we'll find out soon enough.Fuldu wrote: But more than that, you're getting bothered by the fact that this claim came so close to the deadline, but you move your vote to the other player who's likely to be lynched at deadline, making it highly unlikely that he'll have the opportunity to claim, if he feels it's necessary. That just seems inconsistent to me.
In any event, I'm content to leave my vote on armlx and if he turns up scum, I'll be taking a close look at you tomorrow. Probably even if he doesn't turn up scum.
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie
-
-
Fuldu Mafia Scum
-
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: January 26, 2004
- Happy Scumday!
But these are one-shots. Those each require a) a target that we feel is appropriate, and in the case of RB, especially, that means somebody else has to come out and be willing to waste their night action, and b) that we're willing to waste one of those choices on getting him confirmed. And you're still talking about giving him two more days to live before we can even consider to what extent he is confirmed. At this stage of Day 1, I don't think that's worthwhile. I don't find this role entirely credible, and I don't think we're losing nearly as valuable a role as you seem to if I'm wrong.Yosarian2 wrote:Vig is easy to confirm. Roleblocker is often even easier, if there's either a pro-town vig or a minor pro-town role that dosn't mind being blocked. It's almost always a mistake to lynch a confirmable roleclaim on day 1.
It takes a village to raise a lynch mob.
- Bamboomancer
- Bamboomancer
-
Bamboomancer
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 781
- Joined: April 15, 2005
Sorry for not posting, It's finals week and this got knocked off of my list. After my last final I'll make an effort to read up.
Show
SIG TIME.
Okay, it's not BABOOM. It's not BAMBOOM.
It's Bamboomancer: like necromancer, but with bamboo instead of necro.
So to recap:
I am not a Baboom. I am some sort of bamboo magic man.
Okay, it's not BABOOM. It's not BAMBOOM.
It's Bamboomancer: like necromancer, but with bamboo instead of necro.
So to recap:
I am not a Baboom. I am some sort of bamboo magic man.
Hm, I'm not sure I buy armlx's claim either, but I'm not sure it matters that much. If he is town, isn't he rather likely to get killed tonight because the mafia would rather get rid of someone with dangerous powers than randomly kill someone who might not be a threat at all? At any rate, right now I'd still rather lynch Phoebus, who's seemed the most scummy to me.
- GreenLiquid
- GreenLiquid
-
GreenLiquid
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: July 15, 2005
Excellent! DL extention.
I'm not so sure I believe Armlx's claim. That kind of role seems really powerful. Could you at least explain the sun god reference?
For now I'll unvote Armlx though to play it safe.
I am Leo. I am a jack of all trades. I have 1 RB, 1 doc protect, 1 vig kill, 1 cop investigation. There is flavor behind each, but I think some of it is kind of a stretch. Vig is obvious, RB is a lion's roar, and the others are related to some kind of sun god reference I do not understand.
I'm not so sure I believe Armlx's claim. That kind of role seems really powerful. Could you at least explain the sun god reference?
For now I'll unvote Armlx though to play it safe.
Unvote: Armlx
Avatar courtesy of Chickadee! | GTKAL
- Yosarian2
- Yosarian2
-
Yosarian2
- (shrug)
- (shrug)
- Posts: 16394
- Joined: March 28, 2005
- Location: New Jersey
Well, yes, we might have to use one of his one shots in order to confirm his claim. It would be much more useful to do that then to lynch him, though, if he is telling the truth; after all, if he is a good guy and we lynch him, we lose all 4 abilities. If he is lying, which I agree is quite possible, that I don't see how he'll be able to fake those abilities he's claimed. Faking cop claims is tricky enough as scum; faking a role-block is really risky and difficult unless the scum do have a roleblocker; and faking a vig kill is usually impossible. If he's lying, we'll figure it out. If he's telling the truth, we'll figure that out to.Fuldu wrote:But these are one-shots. Those each require a) a target that we feel is appropriate, and in the case of RB, especially, that means somebody else has to come out and be willing to waste their night action, and b) that we're willing to waste one of those choices on getting him confirmed.
(shrug) It's day 1. I think that with the role he has claimed, it's going to be impossible for him to "fake" it for long, so long as we're willing test his abilities. In a few days, I think we'll know for sure if he's scum or not, it seems like lynching him before then is foolish.Fuldu wrote: And you're still talking about giving him two more days to live before we can even consider to what extent he is confirmed. At this stage of Day 1, I don't think that's worthwhile.
One single cop investigation, one confirmed innocent or one caught scum, improves the town's odds significantly in a game this small. At the very least, it should help the town's odds if we get his investigative results before we lynch him, just in case he is town. Besides, any confirmable role is a bad day 1 lynch, even if it's someting of fairly low value, becauseFuldu wrote: I don't find this role entirely credible, and I don't think we're losing nearly as valuable a role as you seem to if I'm wrong.
if we can confirm a person as a townie, that helps our odds.
Anyway, I'm glad we have a little more time; thanks, Mod. Like I said earlier, I don't really like the Phoebus bandwagon either, I only joined it because I liked it better then lynching a claimed cop or having a no-lynch, which appeared to be the other two options at the time. Now that we have a little more time, I'm going to go back to my main suspect.
unvote:Phoebus
vote:GreenLiquid
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie