Mafiascum.net

In post 74, Desperado wrote:Micro 112

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=25233

I just read it. The plan was target the person below. Town-Mollie didn't follow the plan because she "had a feeling" she wasn't a killing doc. Town won on D2.

That appears to be the most efficient way to do this, though--with the addendum that anyone who openly defies the plan should be lynched.

I say we go above.

I thought N and ohm were going to kill me. did we really win on d2? I just remember us talking an awful lot.

every1 targets the person above them. agreed? I will target that rat thing unless he gets lynched today then I will target jacob.

now back to scumhunting....

VOTE: rat thing

Desp, RM and AA9 all Town, townbloc sorted.

Claiming Doctor, I have no line of "I'm not sure will it work." So yeah, other Doctor on me.

In post 76, T S O wrote:Claiming Doctor, I have no line of "I'm not sure will it work." So yeah, other Doctor on me.

What does this mean?

...people claiming 'Doctor' are being anti-town at best, scum at worst. I'm down (or up) with that plan.

Yes, I like winning more than independent thought. Hush.

yeah I totally didn't get that post and would not cry to see him go. is he really saying he is not sure if the plan will work when we have evidence itt that it does? other doctor on him? wat?

mebbe its rat thing and tso

In post 78, JacobSavage wrote:VOTE: T S O

you on for the plan jacob?

In post 48, RationalMadman wrote:desperado it is obvious why, we can tell who is which doc

OMG, you should stop derping.. Seriously.!!!

In post 53, Squirrel Girl wrote:@Desperado - basically I'm thinking it's really similar to the Dethy setup insomuch as if we just get everyone to claim results and targets and no lynch until we're in a lylo situation then we have the most potential evidence to figure out people's roles and then puzzle out who the mafia are that way.

I'm not fully sold on the idea, as this seems likely a bit more complicated than Dethy, but that's my line of thinking.

Your arguments with Despo are just blunt...
Explain me what exactly you mean by "No lynch" helps us today...

Since no doctor knows who they are.. all their actions are sucidial anyways.. Lynch will probably hits a scum or a crazy doctor. I see that might do less damange them having CPR, Quak, Weak and Mafia someone manages kills on night 1

In post 59, penguin_alien wrote:Lynching is the only place where we can dictate results. Night phase, mafia has a kill, doctors don't know what the results of their actions will be. Giving up that opportunity is foolish, IMHO.

Agree!!!!!

In post 79, penguin_alien wrote:...people claiming 'Doctor' are being anti-town at best, scum at worst. I'm down (or up) with that plan.

Yes, I like winning more than independent thought. Hush.

Claim will not help in anyway..Everybody is a doctor..and am sure scum also would say..they are doctor!!!

...the point is that the more people claim Doctor, the more scum have their Nurse targets narrowed down. Since presumably the Nurse is the only one who will know what type of doc they are by the end of Night One.

arc are you on for the plan?

In post 84, penguin_alien wrote:...the point is that the more people claim Doctor, the more scum have their Nurse targets narrowed down. Since presumably the Nurse is the only one who will know what type of doc they are by the end of Night One.

right now anyone of us could be Nurse. Scum don't know that.. I would like to keep that in that way..
the less we talk about nurse, the better it is... I just hope "doctors" wont kill nurse in the night..


Bazinga.. You have my attention.. What is the plan?

In post 80, bazinga wrote:yeah I totally didn't get that post and would not cry to see him go. is he really saying he is not sure if the plan will work when we have evidence itt that it does? other doctor on him? wat?

mebbe its rat thing and tso

guess who just tried to take the low-hanging fruit? You and Jacob, especially you.

I'm obviously not so bad I'd claim real Doctor. The whole post was obviously bullshit.

You then tried to garner support for a wagon while not voting.

In post 86, ArcAngel9 wrote:

In post 84, penguin_alien wrote:...the point is that the more people claim Doctor, the more scum have their Nurse targets narrowed down. Since presumably the Nurse is the only one who will know what type of doc they are by the end of Night One.

right now anyone of us could be Nurse. Scum don't know that.. I would like to keep that in that way..
the less we talk about nurse, the better it is... I just hope "doctors" wont kill nurse in the night..


Bazinga.. You have my attention.. What is the plan?

every1 targets the person above them except for us, we are going to target the last person which is rat thing unless he gets lynched or jacob

In post 90, pirate mollie wrote:

In post 86, ArcAngel9 wrote:

In post 84, penguin_alien wrote:...the point is that the more people claim Doctor, the more scum have their Nurse targets narrowed down. Since presumably the Nurse is the only one who will know what type of doc they are by the end of Night One.

right now anyone of us could be Nurse. Scum don't know that.. I would like to keep that in that way..
the less we talk about nurse, the better it is... I just hope "doctors" wont kill nurse in the night..


Bazinga.. You have my attention.. What is the plan?

every1 targets the person above them except for us, we are going to target the last person which is rat thing unless he gets lynched or jacob

whoops

In post 82, ArcAngel9 wrote:Your arguments with Despo are just blunt...

So are my teeth, what of it?

In post 82, ArcAngel9 wrote:Explain me what exactly you mean by "No lynch" helps us today...

I don't think I said that, I did say I saw no lynch as a workable strategy.
Currently I am *up* with the current strategy and fully promise to do it. I feel like you're not really reading, are you reading?

In post 87, T S O wrote:guess who just tried to take the low-hanging fruit? You and Jacob, especially you.

So you came in, acted intentionally bad, and then decided scum would be more likely to vote you than town?
Heck, if I'd been here I would have voted you too, I don't see how that makes either of them scum. I already have Bazinga as townish, so I'm against that lynch even if I thought you might have something. Stop being a fruit (almonds? Yech!) and get with the program.

Everyone is going to action on the player above them in the player list disregarding any dead people.

We're also going to lynch someone.

what's the benefits of that plan, other than telegraphing what we're doing to scum?

PEdit: no I came in intentionally stupid, but still Town. Why would you auto-lynch a claimed real Doc?

In post 87, T S O wrote:

In post 80, bazinga wrote:yeah I totally didn't get that post and would not cry to see him go. is he really saying he is not sure if the plan will work when we have evidence itt that it does? other doctor on him? wat?

mebbe its rat thing and tso

guess who just tried to take the low-hanging fruit? You and Jacob, especially you.

I'm obviously not so bad I'd claim real Doctor. The whole post was obviously bullshit.

You then tried to garner support for a wagon while not voting.

Vote: bazinga

nobody knows what kind of doctor they are you dummy so there is no "claiming real doc"

if you were town you would know that

what is funny is that I had majiffy on the ropes in the first game but let him go for *reasons* for making a similar mistake

not gonna do it this time

VOTE: tso

In post 93, T S O wrote:what's the benefits of that plan, other than telegraphing what we're doing to scum?

PEdit: no I came in intentionally stupid, but still Town. Why would you auto-lynch a claimed real Doc?

the benefits of the plan are that it wins games

In post 93, T S O wrote:what's the benefits of that plan, other than telegraphing what we're doing to scum?

PEdit: no I came in intentionally stupid, but still Town. Why would you auto-lynch a claimed real Doc?

Telegraphing what we're doing to town also. It's not like scum know what effects our roles will have better than anyone else.

And... I'm not sure how to respond to this politely.
Basically we're all "Docs" (or claiming "Doc") so a claim of "Doc" is about as functional as a claim of "town" in a normal game. It means nothing, and we certainly better be willing to lynch someone who claims to be a Doc or this game will get rather bad rather quick. So what you did was come in, show that you were a player who was likely to be a destabalizing influence if town, and posted a rather null post - that makes you a rather perfect Day 1 lynch to my mind. I also asked Monkey Joe, and he agreed.

L-1

In post 94, bazinga wrote:nobody knows what kind of doctor they are you dummy so there is no "claiming real doc"

if you were town you would know that

You think Rational's lack of setup comprehension is different? I ask because I'd like to understand why you're full on torpedo on one, and didn't really even comment on the other.

No!