No.CK wrote:Fact: Mafia can only talk at night
If I was in the mafia, I would have to be breaking the rules of the game to strategize with my mafia budd y/ies. The purpose of a Day start is that the mafia cannot act before there is any voting, so they have no more time to strategize than the town has to figure out who they are.
It is not a
In the wiki article, it states that the mafia can talk at night. It does not say that it is
Both sides will appear strong. Each side plays to win. Having a tough view does not make one innocent. I’ve seen games where the mafia believes in an argument strongly. A player with a strong view tells us nothing; other than, the player plays to win.Fircoal wrote:I don't know Colonel Kurtz is scum, since he believes so strongly
Baseless, I disagree. And how are we to know if you were stalling—because you said so?chaotic_diablo wrote:Sorry, I'll fix the problems.Although it makes sense, it's still baseless. Your argument only holds in a limited fahion if you are correct that the "stalling" took place. Since opinion isn't evidence, it is questionable whether "stalling" was intended. There is no greater chance of me intentionally stalling than simply forgetting.BigK wrote:The reason, I believe it is scummy of them is because stalling gives them more time to talk. The mod didn’t set a limit for the amount of time to confirm, so the mafia won’t confirm right away so they have more time to talk and strategize. They got their roles and yet didn’t confirm when they had ample chance. They must be mafia.
On day1, it’s all about circumstantial evidence and plenty points at you and CK. As for simply forgetting, I think it interesting that someone could compose a logical argument and be so forgetful.
chaotic_diablo wrote:The evidence on the other players only include the things that you can document. While it's true that they did not post since Dec23, that doesn't mean they haven't been on the site. It just means they simply haven't posted. As a result, it can be predicted that those people will post and contribute the least.BigK wrote:Everyone (save Scalebane) confirmed right away without stalling. By right away, I mean no posts in other games/threads before logging out and beginning a new session. Here is the evidence:
That may be true in general. In our specific case, it is not. Most confirmed within a day or two. That time frame is about when people log on.
Note: I didn't cover everything I wanted to in this post. I have a paper due soon and must work on that. I'll get to what I haven't early tomorrow morning.