Mini 1579: The Great Flavor Caper (Game Over)

[Bacde]

Chaoslord instead of thinking more before you post you should actually think less, just post whatever comes to mind

It will help people realize that you are town

[reinoe]

@Elyse

I think that me being apologetic is not being scummy. It's just that since this is my first game I feel a little guilty because I feel like I was being influenced a little too quickly at the beginning of the game and posting too quick before thinking out my posts and I just don't want to annoy people so I'm trying to think it out a little more before I comment. That's why I also mentioned that for now I want to hear more comments before I take a vote.

So is this nervous town red herring lynchbait?

[Bacde]

What makes you think he is nervous?

[reinoe]

What makes you think he is nervous?

It's his first game, but just to be sure...


Chaoslord...do you have any mafia experience anywhere else online?

[Bacde]

Wordy? Yes

Nervous? No

I dont see it. If he was nervous i doubt he would be as forthright as he has been

[reinoe]

Wordy? Yes

Nervous? No

I dont see it. If he was nervous i doubt he would be as forthright as he has been

I think it's first game jitters. But I do agree that he's town for a different reason. Newb scum would have opportunistically tried to push Josh.

[chaoslord54]

Chaoslord...do you have any mafia experience anywhere else online?

Not really. Never found a good site until this one

[Bacde]

Wordy? Yes

Nervous? No

I dont see it. If he was nervous i doubt he would be as forthright as he has been

I think it's first game jitters. But I do agree that he's town for a different reason. Newb scum would have opportunistically tried to push Josh.

That would be true if josh was town

[phokdapolees]

Vote Count 1.03

Josh_B (3): Bacde, evilpacman18, Sharpest-knife-on-tree
Bacde (2): Josh_B, reinoe
chaoslord54 (2): Mirhawk, Elyse
Elyse (1): Wake88
Slandaar (1): TheYankeeReaper

Not Voting: Slandaar, JarJarDrinks, Damon_Gant, chaoslord54

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

Deadline in (expired on 2014-06-25 16:00:00)

TheYankeeReaper is V/LA until Sunday

[Slandaar]

Hrm.

[Bacde]

^^
Goodposting

[Elyse]

P-edit:
@reinoe

Instead of getting pissy at bacde for calling you out on sidelining, would like to comment on Josh B or knife?

It's not sidelining if people are discussing the merits of RVS and the analysis thereof.

Josh B? His posts aren't great and it looks like sloppy scumhunting. At least he's making an effort.

Sharpest? His vote is only the third on josh so it's no big deal.

Unrelated: I like Mirhawks thought process so we're on the same page there. It considers several possibilities instead of just of just locking into conclusions. With that being said.

You do realize your bacde vote is terrible, right? Are you going to pretend to stubborn and pretend to believe in it or are you going to remove it?

Also, if Josh B's posts aren't great and it looks like sloppy scumhunting, then why would you assume he is town? (This is in reference to saying newbscum would go after him)

Furthermore, if you think newbscum would go after Josh, then why isn't knife's vote on him troubling?

@Elyse

I think that me being apologetic is not being scummy. It's just that since this is my first game I feel a little guilty because I feel like I was being influenced a little too quickly at the beginning of the game and posting too quick before thinking out my posts and I just don't want to annoy people so I'm trying to think it out a little more before I comment. That's why I also mentioned that for now I want to hear more comments before I take a vote.

Ok...

So why didn't you vote for Slandaar if you thought Bacde presented a strong argument and then later substantiated it?

If you can answer this question to my satisfaction I will switch my vote to reinoe, so make it good.

[Mirhawk]

Chaoslord is cautious, that pretty much sums the whole thing up. Also, we both know what Chaoslords response will be and you'll have to unvote him afterwards anyways so why drag it out?

I agree that Reinoe's vote on bacade is weak, but why is he your back up vote?

[chaoslord54]

@Elyse
I first thought that Bacde had a strong argument only because his was the first in the game and since this is my first game I thought about it and realized that it sounded good but before I had a chance to vote I saw how many people starting commenting how it wasn't a strong argument and Bacde himself said that his argument was a weak one at best in post 43 and he also pointed out that I was taking the first page a little too serious so I decided that I shouldn't vote for Slandaar yet because people had already pointed out he was not actually being scum. That's why I'm taking my time before I vote now and why I did not choose to vote for Slandaar.

[Bacde]

Omg chaoslord is town hes literally explaining himself fully and it all makes sense from a town perspective, being cautious isnt a scumtell taken in his context. I would agree that hes cautious but its not because hes nervous, because he isnt nervous

Im pretty sure i know all three scum

[Bacde]

Unless one of them is lurking

[Bacde]

@mod can we get replacements for jarjar and damon please?

[reinoe]

P-edit:
@reinoe

Instead of getting pissy at bacde for calling you out on sidelining, would like to comment on Josh B or knife?

It's not sidelining if people are discussing the merits of RVS and the analysis thereof.

Josh B? His posts aren't great and it looks like sloppy scumhunting. At least he's making an effort.

Sharpest? His vote is only the third on josh so it's no big deal.

Unrelated: I like Mirhawks thought process so we're on the same page there. It considers several possibilities instead of just of just locking into conclusions. With that being said.

You do realize your bacde vote is terrible, right? Are you going to pretend to stubborn and pretend to believe in it or are you going to remove it?

Also, if Josh B's posts aren't great and it looks like sloppy scumhunting, then why would you assume he is town? (This is in reference to saying newbscum would go after him)

Furthermore, if you think newbscum would go after Josh, then why isn't knife's vote on him troubling?

1. Your vote is on chaoslord and it's a red-herring vote, so you're the last person to talk about "bad votes".

2. How do you know I'm assuming he's town? You see the part where several people are waiting on responses? That's the proper thing to do. I don't think Josh's post are so bad that he deserves to be at L-3: which I personally feel is a tipping point on a d-1 lynch. You do see the part where I said "at least he's trying" right? That doesn't mean I think he's town or scum it just means he's putting in effort.

3. I didn't like bacde's response. You do realize people have differing opinions on things right? You're being really presumptious and pushy too. You're making all kinds of assumptions about other players.

4. Newbscum would put Josh at L-3, that previously mentioned tipping point. The fact that chaoslord wanted to wait before putting down a vote suggests that he's not newbscum.

5. And I don't care that Josh had three votes because he's "earned" those three votes. His posting isn't great but I don't think he deserves to have a developing wagon: at least not before he clarifies a few things.

I'm fine with being asked questions but you make several leaps of logic in these questions. The fact that bacde and I agree on chaoslord for independent reasons suggests that my vote on him may be a bad one. Then compare that you your leaps in logic to build a case and well...

VOTE: Elyse

[phokdapolees]

@mod can we get replacements for jarjar and damon please?

Yep, in exactly (expired on 2014-06-13 16:00:00) (sorry for it being extremely arbitrary, but I gotta stay consistent)

[Bacde]

Yo dude you are working really hard to not have a read on josh

Saying that chaoslord is town because he didnt vote josh implies that josh is town, yet you claim to have no read on him?

[reinoe]

@Slandaar
Could you tell us your thoughts on the game?


@mirhawk
what are your thoughts on Elyse and Sharpest?


p:edit

Yo dude you are working really hard to not have a read on josh

Saying that chaoslord is town because he didnt vote josh implies that josh is town, yet you claim to have no read on him?

I disagree. You're going to have to walk me through that logic.

[Bacde]

Because chaoslord not voting josh being a town move only makes sense if josh is town. If josh was scum, and chaos was scum, wouldnt not voting josh actually be more of a scum move?

[reinoe]

it wasn't his RVS that gave him away. There are some other patterns there too that are interesting.

What is this?

it wasn't his RVS that gave him away. There are some other patterns there too that are interesting.

What is this?

I would also like an explanation of this. It looks like you were expecting bacde to continue the push and provide the reasons for you.

TYR I think you bring up some great points, before I cast my vote though I want to hear Josh_B's defense.

So Mirhawk, Chaoslord, and Slandaar are all either scum or town because they've chosen to wait for clarifiction?

[reinoe]

"CLARIFICATION".

[phokdapolees]

Titus replaces JarJarDrinks. Searching for a replacement for Damon_Gant.