Mafiascum.net

No. The 'seriously' in your post implied suspicion.

↑ This is my username wrote:Scum in general needs to be careful. He doesn't need to base his case just on my scumplay.

ding ding ding

↑ Ranger wrote:Actually,
{This is my username}
{TheTrollie, Postie}
{Rhaegar}
{Killthestory}
{PantherPunt}

This is more accurate.

how do you read this shit?

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ TheTrollie wrote:

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

[/u]
You made a scum read on me in post 27. If that had nothing to do with the post about lurking, please tell me EXACTLY what on the first page incited a scum read. Thanks

nah.

↑ Postie wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:The ole too scummy to be scum argument? That's how you're justifying a townread on TIMU?

That's... not really what he said.

It's how I read it. You can let him answer for himself though. That'd be cool

↑ This is my username wrote:No. The 'seriously' in your post implied suspicion.

Incredulity. Not a scum read. As in "how the hell do you rank order someone who hasn't posted?"

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ Postie wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:The ole too scummy to be scum argument? That's how you're justifying a townread on TIMU?

That's... not really what he said.

It's how I read it. You can let him answer for himself though. That'd be cool

That's not what I said.

↑ TheTrollie wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ TheTrollie wrote:

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

[/u]
You made a scum read on me in post 27. If that had nothing to do with the post about lurking, please tell me EXACTLY what on the first page incited a scum read. Thanks

nah.

"Nah?"
seriously?

WOAH....i legit did not realize until just now that my threesome is PP TIMU and I.

Sweet so ima ignore the two of you now and check back in once others start posting.

PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:No. The 'seriously' in your post implied suspicion.

Incredulity. Not a scum read. As in "how the hell do you rank order someone who hasn't posted?"

Alright. I think he put down Rhaeger because everyone else in Group 2 posted so he wanted to complete the list.

↑ TheTrollie wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ TheTrollie wrote:

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

[/u]
You made a scum read on me in post 27. If that had nothing to do with the post about lurking, please tell me EXACTLY what on the first page incited a scum read. Thanks

nah.

Don't do this, answer his question. This isn't useful at all.

BOOM.

and that just confirmed everything to me.

TIMU town 100%

Whatlol

Whatlol indeed.
VOTE: thetrollie

TIMU thanks for humoring my inquisition

↑ PantherPunt wrote:TIMU thanks for humoring my inquisition

Huh?

Thanks for responding to everything I've pushed you on. In comparison, you look much more town than trollie to this point.

His inability to explain his reads/logic and certainty with inconsistent logic paints him pretty clearly.
He clearly took advantage of your early read on me by piggybacking it. Said he scumread me for something other than questioning the lurkers. But when he scumread me in 27, that was about the whole of my content. When I ask him to expound, he says "nah." We both respond in a way indicating that that's not an acceptable response, but somehow he judges our responses on different rubrics considering your response made you "BOOM 100% TOWN"

It's just nonsense

↑ PantherPunt wrote:So I just skimmed the micro 580 6er. WOW at the 2 town self hammers. Can the other 5 townies in this game please make a promise to me that you won't do that?

Also, RC was terribly scummy in those first few pages but that might just be bias from playing with him as town before.

Has anyone here played with anyone else before? As for me, I've not.

Not hammering till we get to talk to his teammates

That isn't a bad point, Panther.

ooh, didnt mean to quote that post...i always do that
but I pressed quote on that cuz its what gave me a slight scum read, that just intensified and then TIMU sealed the deal by helping his scumread push me to answer questions about my scum read of him

the original scumread was his saying "the other 5 townies" as opposed to just like "dont self hammer people"

but his response to TIMU was aweful which strengthened the read, and then once i got involved it became obvious

and then sealed TIMU as town

I'll get myself going when I'm not on a mobile, and I can make some decent posts.

Panther in his group is obvious scum. no need for debate there. yet to see group 1 do anything, and my group has barely posted other than postie. Postie looks p town so far, and I'm just waiting to see what Rhaegar has to offer

Quick one, will catch up later: someone asked if anybody else played with TIMU.
I did in a newbie game, he was scum and was very lurky.
So I read his behaviour as town for now.

Anyone calling me obvious scum:
give a reason, make a case. I haven't seen reasons yet, just "Panther is scum" so I'm inclined to think all 3 scum are pushing that and others may be falling victim to perceived "thread consensus"

↑ TheTrollie wrote:the original scumread was his saying "the other 5 townies" as opposed to just like "dont self hammer people"

but his response to TIMU was aweful which strengthened the read, and then once i got involved it became obvious

So I'm scum for saying "5 other townies don't self hammer"?

I could buy that you thought I was "buddying" the town by trying to say that. I've made that accusation before when people say stuff like that.

But the you speak on generalities. Ie "awful responses" and "became obvious"
Cite something! It's so infuriating when people play the game this way bc some of them are actually town

↑ Killthestory wrote:Panther in his group is obvious scum.

no need for debate there

.

So incredibly anti town and very likely scum. how did you think saying this was a good idea?

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ Killthestory wrote:Panther in his group is obvious scum.

no need for debate there

.

So incredibly anti town and very likely scum. how did you think saying this was a good idea?

To be clear, if you were town, and incredibly sure I was mafia, then you should want to get all the "spew" you can. You'd want to see how others in the game interact with me and how I interact with them.

Writing me off just doesn't come from a townie solve-the-game mindset.
I'm more frustrated with this game than I've been with a mafia game, so I'm gonna step away for a little bit.
- id suggest an unvote so that Trollie can't hammer.
As a sign of good faith, I will UNVOTE: for now