Mafiascum.net

hmmm gotta reread joushi but he's read noob town to me so far

VOTE: innocentvillager

I don't like his iso.

In post 58, ironstove wrote:

In post 55, Transcend wrote:

In post 53, Enefpe no Time wrote:

In post 42, Transcend wrote:chill it with the walls please

a wall every once in a while is fine, but walling in every single post is going to make some players (me) not want to read you.

try condensing your posts

I like this guy

I like you too

I have a gut feeling that 1/2 or 2/2 of the players here are scum. I can see someone as a scum player writing this post sarcastically.

I don't know. I'm not seeing it. I agree with the wall of text thing. It's better if people are to the point and condense what they want to say. I don't want to have to sit here and decipher what appears to be in another language.

In post 58, ironstove wrote:

In post 50, Transcend wrote:There's no chance that I'm town that correctly town reads you?

You sound nervous and you're deflecting the questions by implying I'm mafia for asking them... 100% scum.

This does seem a little scummy. I don't know how anyone can be sure about anyone at this point. We're only on day 1 and there's very little to go on, except random voting and people nit-picking little things that may indicate scum or could mean nothing. So this stands out to me.

In post 65, Skold wrote:

In post 54, Enefpe no Time wrote:Skold is pretty town.

VOTE: Enefpe no Time

Ehh, I don't see how that really indicates anything. But it is weird that Enefpe gives no reasoning for any claims made. Like he/she is trying to stir the pot or something and then just vanishes. Weird.

VOTE: Enefpe no Time

@Transcend I've already decided that D1 lynch might as well be random because any information we have is purely theoretical with no statistical basis whatsoever. So Enfepe giving me a bad vibe is just a gutread which stands head and shoulders above the rest of the bad vibes.

In post 63, Joushi wrote:Care to elaborate? You made fairly sweeping accusations in 54 without a lot of quotes

In post 74, Enefpe no Time wrote:Innocent's reaction to me scumreading him is to weirdly focus on the fact that i townread skold. Evasive, tactical behavior. This dude is scum.

Skold is very non constructive in his tone, seems genuineish, hence town.

Joushi and innocent seem to be having weird interactions also

sweeping accusations without a lot of quotes

You seem to be under the delusion that i am the type of player who makes walls or inclined to address every little non issue that arises. I actuall have given quite a bit of information about my stances, my playstyle, and why i think the way you do. I dont think any "accusations" were made perse, just some pretty on point observations. If you look at your interactions with innocent, they do feel weird. This is my opinion. Im sorry that this flusters you? Its actually quite scummy to insinuate that i have given "no" reasoning.

The way i do* above post was directed at joushi, last sentence @ soula

In post 82, Enefpe no Time wrote:The way i do* above post was directed at joushi, last sentence @ soula

+

In post 52, Enefpe no Time wrote:First page in joushi and innocent are scumreads

Joushi heavy

And you never explained why Joushi was a heavy read. So Yes you supplied no reasons (unless I misunderstood something) and you're really scummy right now because of it. My highest read. It's already the beginning of the game and you seem to be floundering. Care to at least explain why Joushi was a heavy read? Or did you think you'd just throw that in there and we'd all just go with it and find our own reasons? I mean dang, if you are Town, you have an to convince us. Otherwise, what you're doing here is incredibly scummy imo.

In post 81, Enefpe no Time wrote:You seem to be under the delusion that i am the type of player who makes walls or inclined to address every little non issue that arises. I actuall have given quite a bit of information about my stances, my playstyle, and why i think the way you do. I dont think any "accusations" were made perse, just some pretty on point observations. If you look at your interactions with innocent, they do feel weird. This is my opinion. Im sorry that this flusters you? Its actually quite scummy to insinuate that i have given "no" reasoning.

How is anyone supposed to agree or disagree with what you say if you give basically no explanation for it? I'm not saying what you're doing is scummy, I'm saying it's bad play.

52 lists scumreads with no explanation. 53 is barely a post. 54 has some basic explanations, but there's hardly any good pressure put up there.

I agree, IV's response to the pressure is odd, but until 74 you just made unsubstantiated and incredibly general claims about everything.

Your play isn't scummy, it's just anti-town. I really hope you actually start putting actual effort into the posts you make or we're gonna lose.

Also Mori where are you

In post 76, karnos wrote:VOTE: innocentvillager

I don't like his iso.

What specifically do you not like about his ISO?

In post 86, ironstove wrote:

In post 76, karnos wrote:VOTE: innocentvillager

I don't like his iso.

What specifically do you not like about his ISO?

He was spending a lot of time writing "IC stuff" and clarifying the basics of the game and very little time actually scum hunting. The scum hunting I do see from him seems flawed, in the sort of way a scum would see the game. That said, I've never played with him before, so it might just be his play style.

His vote on you was bad sauce k-man and the rest of it was throwing shade and complaining he's not getting town read.

In post 86, ironstove wrote:

In post 76, karnos wrote:VOTE: innocentvillager

I don't like his iso.

What specifically do you not like about his ISO?

Will give you dog treat if you unvote me

In post 85, Joushi wrote:Also Mori where are you

Xalxe, do we have a deadline on this player? I guess technically this is 24 hours though...

Will give you dog treat if you unvote me.

BUMP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LETS PLAY SOME MAFIA GUYS WOOOOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Transcend and enefpe are mafia

Mori's replacement, rar is most likely town.

i assuem you tr her because you fos us

Ok I'm late

I didn't check this forum for ages; sorry guys. Am I definitely replaced at this point?

Not yet, no.

For the record, I really hate the complete lack of specifics in every post after 87 but it seems to me like that's just the playstyles I'm gonna have to deal with this game. :sigh:

karnos wrote:The scum hunting I do see from him seems flawed, in the sort of way a scum would see the game.

could you expand on this? my reread of his posts are kinda showing me an overeager IC more than scum. What are you seeing I don't?

Transcend wrote:Will give you dog treat if you unvote me.

Scoooooby snacks? You're currently still my #1 scumread, though. I'm rather convinced that you and EnT can't both be scum together though, as 53 is just too dumb to actually do as scum, but you two are definitely 1st and 2nd on the list.

A lot of people are fos'ing IV, and there's no way I'm putting him at L-1 while he's V/LA.

VOTE: Enefpe

L-2, voting for tunneling on IV and fairly unsubstantiated claims in 54, and super minimal answers/dodging questions in 74 and 81