Mafiascum.net

Deadline: (expired on 2017-08-24 21:02:02)

VC 1.02

Tarkus, Tucker Carlson, Shawn and Gus
Nazeebo
randomidget, RadiantCowbells, beeboy
Lucky2u, esires


Not Voting: The leftovers

With votes, to lynch

Tucker Carlson is being replaced cos banhammer

We just got told about the day starting.

VOTE: esires

-jj

Well... Banned for white nationalism... Turns out he was scum after all...

Random, the second point about stopping the wagon? On the surface it seems like a town thing to do, try to get the game on track. It's also low hanging town points for a scum to earn and IMO they do it more than town. It's pretty much why I avoided acknowledging my wagon, to see who would come to my defense.

fair enough.

I am miller.

In post 5, Tarkus wrote:Hey wassup hello I'm a miller
Hell = bad hombres VOTE: Lucky2u

In post 79, TwoInAMillion wrote:I am miller.

Vote: Tucker

Is two millers in a game common?

-Shawn

Probably not, didn't see that.

We have our first scum guys.

VOTE: Tarkus
-Shawn

Hmmm two millers idk about that. What's more likely: two millers, or scum claiming miller to avoid a check and mislynch me? Two for one deal seems awfully tempting VOTE: TwoInAMillion

Also I kinda agree with lucky re: randomidget, it does seem like a setup to throw out townreads with no weight then say it was to advance the game when questioned

Well, if you ended up being town I would be an obvious day 2 lynch, so the odds of me lying are slim.

What the hell guys, no lynch page 3? I thought we had a plan.

Unless you felt confident that you could wriggle out of that with enough time and more things to look at day 2. Two millers could be balanced I guess, but idk much about setup stuff like that

Sup kingmaker sorry to disappoint lol. Thoughts on this Miller Time Moment^TM?

Two millers are a uncommon enough setup to be considered bastard and worth lynching over. In fact, I have never seen to millers in a game.

Miller is pretty much a null claim - two millers are a bit unusual but still I don't think it's absolutely alignment indicative or bastard game.

My gut tells me second claim is always better than first though.

mm ok, I'll stay open to the possibility but 89 sounds really dishonest coming from a new player

How so?

You could say that about any claim. I looked up the wiki on miller and I've looked up other games with millers. It's called doing research. Now you're just grasping at straws.

In post 89, TwoInAMillion wrote:Two millers are a uncommon enough setup to be considered bastard and worth lynching over. In fact, I have never seen to millers in a game.

TRFB had two millers

It's the tone and confidence behind it that bothers me. Like you're really sure of yourself here when I don't think it's warranted. There's no hint of skepticism or doubt and it seems like you're pushing an agenda.

Is there a big list of previously run games and their setups that you looked at? I too have looked at the wiki and it doesn't mention anything about the commonality of multiple millers.

I am pushing an agenda to lynch scum.

Toy Story Mafia(Large Theme) - 2 millers
NY 159(Large Normal) - 2 millers
Mini Normal 1908 - 1 Miller
DoY I(Mini Theme): 1 Miller
Undertale Mafia(Large Theme) 1 Miller
Mini 1777 Varied Music Mafia: 1 Miller
NY 192(Large Normal) 1 Miller
Wedding Invitation Mafia(Large Theme) - 1 Miller
Secret Alt Mafia(Large Theme) - 1 Miller
Mini 1735(Mini Theme) 1 Miller
Mini 1699(Mini Normal) 1 Miller

In short, 2 millers in a large game is rare but not unheard of, in a mini game it is a one in million shot.

@tarkus but what does he get from CCing there

TIL 0/5 = 1/1,000,000

Rando I'm hung up on that. First thought was that he gets a chance to mislynch me based on just that claim and then wifom out of it later. It's risky though, and I've been trying to work out whether there's reward worth the risk. Doesn't really seem like it actually. Maybe I'm reading his tone wrong and it's coming from a place of "excited that my CC will catch 'scum'" confidence. I guess I could see acting like that if the order was reversed and he claimed first.

1 for 1 really isnt worth the risk
especially when the 1 is a miller

In post 97, Tarkus wrote:TIL 0/5 = 1/1,000,000

Rando I'm hung up on that. First thought was that he gets a chance to mislynch me based on just that claim and then wifom out of it later. It's risky though, and I've been trying to work out whether there's reward worth the risk. Doesn't really seem like it actually. Maybe I'm reading his tone wrong and it's coming from a place of "excited that my CC will catch 'scum'" confidence. I guess I could see acting like that if the order was reversed and he claimed first.

Why so serious?