Open 728: Sharing is Caring (GAME OVER)

[northsidegal]

Okay, NSG is town

where does that come from?

[ruru]

It took me longer than a couple minutes to go through his meta, so I'm assuming you'd already done it before I asked

[Almost50]

Sharing is Caring D1 VC #2

northsidegal (3): Mathdino, ofrhz, the worst,
Zoronos (2): davesaz, BlackStar,
pinturicchio (1): northsidegal,
Mathdino (1): pinturicchio,
ofrhz (1): ruru,
BlackStar (1): jjh927,

Not Voting: HeWhoSwims, Something_Smart, HitAlt, Zoronos,

[Zoronos]

This is my second game since 2016 or so, but the prior game I played NSG was in, as was SS. I presume she did the meta check during that game.
I played like crap during that game; I spent most of it wrong and stubborn, so if NSG seems short or frustrated with me (see her post earlier that I should step back from the thread), I’d advise taking it as NAI rather than a discredit attempt. It’s a reasonable town emotional response to how much of a pain I was in that game.

[ruru]

Oh well, I guess I'll just sheep Md's read then

Also before I forget, I propose we vote on which PRs use their night actions every day so that we always know what X is

Quickhammers are potentially extra dangerous in that they could obscure X

HURT: Cop:Yes JK:Yes Vig:No

I'm doing this for plurality purposes for now, I don't know if it's correct

[pinturicchio]

Mmmm I don't think that's a good idea, you give Mafia information on what PRs they should use... If we decide Vig shouldn't shoot, then the Mafia Doctor won't use his target either

[pinturicchio]

I think the best alternative would be vote who the vigged should be and then let the vig decide if he wants to shoot or nah; that way, if vig is shooting scum, either he (1) makes the Mafia lose one of their shots or (2) confirm someone as Mafia, since Mafia wouldn't protect a townplayer (I mean yes, they could to make some WIFOM shit, but that would be risky as fuck, like imagine they protect a PR or something)

[pinturicchio]

Nah maybe that's bad too, a PR would claim if he/she's getting shot so the scumteam would know who they could protect to create WIFOM shit

[ruru]

So the alternative is we randomly vig or don't vig and scum randomly docs or doesn't doc

The vig shot is still probably going to hit a town PR right? Considering scum might doc it (and also considering JK doesn't self-target)

Like I feel like knowing X is valuable enough to be worth letting scum save a Y?

PE: Yeah I don't think we can vote on the vig shot in this setup. Like consider a (suboptimal) scum strategy of just doccing every vig shot, regardless of alignment. Vig becomes a nearly useless role in this situation unless we vote precisely the doc. And scum can definitely do better than always doccing the vig shot

[ruru]

I guess since the vig shot is often evident, we could vote on cop y/n and JK y/n but not vote on vig at all. And then there's only an issue if there was a blocked shot (vig could maybe just claim the next day in this situation if knowing X seems important to the game state?)

[ruru]

Yeah, I guess that seems good to me

HURT: Cop:Yes JK:Yes

[the worst]

blink

[pinturicchio]

Hello Duckling <3 will this finally be the game where I see your scumgame?

[the worst]

Ruru strength of townread on NSG?

you wish sweetie<3

[ruru]

I'm not really townreading NSG anymore, my reason turned out to be silly

[the worst]

how do you find zoro's posting so far?

[ruru]

Evil-duck: Are you joke voting the worst

(as I am / was)

The bolded is a bit self-aware in a scummy way to me, but it's kind of a small thing

I don't know what to make of the rest of his posts especially without much meta knowledge

[pinturicchio]

ruru I think your townread on NSG was pretty good actually

[ruru]

Okay well my only experience with scum.NSG was that she posted like twice all game so if the RC hydra is any indication then I guess she's also pretty likely to be town here

But I'm not totally sure if that counts, so basically I feel like sheeping Md's eventual read on her will probably be more accurate than anything I can come up with, unless it's an extreme townslip like I thought she made just now

[Mathdino]

Are we talking setup?

Cop and vig act tonight, jailkeeper does not

Problem solved

Cop nullreads, Vig distractions, lynchbait and universal scumreads

[Mathdino]

I'm not 100% on her currently, sorry to say

Like the more I brag about me reading NSG

The more the observer effect comes into play

I can read her in games that I'm not playing in

[Something_Smart]

His posts are too long

We're not in RVS anymore...

It feels like he's trying too hard even though nothing has happened

This is playstyle.

HURT: Cop: YES, JK: NO, Vig: YES

[Something_Smart]

I'm not 100% on her currently, sorry to say

[ruru]

Cop and vig act tonight, jailkeeper does not

I'll have to ask you to explain this when I'm more awake I think

For now, why did you rvs NSG?

[the worst]

Isn't the answer to the question in the question? @ruru