Guns & Roses II Dead PT

[Firebringer]

yeah, nom is town here. Which makes their actions more and more questionable

[Firebringer]

The game is def over with claimed rose. I think FG should probably call it here.

this is partially a joke but bar scum doing something extremely dumb (not shooting croag), this game is def over.

[Firebringer]

nomonom is trying to signal so hard to croag that nom isn't really rose to get them to take it back............IT WONT REACH NOM

[Dunnstral]

Because nom shot at me n1 they're pretty much confirmed to be a gun and not a rose in mafia's eyes - continuing to lie about being a rose is questionable.

It's either gamma or nom lying in mafia's eyes but gamma fakeclaiming night 2 vig as town who shot already would be much more unlikely

[Dunnstral]

how have i guarenteed my loss if i am

a) night 2 rose
b) town gun

You're neither of these things buddy

[chennisden]

I'm not sure if Croag understands that counter claiming rose is a gauranteed town loss - Scum isn't afraid of hitting the last rose while they're immune, that's still their fastest way to victory

Nom is town? Fakeclaiming last rose and then asking other people to counter claim you is pretty much gamethrowing, not sure what the plan was there

The ONLY claim that should have happened all game was me claiming to have shot fire after he flipped mafia, and even that is questionable.

Tiphainedeath claiming to have shot chennis was really dumb as well. With 1 rose alive you shouldn't claim as a gun unless you'd be lynched otherwise

Tiphainedeath is scum lol

Since noms is town :/

[chennisden]

I think it's dumb as scum to claim that lol but she isn't town

[Bitmap]

I also never understood the scum read on Dunnstral and think shooting him N1 was bad.

[chennisden]

my b on that

[chennisden]

it should be obv that the majority of these shots are scum

idk why people r letting TD get away with what TD is doing

[chennisden]

People in the dead PT are either laughing, clapping, cursing, screaming, or a combination of those

im hurrt

[FakeGod]

nomonom is trying to signal so hard to croag that nom isn't really rose to get them to take it back............IT WONT REACH NOM

I have never seen this particular gambit to work out.

If you are town and you fakeclaim something to draw the nightkill... you are also going to be counterclaimed by the actual role and probably lynched.

I don't know what deliverance awaits nomnomnom postgame.

[chennisden]

Hey FG

Are u and FB trolling and nom3 is just scum

[chennisden]

I've never seen a mod who hasn't trolled with dead scum

[chennisden]

I finished rereading day1.

chennis was tunneling TD pretty heavily which makes me wonder whether the kill on chennis TD is claiming was factional and self-serving.

day1 is surprisingly scant for information overall

i wuv you popsofctown

[FakeGod]

But the fact of the matter is, you are either scum, or you are playing really really bad as town.

Hmm.. Isn't counterclaiming the correct move for Croag?

[Bitmap]

Not in this case because it's an instant loss when he does and Croag knows that.

[chennisden]

Fakeclaiming is also the wrong thing

[FakeGod]

Not in this case because it's an instant loss when he does and Croag knows that.

So what should Croag do in this case?

If nom3 was mafia, she has uncontested control over town today, and she can just feign being Night 2 Rose to justify her survival tomorrow. (If the game even lasts that long)

[chennisden]

Croag's in a bad spot

[chennisden]

Croag's current vote is good yeah.

[chennisden]

But idk if nom shut up about the rose it'd be better

[Bitmap]

Push a lynch on nom without revealing their rose status. Anything else is suicide.

[chennisden]

That ain't possible

[FakeGod]

Push a lynch on nom without revealing their rose status. Anything else is suicide.

That's impossible. She's an uncontested rose.