Mafiascum.net

In post 70, Servant Foreigner wrote:The best way to elect master would be to give it to person, who steals the most page tops as this person has to be active and vocal

hi

I assumed post 8 is clarifying what happens in post 0 since post 0 is fairly vague about what the "upgrade" would entail while post 8 is very specific.

I don't think they would get upgraded abilities and ***** ?

In post 63, Servant Alter Ego wrote:

In post 48, Servant Saber wrote:

In post 43, Servant Alter Ego wrote:

In post 35, Servant Saber wrote:I want to be the master. My strength is in the early game and I don't particularly like my noble phantasm.

But one of the upsides to being the master is being able to use your noble phantasm right away. Wouldn't it make sense to let someone who wants to use theirs have it, then?

Using mine right away is better than using it later.

I want to use mine to reinforce my reads and improve thread cohesion. It's much better used in the early game than late.

I see. I'm not sure why exactly you don't like it, then. Do you believe you'd be a good leader?

I do feel I'd be a good leader. I'm great at listening to other players and I won't have to fight to get my reads heard. I see so many stump games go sideways because ICs don't listen.

My noble phantasm involves me making judgments about what other people find useful. It's incredibly powerful if I use it right, but it's an action I don't take lightly. I might hold it to night 1 just to ensure I use it correctly.

In post 60, Servant Caster wrote:I don't think it's that bad if we hit mafia tbh

I don't think it's the end of the world either way but would strongly prefer having town. Scum being down a member to start the game isn't bad but they would likely take care to disguise all their interactions if they expected to flip early, so I don't see that angle as particularly worthy. Really I'd just like to have an Assassin v2.

I'm falling behind on getting townreads. Unfortunate.

Yeah okay,

Saber seems fine.

Did you read the flipped roles from the first game, caster?

Pedit-
I have agreed with most of Egos posting.

Nope I haven't read anything from the first game because I like having new experiences

I agree. I like Ego for town.

Alter Ego - what are your thoughts on being the one with a master - you look like you are building up the most town reads so far

I feel like I’m being pretty wishy-washy. It’s probably still better if I’m not selected, although I won’t say no if we’re prioritizing trying to hit town. I feel like I’ll be pretty obvtown which is good for that, but also I’ll be obvtown regardless and don’t need the master to confirm me per se.

Archer, are you thinking that because Saber may have TMI'd that he's a poor choice?

In post 77, Servant Saber wrote:My noble phantasm involves me making judgments about what other people find useful

Would you say it's better than a guaranteed cop-shot? That is my offer.

In post 85, Servant Lancer wrote:I feel like I’m being pretty wishy-washy. It’s probably still better if I’m not selected, although I won’t say no if we’re prioritizing trying to hit town. I feel like I’ll be pretty obvtown which is good for that, but also I’ll be obvtown regardless and don’t need the master to confirm me per se.

Glad I lucked into voting town correctly when the game started. Wanna be town buddies?

In post 87, Servant Assassin wrote:

In post 77, Servant Saber wrote:My noble phantasm involves me making judgments about what other people find useful

Would you say it's better than a guaranteed cop-shot? That is my offer.

Both would depend on the utility of the target selected. Mine could be better or worse depending on various hypothetical game states. I can't guarantee mine would be better than a cop shot, no.

In post 86, Servant Beast wrote:Archer, are you thinking that because Saber may have TMI'd that he's a poor choice?

Not really tmi - because that is not something that the scum team would know that the town wouldn't. Neither side would really know how our power levels match up.

It is more that it looked like they were overselling

Is overselling scummy or

I think Saber's sales pitch is decent so far, but I intend to wait until everyone has checked in and see what the options are before I lay down a vote.

Archer, Lancer, Egos all town. I could argue Caster either way, but it doesn’t seem likely scum is this.. off. At least not openly. I don’t like the posting from assassin and foreigner.

In post 88, Servant Beast wrote:

In post 85, Servant Lancer wrote:I feel like I’m being pretty wishy-washy. It’s probably still better if I’m not selected, although I won’t say no if we’re prioritizing trying to hit town. I feel like I’ll be pretty obvtown which is good for that, but also I’ll be obvtown regardless and don’t need the master to confirm me per se.

Glad I lucked into voting town correctly when the game started. Wanna be town buddies?

Why did you vote me originally?

I think I like the cop shot if we choose based on mech.

If we are choosing based on TRs tho, I am currently leaning Alter Ego

In post 93, Servant Berserker wrote:but it doesn’t seem likely scum is this.. off.

?

How am I off?

In post 16, Servant Lancer wrote:

Servant Archer wrote:What are your thoughts on being the master?

I typed out a whole response and then realized maybe it’s not good to explicitly talk about stuff. I don’t feel the need to be given a master (is that the right terminology?), although it would certainly be nice.

yourself?

This sounded pretty honest, without pretension.

In post 90, Servant Archer wrote:It is more that it looked like they were overselling

This is fair. I feel like I have a duty to go after the master role and that might come across as overselling.

In post 91, Servant Beast wrote:Is overselling scummy or

Unsure. I think that it means that they really want it though.

What I thought was scummy was ignoring my question.

Saber seems to think that their ability would be about on par with Assassins, so if we are making a mech choice, I would rather Assassin over Saber.