Mafiascum.net

In post 59, cyrus62 wrote:Lmao

In post 60, cyrus62 wrote:Lmao

Did you roll scum this game?

VOTE: Elsa Jay

Gut read

In post 71, humaneatingmonkey wrote:Hello excuse me I'm KittyTacky and I don't like wagons because wagons are scummy only scum make wagons

Not only scum make wagons in general, but scum often make wagons literally 3 pages in.

In post 72, nomnomnom wrote:

In post 68, KittyTacky wrote:

In post 67, nomnomnom wrote:You don't see my reason as legitimate?

Nope.

Why?
His initial hyperposting pinged me especially knowing he tends to be a very low poster.

Does he? He was pretty quiet in the last game I was with him where he was scum. He was limmed D1 tho.

VOTE: KittyTacky

> Votes me because I'm the third vote in the wagon.
> Obviously, scum makes wagons.
> And not only that, scum often makes wagons 3 pages in.
> I'm not even the third vote in the wagon.

This is what it looks like when scum is trying to fake a reason to vote 4 pages in.

KittyTacky, cite five Normal games in the past 6 months where scum made wagons 3 pages in.

In post 16, T3 wrote:

In post 13, Elsa Jay wrote:For a 17 person game I expected more people to show up in the first hour. I wanted three pages already.

It is 10:42 in the bEST time zone.

Yes it is, right now, but not when you posted

Hi Titus

VOTE: KittyTacky
Serious vote.
I remember the last game I played with scum KittyTacky he was nervous and made that known in the thread. The post about the wagons pings me the same way. It's also very unlikely that scum start a wagon 3 pages in and this just seems like being fake helpful.

ok I sheep
VOTE: KittyTacky
feeling much better about T3

This doesn't feel right, personally. Last time I played with Kitty he was a PR and made mistakes, so I don't know how much he improved but I wanna give him the benefit of the doubt this time.

I think that T3 scumtell would have yielded null results because we called it out too early

In post 86, Elsa Jay wrote:This doesn't feel right, personally. Last time I played with Kitty he was a PR and made mistakes, so I don't know how much he improved but I wanna give him the benefit of the doubt this time.

Tell us about Kitty

I've been trying to mimic my scumplay as town in that I actually case people in the post I vote them for.

Well last time we played I was scum (big shocker) and it was my first game back after my 6 month hiatus. It was a good game besides our Mod kinda abandoning us. Even as a PR he said kinda stupid ideas. He was a 2-shot town Roleblocker for context.

That game ended up having like 8 PR claims because all the PRs claimed early and all the scum also claimed PRs. So he kinda just... Let everyone elsa battle it out. He also had a big habit of literally ignoring my posts sometimes which frustrated me. So unless he improved alot in the last two months I think he's just an awkward but nice guy who sheep's people while trying to give town ideas.

So what's your read into his posts recently? How do you figure if he's just an awkward but nice TOWN guy who sheeps people while trying to give town ideas vs an awkward but nice SCUM guy who sheeps people while trying to give town ideas? What exactly about it doesn't feel right?

In post 78, KittyTacky wrote:

In post 71, humaneatingmonkey wrote:Hello excuse me I'm KittyTacky and I don't like wagons because wagons are scummy only scum make wagons

Not only scum make wagons in general, but scum often make wagons literally 3 pages in.

humaneatingmonkey wrote:So what's your read into his posts recently? How do you figure if he's just an awkward but nice TOWN guy who sheeps people while trying to give town ideas vs an awkward but nice SCUM guy who sheeps people while trying to give town ideas? What exactly about it doesn't feel right?

That might be from his personal experience. You gotta ask him that, HEM. Beginning the day defending someone rather then attacking seems about right for him, so I'm not making a hard read like you guys are doing.

This may also be bias but I'd rather wagon a more experienced player atm instead. Because while scum aren't known to wagon like page 3 (atleast alone and not RVS), they can easily help elim a guy early on. So I don't want a fast day by wagoning a guy and him breaking in pressure but then he flips town.

I can take a wagon so you can pressure me, but considering I'm a liar you know I won't claim VT anyway even if I am one, so I'd say go after a better player atm. Titus is a good player to be able to read early so I'm starting there.

VOTE: Titus

when you're not experienced enough for elsa to wagon you on day 1

It's not that. It's just better to have a player like Titus confirmed early on. She gives good townreads so knowing her alignment is a good way to avoid a headache. Sheep me on this nom, it's a good idea.

I'll think about it, I like my vote on Kitty right now!

Well, I guess Elsa can't be TMI about KittyTacky's town alignment because there are two scum teams in this game. So maybe if KittyTacky flips town, Elsa's town as well. Otherwise, if KittyTacky flips scum, there's an obvious connection to be made that Elsa is partners with Kitty.

In post 89, T3 wrote:I've been trying to mimic my scumplay as town in that I actually case people in the post I vote them for.

What for?

Honestly it's just a convenient thing to have your reasoning in the same post as your vote. Plus I guess getting out of a meta tell is a good thing if you wanna improve your social deduction skills.

In post 90, Elsa Jay wrote:I think he's just an awkward but nice guy who sheep's people while trying to give town ideas.

My scum detector is fully erect from this and it won't calm down. Intuition says TMI, but I don't know how TMI you could really be as scum in a 2-team game.

nom what's your take?