Newbie 1345: Mafia in a Bind (Game Over)

[Equinox]

Roles

The following two roles were chosen at random for this game: town cop, town doctor

Mafia Role Cop:

FSnake

Spadille

NicCage
Mafia Goon:

KingPin96

frog
Town Cop: theslimer3
Town Doctor: Voodoo Lady
Town Vanilla: Didi
Town Vanilla: MP5
Town Vanilla:

MontyWhittaker

Xiao Long
Town Vanilla:

RAMBO WOLF

Mutleyddmc
Town Vanilla:

unseencamo

Xegarus

Mac

Actions

Night 1

frog kills Voodoo Lady (successful)
Voodoo Lady protects NicCage (successful)
NicCage investigates MP5 (successful, vanilla)

Night 2

NicCage kills MP5 (successful)
NicCage investigates no one (successful)

Night 3

frog kills Didi (successful)

QuickTopics

Graveyard: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/hy8649i5yHhbV

The mafia may reveal their QuickTopic if they so choose.

---

Everyone should use this time to discuss the game and give and receive feedback for game play. Ask questions and see what you did well and what needs improving, and apply them to future games.

First off, thank you to everyone for playing this game, and special thanks to all the replacements.

Not much to add here, really, since much of it has been covered in the graveyard QuickTopic. Day 4 need not have lasted as long as it did; LyLo will always feel like there's more time for discussion and more things to examine, but, in this case, Xiao Long just gave himself unnecessary stress for three weeks. To be fair, though, I had hindsight. The ghosts did, as well, so don't take their criticism to heart

too

much. Props to frog for trying as hard as he did to spin the game to his favor. Many would have viewed that situation as a hopeless one.

I owe theslimer3 an evaluation. theslimer3, if I don't give it to you by tomorrow, then please PM me and make sure I do it. At a glance, though, I think you did fine, but your activity was a little lacking from what I remember; you were pretty busy at the time, anyway.

The thread's open for post-game discussion. Remember to be nice, guys.

[Mac]

My apologies for being shit town there, at least we won, can't believe you flipped a coin though. Thought frog was dead cert scum.

[frog]

Agreeing with Mac here. I was so clearly scum on D4 and flipping a coin is not the way to solve LyLo.

[Xiao Long]

lol, I was going to vote frog anyways, but I decided to flip a coin just to see what chance had to say about it. Chance also said frog. After I caught Nic D3 I was about 94% certain that either Didi or Frog was his scum buddy, and before I hammered D3, I was 98% certain Didi was town and frog was scum. I just let D4 play out because 1. I was busy with school and kept forgetting about the game, and 2. I wanted to make scum slip harder for my own personal amusement. At the start of D4 I mentioned I was most likely going to hammer you, Mac, but I kind of wanted to see how you two would react to that. Despite how sure I was, you were pretty scummy Mac, and that did mess with me a little bit, haha. I wouldn't mind playing another game with you lads, though.

[frog]

Also agreeing with Equinox, three weeks is good and all but spinning it out for as long as we did only to end it on a coin flip had the effect of making the game incredibly boring in its latter stages. D3 could have ended a week before it did and D4 could have been sorted in a matter of real life days. Water under the bridge, anyway, since this was a fun game overall and the people in it were excellent.

Props to Mac for not getting really angry (as I would have) in remaining in LyLo for three weeks with a guy who is practically confscum and who is spouting nonsense and getting away with it!

[Xiao Long]

You people are too eager to end games, I'd rather let it continue because your responses to each other were getting rather humourous.

[Xiao Long]

Reading the graveyard thread has me lolling hard, too.

[Mutleyddmc]

They weren't that humorous. They got rather samey. Well played mac and frog. Frog you were so close had you not gone for the win on day 3 I think you'd have won it! I learnt that I should have kept my read on kingpin knew he was scum!

[theslimer3]

I flipped a coin.

VOTE: frog

/).-
this was funny


I'll post my evaluation on the game a bit later after church/work... Or maybe not since I'm closing. I'll get to it!

Great game guys, and yeah, equi was right, the day lasted a little too long for the ending it got.

But thanks Equi for my first IC game :$

[Xegarus]

Hey look. The game ended. About time.
Good Job Mac. I had a solid town read on you from the start.
Poor slimer. You did well as IC.

[NicCage]

Good game, I had fun. Xiao, you're a tricky bastard, you know that? I should have known better than to vote, I saw you and frog online and I thought I had a chance. Should have just called you out for voting.

Sorry frog! You were a good partner, I think we would have won if not for me.

So what did we learn here? Trolling only hurts town, never do it ever.

[frog]

Don't worry about it, I should have been on the ball. The two of us can count this one as a win, I think we played well enough

[Xiao Long]

Good game, I had fun. Xiao, you're a tricky bastard, you know that? I should have known better than to vote, I saw you and frog online and I thought I had a chance. Should have just called you out for voting.

Sorry frog! You were a good partner, I think we would have won if not for me.

Haha, I got really lucky with that play, I wasn't sure if it'd work. Up until that point, I hadn't suspected frog much at all, and I only suspected you because of Spadille. You guys were fun to play with.

So what did we learn here? Trolling only hurts town, never do it ever.

+1

[Voodoo Lady]

This game... hadn't already ended?? Wow.

Anyway, I think we all did pretty well! I probably shouldn't have went after Mutley so hard, though.

[Didi]

Glad we all made the right call on D3, was a nice game, albeit a bit long. Well played everyone.

[theslimer3]

I'd say everyone did do pretty good.
Day one was quite the uproar because of Mutt's distraction, and my inactivity wasn't really one to help much.
Also the fact that none of us was in sync for the majority of the time as a bit of Chaos. Town's gotta be town, not attacking everyone and trusting no one >.>
But all in all, that ending was pretty disastrous. It's not mutt's fault, he didn't know I'd get hammered, and plus, it was just a little joke. I forgive yah, buddy.

Day two was chaos too. And mutt hammering himself wasn't helping much.
I think he's learned quite a few lessons too from this.
He hammered himself too quickly, and I'd say right in the middle of the town's theory moment. A very crucial thing and probably could have changed the outcome of day 4 (maybe by lessoning the time by a few weeks xD).

Day 3 had mutt out of the picture and it seemed to clear everyone's mind a bit more. Seeing a lot of key posts here. Glad town took it serious. Mac acted quite well. I think maybe Nick and frog should have bussed a bit more so it wouldn't be more obvious in the end. I think Xaoi was getting even more serious in this day.

Day 4
Pretty much this in a nutshell

Some good content, but stretched over time. Lots of waiting that seemed unnecessary when this could just happen

But good games guys. I suck at explaining things but hopefully you understood what I meant.
Good game scum. You might have bested us, but we survived! :3

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Last Post.