In post 751, TheIrishPope wrote:Breakfast at 9 PM?
Silly timezones
Bert, all I have to tell you is Wisdom is scum and NS is 75% scum
It's 10:49 AM. I'm done with breakfast now.
Why is NS 25% not scum?
Without looking back, I'll start off with one short post with brief feelings, hopefully that can get me going. I've kept up all through yesterday, but haven't been able to post until now. I'm disappointed with myself lol.
In post 659, TheIrishPope wrote:No, I am including the fact that scum chose a hydra to be the gunbearer for one reason only: hydra dissonance. Gives scum more chance to survive.
And they couldn't choose Kerberos because, you know, scum.
Point out where my logic is flawed.
You are right! It has nothing to do with what they've done ingame. I'm still right though.
PEdit: Yes Mara, that was my case. Why else would they choose Oil?
Second PEdit: Every hydra argues.
I write this with the greatest civility I can muster. For all I know, you could be scum, and you could have picked a hydra to be the gunbearer so that you could frame Kerberos the other hydra, killing two birds/hydras with one stone.
@notscience:
In post 671, Wisdom wrote:One of them may be, most likely Jacob. Need to hear more from them.
Why is bork town?
In post 673, notscience wrote:He seems to be actively scumhunting and bringing in new points that were overlooked.
Why do you think he's scum?
I think the key word Wisdom can see in your post is "seems to." Will you do us a favor and tell us what new points he brought in that were overlooked?
I agree. It's getting on my nerves. I got a chance to skim through the Cult game he recently finished with Arcangel. I can sense her frustration with what happened in that game. Initially, I ruled TIP as null/leaning town based on his excessive, overbearing tunneling sensational type posting. I don't trust what I think, and I hate how I can't reach a decision on him. I'm confused, and I don't think what he's doing is pro-town at all. He has me fooled if he's town, but the same can be said if he's scum. Please don't call me out for posting fluff for this because this is my thought process. I mean, why spam so much...it doesn't even help the game in general, then I/we have to weed through more posts and look for scummy tells...it makes looking through TIP's posts for content like looking for a needle in a haystack. Sorry, frustrated here too. Darn it. Okay, moving on.
And with that said I think TIP is not playing pro-town but I don't know if he's scum. UGH. I hate myself. I wish he were noticeably scum because then they would shoot him because he's so cutesy in his posting, but nonsensical, endearing in such a way, but also so damn frustrating. That'd be my dream. Bah, humbug!
I'm null on TIP but genuinely confused.
_______________
Part 2:
@Angel:
- Angel, thank you for joining us and telling us about your experiences with TIP. That is helpful, regardless of whether TIP was cult, mafia, whatever anti-town role in your specified instance.
I read your first post minutes after you posted, although I was unable to put forth any words together and make anything coherent and practical. I'm going to admit to you that when I read your first few posts, I wanted to tell you to please read the game again because some of what you said didn't make sense. I mean, I have no idea in hell if Bork is scum or not, but I had asked Bork the same question about leaving Jacob on/off his list. It's not your fault really though, well yes it is your fault for not joining this damn game sooner. So you deserved lots of "why aren't you reading" comments when you came in, for being so damn "busy" and not joining us sooner
@Wisdom
In post 665, TheIrishPope wrote:So you people are convinced I'm scum because I am scumhunting.
Seems legit.
Anyway, talk to Oil
In post 666, Wisdom wrote:Funny you're focusing on that of all things in the conversation.
Caught scum, methinks.
I really liked 666. Something about it felt genuine.
In post 492, Kerberos wrote:
You aren't taking a stance though which is odd because I have seen town wisdom take stances early on in the game. I am scum reading you for calling people out for Anti-town over scummy actions and for leeching off of other peoples reasons when making your arguments. The only thing that was your own was your little argument with Fege and starting up the conversation with me. Nothing you are doing reminds me of town Wisdom in the slightest
In post 493, Wisdom wrote:Except there's no such thing as town Wisdom; I'm tired of hearing things like that.
Looking back, I looked at cases made against you, Wisdom. Honestly, if the three heads is scum, then this case/meta makes sense for them to make so that they make can be putting dirt on you early so that you don't bleed obvtown down the stretch towards the end of the game. It's like a political commercial sorta. This is my total BS commenting at this point but honestly I have a headache and I need to stay active so what the hell I'm posting whatever I think because I'm grumpy and cornball emotional. You always sound so damn paranoid that it irked me without me realizing why. I'm trying to get used to it.
I think Wisdom's town. He/she has won over my trust. Maybe I'm just that gullible of a newb. If I'm wrong, well bollocks!!!!!!
@Don Johnson
( I wanted to type Lyndon
)
I had a feeling that there were scum partaking in an argument on 28 but I couldn't tell who when I saw those pages too. My gut still says Angel is being so damn defensive and it just looked so fake the way she was trying to instigate reactions. Is this her playstyle? I don't know her, and no I'm not using "not knowing her" as an excuse. I think it's just that Angel was SOOOOOO defensive. I mean, why so defensive when entering the game. OK I have not played with you before, but that was like so over-defensive. I mean, I thought Bork was pretty defensive, but you were more so and I was flabbergasted. Angel, it seems like you pulling I mean manafacturing cases out of your mind and some things you said made sense and some things you said didn't. You'll ask me what things made sense and what didn't. When you ask me that, I will go look back, your asking me will motivate me to look back. So ask away whatever you want to ask so I get off my lazy buttocks. But I will tell you I really like the point about Kerb and Bork and how people might rush to look at small contexts sometimes too soon, to his/her detriment. But moving forward, what really bothered me was:
In post 697, ArcAngel9 wrote:
Your unwillingness to give town reads!! that's anti-town. therefore, makes you most possible scum.
Why wouldn't you just say that's scummy? It just suggested that you didn't want to say directly that Wisdom is scum to you, and in my own wack wild world Wisdom is town to you. I hate myself for thinking this. I really do. I'm leaning scum on you. You brought new points to the table, I give you credit for that, but I still don't like the tone and feeling I get from your posts. Just way too defensive and not genuine feeling to me. Sorry if that makes no sense.
@Don Johnson
With that said,
In post 725, don_johnson wrote:a) i said: wisdom thinks jacob is scum.
b) wisdom says: you are not reading.
statement was actually correct, but you decided to try and make it sound as if statement a was not correct.
seeing as how you bolded your vote for jacob and have implied all game that your suspicion of jacob was serious, i kind of assume you would continue to bold your "vote".
p-edit:
who would you shoot first?
Why did you have to wait for Wisdom to say who he wanted to shoot, and then when you have to think a while before telling everyone else to shoot Bork? That bothers me. I'm leaning scum on you still, even if your posts make me laugh sometimes lol. But wait, there's more!!! (DING DING DING)
@Bork:
Don, what were you talking about with this "nice omgus" comment? I felt Bork's reply to me when I gauged his handle on me as sort of appeasing (not sure what to make of it), but nothing more than that?
I'm going to take a break and comment more on the others who I haven't talked about, and a break gives me time to mull over who I think should be shot. It's tough to decide and I'm out of energy from making this post - and this post sucks too, so guys please tell me what I can do to play better. Thanks.
