Mafiascum.net

In post 728, Chip Butty wrote:

In post 707, Smithereens wrote:Don't worry guys, you can shit all over me if it goes wrong, just put your votes on with confidence~

In post 710, Smithereens wrote:

Podo -> Trans -> Maru -> Aneninen. Use this flow chart in case I die tonight. Maru and Trans are interchangable

. Avoid introducing new names into the lynch pool without objective scum tells or

the approval of Ranger

.

In post 712, Smithereens wrote:

My scum reads are irrelevant

. My controversial actions stirred up enough people to drop a deliciously large amount of AI material for us to read through. I'm happy with the results, you would be happy too if only you were town.

In post 715, Smithereens wrote:

I've dropped the assumption that my reads are correct.

What are we left with? Pages of posts you've made that betray everything from your desire to lynch a person you've prior recognised as town to you attempting to reach for more reasons to substantiate a scum read that was falling apart.

And not just on you, Trans and Maru have dug themselves into pits as well.

Smithereens, you are confusing the fuck out of me. You seem def on your scum reads but see the bits in pink. And are you saying you def read Ranger as Town? Why? I'm not necessarily disagreeing, but I need to see reasons.

Good point: The schizotypicality is strong with this one.

Will catch up tomorrow

what's up with the vanity vote on Ranger?

i'm fairly sure no one will get enough momentum to be roped besides podo and Smith lol.

At least I'm trying to do something by reading the last couple of pages.

I don't know what to think of Podoboq's N5 Cop claim. Too lazy as scum and here's the crux of the problem. lazy.

In post 699, drmyshottyizsik wrote:I see you saying I'm a N2 cop guys, come on let me prove myself on day 3 or something like that. You practically claimed VT in a sea of PR roles that can't be CC'd.

That was terrible.
I'm pretty sure that Shotty's aware of the fact there can be Cops and Docs with the ability.

In post 710, Smithereens wrote:Podo -> Trans -> Maru -> Aneninen. Use this flow chart in case I die tonight. Maru and Trans are interchangable. Avoid introducing new names into the lynch pool without objective scum tells or the approval of Ranger.

I know this attitude. I've seen this before. Either he's town or he's genius-scum. He seems to be relatively new to the site, that'swhy I think he's the first one.

In post 731, Chip Butty wrote:Yeah, and I see Shotty switching between wagons. If podo/Smithereens is t/t and Shotty is scum, he doesn't care which wagon goes through...

I start thinking the same. Because of this and because of the post quoted above.

In post 744, Dunnstral wrote:[Chip Butty, Karnos, Transcend, Smithereens, DixC]
[SirCakez, podoboq, drmyshottyizsuk]
[Aneninen, PenguinPower]
[Ranger, MURDERCAT]

Bad list.

________

The problem is, that I'm much less confident about Podoboq than I used to be.
But I doubt we'd have enough time for a new wagon. Especially because we wouldn't be able to compromize.
Eg. I wouldn't lynch Ranger or Murdercat.
I'd pick Shotty or Penguin.

In post 752, Transcend wrote:what's up with the vanity vote on Ranger?

podoboq is town

smithereens is maybe maybe

Ranger is mafia

Care to join me?

Wat you're mafia too aren't you

meh

i just feel like ranger wouldn't get enough momentum given the way this game has gone

What in the world does that mean

no idea

whati 'm trying to say is

we need a lynch as opposed to a forced nl

and i feel like ranger wouldn't get enough votes to get anywhere near rope

so your vote feels kinda vain

most likely town's gonna mislynch today at this point

and given that podoboq has been giving genuine reads for town to work with over smith who's just been throwing shade.

i'd rather podo alive than smith.

yeah.

I would also want podo alive over smith.

^^^ So I've changed my mind basically, still don't really want to get smith as opposed to ranger

meh

VOTE: ranger

i just wanna see where this goes and i trust that if it doesn't get enough momentum that you'll rope smith

In post 728, Chip Butty wrote:

In post 707, Smithereens wrote:Don't worry guys, you can shit all over me if it goes wrong, just put your votes on with confidence~

In post 710, Smithereens wrote:

Podo -> Trans -> Maru -> Aneninen. Use this flow chart in case I die tonight. Maru and Trans are interchangable

. Avoid introducing new names into the lynch pool without objective scum tells or

the approval of Ranger

.

In post 712, Smithereens wrote:

My scum reads are irrelevant

. My controversial actions stirred up enough people to drop a deliciously large amount of AI material for us to read through. I'm happy with the results, you would be happy too if only you were town.

In post 715, Smithereens wrote:

I've dropped the assumption that my reads are correct.

What are we left with? Pages of posts you've made that betray everything from your desire to lynch a person you've prior recognised as town to you attempting to reach for more reasons to substantiate a scum read that was falling apart.

And not just on you, Trans and Maru have dug themselves into pits as well.

Smithereens, you are confusing the fuck out of me. You seem def on your scum reads but see the bits in pink. And are you saying you def read Ranger as Town? Why? I'm not necessarily disagreeing, but I need to see reasons.

Oi, you're not reading. Podo asked me to pretend for a moment that my reads were irrelevant, and while I don't believe that to be the case, for that conversation I told him 'let's pretend my reads don't mean anything.'

Of course I don't subscribe to this position. You could read that clearly from the posts. So why did you create this? ^^

Also, there isn't anything contradictory within those posts. You'll have to elaborate.

Dunn is looking as scum as his predecessor.

There's no case against Ranger. None at all.

yeah but i think podo is town

In post 765, Transcend wrote:yeah but i think podo is town

No you don't. As a town you would immediately recognise bullshit reaching when you see it, but you're not town so arguing this point with you is pointless.

In post 762, Smithereens wrote: Oi, you're not reading. Podo asked me to pretend for a moment that my reads were irrelevant, and while I don't believe that to be the case, for that conversation I told him 'let's pretend my reads don't mean anything.'

Of course I don't subscribe to this position. You could read that clearly from the posts. So why did you create this? ^^

No, I AM reading. You say you are dropping the assumption your reads are accurate, but then - based on the input of podo, Maru, Trans - you read them as scummy, IN THE VERY SAME POST. That is what is confusing me.

How can you say those three have dug themselves into a pit, unless it is on the basis of you reading them? Which means you have not dropped the assumption your reads are correct, at all.

In post 753, Aneninen wrote:That was terrible.
I'm pretty sure that Shotty's aware of the fact there can be Cops and Docs with the same Night ability.

I think you misunderstood Shotty's point.

In post 753, Aneninen wrote:I'd pick Shotty or Penguin.

Agree 100%

i doubt shotty's scum

i'd possibly rope penguin here

IME, it's the people who you feel like aren't actually doing anything who are most likely scum on day 1, not the people who had that "super obvious scum tell" that you noticed because you're a scum hunting god. Those people always seems to be town...

In post 753, Aneninen wrote:I'd pick Shotty or

Penguin

.

In post 744, Dunnstral wrote:[Chip Butty, Karnos, Transcend, Smithereens, DixC]
[SirCakez, podoboq, drmyshottyizsuk]
[Aneninen,

PenguinPower

]
[Ranger, MURDERCAT]

In post 770, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 753, Aneninen wrote:I'd pick Shotty or Penguin.

Agree 100%

In post 771, Transcend wrote:i doubt shotty's scum

i'd possibly

rope penguin here

In post 600, podoboq wrote:Readslist, in case I get lynched lynched

karnos
Maruchan
SirCakez
Chip Butty
Transcend

MURDERCAT
DixC
drmyshottyizsik
Aneninen

Ranger

PenguinPower

Smithereens

We've got five. Let's do it
VOTE: PenguinPower

In post 666, Ranger wrote:I'll risk it.
{karnos, Aneninen, SirCakez}
{Smithereens, Murdercat}
{shotty, Chip Butty}
{DixC}
{podoboq,

PenguinPower

}
{Maruchan, Transcend}

Ranger, it also seems like you should be fine with this.