Mafiascum.net

In post 7665, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 7662, Gloria Cleary wrote:You, Owno and Bell are all suspecting him,

Bell and I should never be getting a scroll so I can't shoot him.

You are thinking about this the wrong way. The right way to think about this is to assume for a moment that Pooky is scum? What is more likely to lead to victory? Killing tayl0r early or letting her live to the end where there are fewer other targets?

It could have been to paranoia us? But Titus was definitely trying to get him yeeted on D1 and had Toog scrolled me, because he absolutely would have if I hadn’t had been V/LA, he would be dead rn.

Titus didn’t try to talk Toog out of giving it to me, did she? I missed reading chunks of the game while I was V/LA.

Anyone recall?

In post 7673, Noraa wrote:

In post 7672, MURDERCAT wrote:There is one scum in here, I'm not going to let pooky live past today and have a shot at convincing Noraa that he is town over me. Kill us both today.

no wtf. didn't we agree that we shouldn't kill from the inner town block?

This only works if you commit to it and you have crazy paranoia.

Murder, ur actually just gonna leave us in a limlo with like uno(who still think I might be scum for ??? reason) and fidget(who I used to SR big time) and someone from the inner town block. That would be disastrous. No. we are not killing from the inner town block when we can literally prolly win the game today by going to UNO and fidget.

In post 7675, Gloria Cleary wrote:It could have been to paranoia us? But Titus was definitely trying to get him yeeted on D1 and had Toog scrolled me, because he absolutely would have if I hadn’t had been V/LA, he would be dead rn.

Titus didn’t try to talk Toog out of giving it to me, did she? I missed reading chunks of the game while I was V/LA.

Anyone recall?

Last scum left is a very different situation.

You do realize that @MC, right? If Toog had given me the scroll, Pooky would have auto received it because he was my last vote.

In post 7668, Gloria Cleary wrote:

In post 7663, Fidget wrote:Oh I forgot about an entire game mechanic that allows one person outside of Noraa/Bell to have a shot at winning

Oops

Can you elaborate on that? I think I missed it.

Scum can shoot one player. Let me see if I'm interpreting this right

Fidget gets scrolled (5v1)
UNOwen gets scrolled (4v1)
-
(Let's pretend Noraa is good as dead and is shot)
Gloria gets scrolled (2v1)
Murderkitty gets scrolled (1v1)
Murderkitty has to choose between Pooky/Bell for the win

Ah I was interpreting it wrong, I thought game would end on Murdercat getting the scroll in this scenario, but I think he still counts for wincon so actually nvm.

@Murdercat I'm pretty sure that Pooky can't win by being in top 3

In post 7677, Noraa wrote:Murder, ur actually just gonna leave us in a limlo with like uno(who still think I might be scum for ??? reason) and fidget(who I used to SR big time) and someone from the inner town block. That would be disastrous. No. we are not killing from the inner town block when we can literally prolly win the game today by going to UNO and fidget.

You still get to kill them tomorrow, you just have to commit to Bell. If you do that, the order doesn't matter. Killing Pooky gives you the highest chance of keeping Bell.

In post 7679, Gloria Cleary wrote:You do realize that @MC, right? If Toog had given me the scroll, Pooky would have auto received it because he was my last vote.

Toog was town though

In post 7674, MURDERCAT wrote:But I don't trust Noraa to take Bell over Pooky if it gets that far.

both are town so it won't get to that point in the first place. By the time we get down to like only the inner town block, it should be game over.

Like we all agree that it should be Bell and Noraa final 2 right? So then the order doesn't matter let's just shoot everyone else. I think Pooky has the best chance of wiggling into the final two as scum so we should take him out. If I though there was no chance of that happening I wouldn't care.

In post 7674, MURDERCAT wrote:Gloria Cleary
Bell
UNOwen
Noraa
Fidget

We go to here, and then we shoot Fidget, Uno and Gloria and leave Bell and Noraa final two. If we all agree to do that then the game is won anyway as long as Bell and Noraa are clear. But I don't trust Noraa to take Bell over Pooky if it gets that far.

Gloria is town. Pooky is town. We dont lim those ever.

In post 7678, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 7675, Gloria Cleary wrote:It could have been to paranoia us? But Titus was definitely trying to get him yeeted on D1 and had Toog scrolled me, because he absolutely would have if I hadn’t had been V/LA, he would be dead rn.

Titus didn’t try to talk Toog out of giving it to me, did she? I missed reading chunks of the game while I was V/LA.

Anyone recall?

Last scum left is a very different situation.

I’m saying is who besides Tayl0r tried to stop my scroll, because my scroll would have killed Pooky?

In post 7683, Noraa wrote:both are town so it won't get to that point in the first place. By the time we get down to like only the inner town block, it should be game over.

What I'm saying is that I don't think that is true...........
Or at least I'm not convinced of it

In post 7686, Gloria Cleary wrote:I’m saying is who besides Tayl0r tried to stop my scroll, because my scroll would have killed Pooky?

I don't think anyone was as concerned about your VLA as you seem to be

In post 7685, Noraa wrote:Gloria is town. Pooky is town. We dont lim those ever.

Shoot me then

Flea dont hand to murder

In post 7682, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 7679, Gloria Cleary wrote:You do realize that @MC, right? If Toog had given me the scroll, Pooky would have auto received it because he was my last vote.

Toog was town though

That isn’t my point. My point is who besides Tayl0r tried to stop him, any scum?

He's literally gonna take out an inner town block member and that's stupid

In post 7688, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 7686, Gloria Cleary wrote:I’m saying is who besides Tayl0r tried to stop my scroll, because my scroll would have killed Pooky?

I don't think anyone was as concerned about your VLA as you seem to be

Scum 100% ought to have been if Pooky is scum here, no?

In post 7692, Noraa wrote:He's literally gonna take out an inner town block member and that's stupid

I think if Murder is under the impression scum!Pooky can win by getting to top 3, and he thinks there's a chance that is the case, then it makes sense to get that elim while he can.

But I don't think that is true. Scum!Pooky doesn't win with top 3 and I assume you would side with Bell over him anyway.

In post 7680, Fidget wrote:@Murdercat I'm pretty sure that Pooky can't win by being in top 3

I am worried about this scenario. Let's say it is you with the final scroll. You have to choose who to shoot in Pooky/Bell/Noraa. Suddenly Noraa is confused. Maybe Shelly was bussing Bell and all that stuff was fake and it's actually Pooky who should be in the final 2. Noraa tells you to shoot Bell and because she is town you go with it. Pooky wins as scum. There is no one else who makes it to that point who that happens with.

In post 7692, Noraa wrote:He's literally gonna take out an inner town block member and that's stupid

He is missing my point entirely. My scroll death on D1, meant Pooky scroll death.

In post 7693, Gloria Cleary wrote:Scum 100% ought to have been if Pooky is scum here, no?

Once again you can town case anyone here and make a good argument. What we should be worried about is "which 4 do we want in the final 4" because someone would have to make a call there to win the game.

In post 7696, Gloria Cleary wrote:

In post 7692, Noraa wrote:He's literally gonna take out an inner town block member and that's stupid

He is missing my point entirely. My scroll death on D1, meant Pooky scroll death.

Did any scum try to talk Toog out of giving me the scroll?

In post 7696, Gloria Cleary wrote:

In post 7692, Noraa wrote:He's literally gonna take out an inner town block member and that's stupid

He is missing my point entirely. My scroll death on D1, meant Pooky scroll death.

For the record if I were scum, I would have never considered your vote being on Pooky during V/LA as meaning anything. Or at least I seriously doubt it. And I even if I did realize somehow, I also doubt I would go out of my way to defend you for it.