Nintendo Mafia (Game Over)

[Kdub]

PatB:
Their votes seemed quick and not well-supported by earlier interactions with Tragedy. Are you asking me because you disagree?

Dekes:
More people have taken a stance on Espeonage than on dana. dana himself has indicated suspicion of Esp. That is why I think Esp's flip will tell us more because there will be more interactions to look at.

Since the two lynches we've had have both been town, I'm thinking the scum are among the people who are lurking (If you want to be a jerk and call me out on this, go ahead, it should make you look more town) but clearly all of them couldn't be.

If the scum are mostly lurking, do you think that the people who were actively pushing the mislynches are more likely to be town then? Why?

[thil13]

More than likely, because it seems that we have somewhat of a zealous group of people here, and once they find somebody that drops a tell, and cracks under the pressure, they are all over that person.

[lewarcher82]

@mod:
1) how long can Espeonage keep prod-dodging?
2) last post by mb53 was on April 28. Can we get him prodded?

@everyone: I have some shit happening. I will be back to normal activity tomorrow.

[The Master Hand]

hmm I'm starting to see Espeonage, thil13 scum....both lurk, thil being the one to suggest it for tow cred, and he defends by playing the newb card and saying NOW i'm not lurking. If that is the case, thil, what is your excuse for lurking at the beginning?

As for me, I've been lurking due to finals, but now that that's over my posts should become more frequent, as long as andrius SAYS SOMETHING.
-

Toast

[chkflip]

VOTE: thil13

Case forthcoming; sorry, hard-pressed for time ATM. Next post will have this case as well as the overview of the last 30 pages that I've been working on since I replaced in.

[jmj3000]

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 9

Espeonage

- 6 - esuriospiritus, danakillsu, kdub, lewarcher82, Pinky and the Brain, crazypianist1116 - (L-3)

mb53

- 1 - RedCoyote - (L-8)

Ythan

- 1 - GhostWriter - (L-8)

Kdub

- 1 - Dekes - (L-8)

thil13

- 1 - chkflip - (L-8)

Players not voting: Bunnylover, Espeonage, mb53, The Master Hand, thil13, Xtoxm, Ythan

Deadline is May 22nd at 9 PM EDT.

(expired on 2011-05-22 21:00:00)

[mb53]

Hi, I'm sorta here. Been very busy lately, so I'm just going to make a quick post.

Vote: Lucresia's replacement

, for reasons I gave yesterday

Officially V/LA until Sunday. Going on a road trip

. I probably should have posted that earlier, sorry.

[Espeonage]

Phone line connected. Should be two days max for internet.

[crazypianist1116]

Will read within 24 hours.

[RedCoyote]

Alright, Mod. Everyone in your game decided to take a little break.

[GhostWriter]

Unvote

VOTE: Bunnylover
The other vote sort of served its purpose. This, however, should happen soon, since I really believe this slot is scum.

[danakillsu]

Unvote

VOTE: Bunnylover
The other vote sort of served its purpose. This, however, should happen soon, since I really believe this slot is scum.

Bunnylover, huh? Do you have some special reasons for that? Cause Bunnylover just plain always looks scummy, kind of like me (although I think that has diminished some over time).

[GhostWriter]

Keyword was the slot. I've mentioned this slot before. Seems irrational once you find it, but I believe it to be true.

[lewarcher82]

Bunny's slot was held by an absolute lurker... did you really find something scummy in the slot's ISO?

If so: what?

If you already explained it before, it probably didn't strike me as particulary interesting, because I forgot it. Can you at least direct me to the posts in which you discussed the slot?

[GhostWriter]

@Ash, something I find even more disturbing than the DBE wagon speed was the speed of the TMH counter wagon for such seemingly innocent reasons.

[Kdub]

Unvote

VOTE: Bunnylover
The other vote sort of served its purpose.

What purpose?

@Ash, something I find even more disturbing than the DBE wagon speed was the speed of the TMH counter wagon for such seemingly innocent reasons.

Considering that it happened on page 1, were you really expecting serious reasons to be given for the TMH wagon? Also, you were the 3rd vote (out of 4) on the DBE wagon, yet now you find the speed of the wagon "disturbing"?

[GhostWriter]

Now? Now? That isn't a recent quote from me. It was my reason for staying on the DBE wagon after RVS. However, DBE was never around, so there was no way I'd get support for it. While looking back, I realized that, with the replacement, perhaps now the wagon would fair better. And I don't really find the DBE wagon speed disturbing, I find the TMH counter wagon speed disturbing. No, I wasn't expecting serious reasons. However, with reasonings of wanting a RVS wagon to hop on, but not going for an already begun one, I became wary.

[Bunnylover]

GhostWriter, I'm a little distraught.
I mean do you think their scum on the TMH RVS wagon? If so wouldn't your vote be better placed on someone on that wagon? Also are you proposing that several scum decided to bandwagon on TMH to save a worthless player like DBE? I don't see the TMH wagon as a counter wagon towards DBE. I am disturb by TMH getting 6 votes on the first page, the first 3 votes seems like an RVS type of vote, but after that its more of people just bandwagoning.

Vote: MB53

[lewarcher82]

Unvote

VOTE: Bunnylover
The other vote sort of served its purpose.

What purpose?

^answer this, please.

[GhostWriter]

Giving me a better read based on reactions. Granted, most o the reactions were on what Thil said to Ythan, I'm gonna, in my mind, chalk it up to my vote setting it off.

[lewarcher82]

Giving me a better read based on reactions. Granted, most o the reactions were on what Thil said to Ythan, I'm gonna, in my mind, chalk it up to my vote setting it off.

You probably misunderstood the meaning of the question. I am not interested in what you think are your merits, but rather in the meaning of your being content with these reactions: does your unvote mean that you now think Ythan is town? Since you voted him to get reactions, sharing details about the results of your analysis would be helpful.

[chkflip]

I am

not new to the game of mafia

, though I am new to it on this site.

Yes, it's the

noob card

.

Do I need to mention why these don't match?

Chill out about my "lurking" what else do you actually have on me to call me scum?

this is exactly what I was talking about... every time I log on this game has 3-4 new pages to read and I just feel so overwhelmed by it that it doesn't feel right for me to post since I didn't have any part in them.

but I'm not lurking anymore, which is what should be noticed.

So you're admitting to lurking or aren't you? The first quote would say that you don't think you're doing it, thus the "quotes." This thought would be reinforced by the second post stating that you're only lurking by definition because of the frequency in which the town as a whole is posting. Then you flip-flop most recently by calling yourself out for something it seemed you didn't think you were doing?

Blatant OMGUS vote is blatant. No need to quote that, but it's noteworthy to my case against thil.

I'd like to hear thil's rebuttal to this much before I present more; I feel it helps my reads if I can get them to reiterate what I may be interpreting differently.

@All:

what is the concencus about catch-up posts? I don't want to post a huge wall of thought if people are going to simply overlook it or don't care to see it.

[Ythan]

Giving me a better read based on reactions. Granted, most o the reactions were on what Thil said to Ythan, I'm gonna, in my mind, chalk it up to my vote setting it off.

Pretty sure your vote on me didn't have anything to do with it.

[chkflip]

On Tragedy and Espeonage: Neither has impacted on me in any way to alter my reads of them from null. If one of these two are to die today, then i'm not too bothered which one.

This Espeonage wagon has grown far too quickly. I looked into him over the night phase, and i'm pretty sure he's town.

What changed?

Also, judging from your post you suspect there is scum on the Espeonage wagon. Any idea who?

I was just about to ask the same two questions, as well as:

Of the three people you mentioned in your ISO #3, which do you think is most likely to be scum? Which (if any at all) is misguided town?

[thil13]

So you're admitting to lurking or aren't you? The first quote would say that you don't think you're doing it, thus the "quotes." This thought would be reinforced by the second post stating that you're only lurking by definition because of the frequency in which the town as a whole is posting. Then you flip-flop most recently by calling yourself out for something it seemed you didn't think you were doing?

Yes I was admitting to lurking.
The games that I played on another site were a lot slower paced, and I figured that these games wouldn't be too much different, so I went ahead and joined multiple games, and quickly became overwhelmed.

The first two quotes you posted don't match, but not for what you are using against me. They are relating to two different things. The first just tells that I have some experience playing mafia, and the second is about my lack of ability to discern scum.