LET'S LAY DOWN THE LAW.
1. Colonel Guile ( Uberninja/guille2015 hydra )
^Town. Screw their content. Screw how little they've given. Screw having a scumread on their weak posting. I'm calling them town, my word is law, so live with it. Because I'm ticked off at the derps in this town and I'm going to trust my gut. Period.
2. Messiah *
^Scum. AND SHOULD BE AT THE TOP OF EVERYONE'S LYNCH LISTS. Name one goddamn thing in
Messiah's iso which is town. I dare you two, because there's dozens which make him scum, as I have explained before.
3. Slandaar
^Town. The suspicion on him is moronic and out-of-date. This is his town-self, and he's scumhunting mostly like a pro. Don't you dare touch him as being scum.
4. CryoNudist
^Scum. Cryo's content is empty and hollow. It's made to make people think they look good when they really don't. There's nothing in there but opportunistic posting. I don't mean opportunistic in the sense of 'lol vote largest wagon'. I mean opportunistic in that they're seeing a situation and taking advantage of it and manipulating it so that the town can destroy themselves. Seriously, I mean it, you guys are being idiots. There's no personal attack involved; this is simply a statement of fact.
5. Angelious Nero ( Nero Cain/ArcAngel9 hydra )
^Town. Seriously. This is Nero in his town meta. This is also Angel in (as far as I can tell) her town meta. Their reads are solid and well-reasoned. Their contradictions are a stretch at best, and attempts to discredit them are horrible-as-hell. Got that? They're right there up with Slandaar (slightly above him, in fact) and only slightly below AP in strength of my townread. So back off, go elsewhere, and help me lynch scum; they. are. not. it.
6. PirateCat ( Pirate Mollie/Malakittens hydra )
^We'll deal with them later. Okay. Town, scum, doesn't matter. They're on the backburner. I realize some people have scumreads, but there are an equal number of townreads on them. They can be put off for a day phase or two, because they're not getting lynched d1. I personally have a slight townread on them, though this is admittedly weak.
7. borkjerfkin
^Town. His posts are nice and solid, and he overall feels like a different beast from Posh Mafia.
8. Majiffy
^Piratecat, only more. He's someone who we can look at later, but he's not getting lynched d1, so stop pushing him. Hail the flowchart if he's town.
9. AngryPidgeon
^Number. one. townread. I swear to god, he's town. Screw me having misread him in one game. I've gotten better at it since then, and I'm telling you he's town here. He wasn't town at first because he was kind-of just...there...but now he's being his proactive town self, and I am NOT. GOING. TO. LET. HIM. GET. LYNCHED.
10. The Goat
^Town. Solid posts all-around, he's definitely a damn-strong scumhunter, and I'm not going to accept any accusations of him being scum.
11. Mac
^Town. Nero, I realize you're a good scumhunter, but you're wrong about Mac being scum. Those posts are pretty dang solid all-around, overall well-reasoned and putting things where they need to be. Not worth lynching for a long time, at the very least.
12. Approximately Normal Guy
^Scummish. I would be okay with a lynch on him.
13. Ms Marangal
^Town. Play's still scummy-as-hell, but claim is believable.
15. Jal
^Town. AP's right, this is toe-stepping on Jal's part. She's horribly horribly wrong on me, but she's probably town from it.
18. PeregrineV
^Town. AP's right, this is PV in his town self. His posting's incredibly solid.
19. qwints
^Town. Though his posts have been a bit minimalistic and sheepish, what little content he DOES bring is solid, and that's what I'd expect from him as town.
21. GuyinFreezer
^Increasingly looking like scum. His post about not knowing the flavor but asking about multiscum reeks of BS.
And you'll note that I eliminated Bitmap, KoC, and fitz; they're all null, and I can be swayed one way or the other.
But this is my word, and you. will. sheep. me.