actually these are kind of a composite of mine and borky's altho the thoughts behind them are my own. we talked a bit and some of these I am pulling off of our spreadsheet. majiffy has access to it too he just doesn't use it so I am not sure what the full scope of his reads are. I could be wrong but I think he might have bubba as scum.
players I have hydras with and know fairly well:
mala
of chamber of kittens: I don't like that they sub into this game only to immediately say, "see ya in 2 days!" but I will probably leave them alone unless they do something horrifyingly scummy mostly cos I have hit my limit with meltdowns this weak and if I am going to make mala meltdown I would rather do it at a time when I can rub her feet so that she will like me again. this will be my first game with chamber except for marathons but we have chatted enough so that I have a sense of his personality enough to go "beep boop" when he is actually being beep boop which I hope he does cos lets face it this game needs more fun. I really hope that they are town if they were it would be awsum cos yaye! mollie will have 2 people who might be nice to her in this game. besides jaqen.
desperado
of messiah complex: you know I totally forgot about them until cabd brought them up!
and that is very disturbing cos desp should have had a lot to say about the earlier drama especially since he has come up with this theory that for some weird reason people will sometimes lose their minds around me. I find it weird that he has said absolutely nothing especially since he could have either been more supportive of moi or try to smooth things over if he was townreading morph. we work well together and if we are both town between the 2 of us can pin down an entire scumteam very early and when I say early I mean d1. I am usually pretty good at reading him altho in the upick asofai I gave him a town read cos I was trying to get him to help me lynch his scummates and out of every1 I was scumreading he would be the 1 most likely to do it. biggest mistake I made cos nacho & co wound up sheeping the read (I died early) and messiah gained a lot of mileage in the game. formerfish is a darling that I do not know too well, he was pretty easy to spot as scum in marathons tho. all I know is they better do something amazing real quick or I am about to get pretty weird on them for being so lurky.
do you hear me messiah I am about to get weird on you guyz until you do something amazing!!1!
mac
: mac and I are not clicking this game and it worries me kind of. I liked his suspicion of kagami cos I understand how his brain works and I know what he looks for. I have a light town read on this slot, just wondering why we can't seem to connect. <---- it may look like I am not saying much about him but I will tell you this; out of all of my hydra partners he and I can post and you would never be able to tell us apart. we tend to think alike and so need fewer words.
lean town
players I have at least 1 game experience with:
bubbajack
: we have a light town read on him and when I say light I mean it is super duper fragile and of course majiffy is scumreading him. I thought he was pure scum in that epic mafia game mala and I hydra-ed in and then he town-flailed and then I think we lynched the doc lolololol. his thinking does not make sense to a typical ms player but if you peek though the surface you can some real potential there and some srs skill developement. the only thing that is bugging me is his townread on us. I expected him to go hot and heavy with majiffy and do a 1v1 but tbh (and I know some people might not think so but comparatively speaking) other than asking that we get replaced it is pretty mild.
so unsure mebbe town.
dramallama
: wait for it wait for it WAIT FOR IT. I think he might be town. I have no real way to quantify this read it is the closest to intuition that I come to but every time I read a post of his I just think town. he really hasn't done much this game except complain and I actually half-expected him to jump in during mine and fery's kerfuffle and scream "mollie is horrible! she is a horrible horrible person she will even accost strangers in the street with pleasantries and cheerfulness lets lynch her!". that he didn't sort of worries me and if he is scum then I will know he has this sneaky super power that makes my scumdar point in the wrong direction on him.
unsure mebbe town
kise
: now don't tell him, but I am seekritly in mafia love with kise and I was super excited when I saw him on the playerlist! unfortunately his familiarity with me is from pikman and he doesn't know that have been trying to recover from my ebil trollish ways and I bet this game has not convinced him so far even tho I actually haven't done any trolling. *sigh* it will be a love that is unrequited most likely but he is kind of in that sacred pile I have of don't you dare touch him if you even so much as look at him funny I will eat you pile. give him until d3 then turn up the heat if you are not happy with him but I am thinking you will be.
town
varsoon
: what is funny about varsoon is how incredibly confident he sounds in skype mafia and incredibly authentic when in the forum games I have played with him he gets a bit whiny when he is feeling left out. he is a player who likes to gambit I just think he needs to get some established cred and more solid skill level before he does it that way they have more potential to be successful and he will get the respect that he deserves. I am leaning a little scummy on him here, it is a light scum read but it is there.
unsure mebbe scum
.
muffinman
: anybody who is already townreading him needs to have their head examined. in monks and masons he looked so incredibly town that nacho and I bought it, hook line and sinker but lucky for us he was nked by the opposing scumteam. I guess luck is a strong word considering we lost that game to scum saki. he is up for a scummy for cunning manipulator or something cos I think he has managed to fool every1 who has ever played with him. in xeno2 I kind of felt very strong town vibes from him after I got over paranoia and here I am not feeling it. like I feel nothing. it reminds me of me when I have gotten just 1 too many scum role pms in a row and am fatigued. <--- that is how he is acting.
unsure could get weird on him any second. he might be scum.
gaiden
: gaiden was weirdly easy to read in marathons. like there was a game I should have been all
ack! ack! ack! he is a mafia flavour cop traitor something! and I didn't cos I trusted those good townie vibes which I could not explain in a million years.
I am leaning town mebbe but I want him to be a stronger presence in the game.
people I have heard about from other people but have never played with
:
kagami
: I don't even remember who turned me onto kagami but I have liked what I have seen in other games I have read/observed. she made 1 post that I liked but I am pretty sure I had to agree to give up a kidney in order to get it. borky swings wildly on that slot, not sure what majiffy thinks but I am kind of leaning possible scummy.
possible scum.
kazekirimaru
: now he is interesting. I played a game with him in marathons I think but what turned me onto to him was etl. we were thinking of adopting him. so I was kind of excited to see we were going to play a game together! so far he looks pretty town, borky has him as town and I think majiffy might too. he is also a player I can get super duper weird about later in the game but for now I think we say town. he is probably the only player we all really strongly sort of kind of agree on.
lean town.
the rest of you I am sorry but you have not made that much of an impression yet I do better with players I am familiar with. I hope we will have time to get to know each other! sorry things got off to a bad start.
also jaqen is IC so that goes without saying but I think he has really good instincts and some people might want to think about working with him.
It's kay, their hands are too small anyway!
