Mafiascum.net

Whoa, L-1? You're right, it is. Didn't even realize. , did you realize?

UNVOTE:

I'm not comfortable with a lynch this quickly

In post 764, KuroiXHF wrote:My guess is that they're choosing smart and is willing to put two and two together very well. Xkfyu was pretty good yesterday, which would make MoI a good fit at killing Xkfyu. I'd nearly expect scum of less experienced people to kill me as I'd suspect people coasting by and less active.

Can you explain this again?

Also,

In post 774, lilith2013 wrote:Do I seem like the type to hard bus?

Also, you didn't actually unvote.

No I didn't realize javajoe was voting moi

Hmm. Seems like Magna's on VLA so I'll unvote I guess. But yall please remind me to get back on this wagon when he's around to engage.

UNVOTE:

In post 772, KuroiXHF wrote:OK. I get a good feeling that Clumsy is town here. It's too early to do a complete reads list but I'd venture to say leans town.

SirCakez, you wouldn't be able to link us to that, would you?

http://www.blankmediagames.com/phpbb/vi ... 17&t=36624

Okay I guess that did count as an unvote.

Still, I think I want to spread some tentacles elsewhere (sorry for the weird metaphor I don't know how else to describe it I'm so tired) before returning to the Magna wagon.

I will be going V/LA over Memorial Day weekend. I'll be back on Tuesday.

Bold this time so Cakey doesn't miss it.

So I'm not sure exactly what to make of discussion on World 1 while on World 2 - feels like trying to be productive in a way that isn't relevant to whom we're actually lynching. So my vote isn't exactly random.

Being alive after being lynched seems weird to me, since I can technically still contribute to earth 1 by discussing it here...

In post 787, SnarkySnowman wrote:So I'm not sure exactly what to make of discussion on World 1 while on World 2 - feels like trying to be productive in a way that isn't relevant to whom we're actually lynching. So my vote isn't exactly random.

I disagree. Clumsy here is trying to look for an explanation for Xk to be the nightkill. Since we've only been in Earth One until now, the Earth Two scum team has to decide their kill based on Earth One play. It might be relevant to discuss Earth One play in this situation. I don't like that you're so quick to dismiss it.

VOTE: Snarky

In post 788, Javajoe24 wrote:Being alive after being lynched seems weird to me, since I can technically still contribute to earth 1 by discussing it here...

Okay then, thoughts on your final wagon?

I was going to compartmentalize discussions of the separate Earths because this is a little confusing but if we're gonna talk about Earth One, let's get that out of the way so we can lynch scum on Earth Two please.

In post 715, Clumsy wrote:I'm neutral good man.

In post 722, Clumsy wrote:

In post 720, MagnaofIllusion wrote:

In post 714, lane0168 wrote:Nobody is saying of they're the same alignment or not

Oh, were you serious? I thought you were RVS derping around.

Everyone is going to say yes. There is not a single motivation to do otherwise. Town in both are going to tell the truth. Scum on one world and Town on the other are going to lie. Scum on both are going to be truthful but it will properly suggest they were lying if they ever flipped. It would be tantamount to game throwing for scum to not do so.

Did you expect great things from your question? What answer that was at all alignment indicative did you expect to get?

In post 714, lane0168 wrote:Nobody is saying of they're the same alignment or not

In post 718, Javajoe24 wrote:Are you saying you are third party clumsy?

He’s making a D&D joke folks …

100% correct on all points. You guys need better hobbies.

@clumsy, to me, a town on both worlds says they're town on both worlds no objections. Cause what's the issue?

Town+scum avoid answering because their first thought isnt that they're the same on both worlds. It's that their roles are different and so they think about how claiming the same is what they should do, and what everyone will do. Plus there's the issue about claiming that they're the same, and get lynched as scum. Theres the thinking about how then people might think they're scum on both. Which isn't true of course, but that's the initial thought process.

My thinking is a town on both doesn't have to go through an elaborate thought process and can claim outright, or ignore as several people have

...Oookay? And no, scum will just say that they're the same, because that's what town will do. If they were scum in one, and got hung there, they would just say that they were lying in the other, whether they are scum or not.

It's like the riddle of two paths. 2 men sitting between the paths, one always lies, one always tells the truth. You can't just straight up ask them which way is the right way, because you don't know which one is lying.

Is Magna scum as well for post 720? Would I be scum if I just said "Yes"?

Your logic is very very flawed here Lane.

Why didn't you just say "Im town in both" or something like that? Why didn't magna just say something like that? Why did he go so I'm depth about why its such a terrible question. My logic may be flawed, but it's good enough for me as of now. Because I don't see why town in both wouldn't say anything other than "hell yeah I'm town in both" and that response doesn't make them town in both either, cause scum can say that. But I'd expect that to be the only town answer

Lane, are you scumreading both Clumsy and Magna for not responding that they're the same alignment in both worlds? Or just Magna?

No. That they did respond. And I don't like their responses. Magna here. Clumsy probably in earth 1

I can't answer for Magna, but for me, it's a useless question with a useless answer. If I was seriously going to answer of course I would say I was town in both. That goes for if I was scum or town. But because it was such a useless question, I made a joke about it. Why would only town answer that way?

"Plus there's the issue about claiming that they're the same, and get lynched as scum." But anything other than claiming as town (same) in both, would be working against them. They have no reason to not say they're town in both.

P-edit: If that's your major case on me or Magna, I think you're going to have a hard time convincing anyone of it.

Town isn't the only one who could answer like that. I'm saying I think town would only answer like that or just ignore it. Not avoid answering with a joke response or elaborate response about their issue with the question.

There are other cases for scum magna. And the are cases for you on earth 1. This is a point in the case. Not THE case.

How was kuroi's response different enough for you to not scumread him, as you haven't said anything about him?