Not voting (5): mikeburnfire, Holy, Drunken Piper, Skruffs, SensFan
With 5 alive it is 3 to lynch.
Hold on now, friend, let me take noteDrunken Piper wrote:Skruffs, so if Holy is on top of you list.
What are you waiting, for this I have missed?
Do you have questions for Holy or I,
or are you just waiting for town feelings to see who you want to push to die?
Holy was the top of my list until the above^
now I am wondering who really does wear the SK glove.
I just saw this post from right before the lynch. I already explained, in great detail, why the cop can not be the SK. This is the second time I've had to repeat myself for DP.DP wrote:if this could be wrong, please someone tell me.
but could the SK be a cop and the scum the RB?
There you go again, insisting that the mafia is a bunch of morons. Why would the scum protect a townie? They want town to die. It would be much smarter for them to NOT protect a townie, or even *GASP* protect themselves from the SK.There's no reason to think the doctor didn't actually protect thanatos night one, and that the sk tried to kill him.
I'm certainly leaning that way.even if it feels like you guys are setting yourselves up to lynch me, which is what i'm picking up on, now.
One mafia claimed to have a guilty on the scumdoctor, but he was already in a tight hole after being declared guilty by Thanatos and was probably trying to distance himself. And killing a mason while switching a mason role out is a good idea, IMO. Gets rid of a useless role.The mafia aren't morons? Are we talking about the same mafia, mbf? Didn't one mafia out another, or something like that? Didn't they kill a mason while switching the role of the other mason?
It's possible. Either that, or the SK tried to kill whomever the mafia doc protected. Both seem equally likely.That leaves the only death, which means that the roleblocker, the scum mason, the mafia, and the sk all targetted one person last night.
If there wasn't a serial killer to plug into the equation, I would agree with you. Also, the mafia cannot kill, block, and protect in the same night if there is only two of them still alive.Considering the mafia DID have the doc AND the roleblocker, it still doesn't make sense that they would kill a townie and block the cop, when the better choice, the more logical choice, would have been to kill the cop and block someone else while protecting one of their own, and then claim a RB the next day.
As well as the rest of page 3. If Sensfan is the SK, then he is doing a good job at acting like he has no clue how the game works, at this point. He's also suggesting something that - as the role opener - would be unbeneficial to him and (at that point) likely to draw a lack of doc protection AS WELL as mafia fire, if he was SK. So just on this post, I'm pretty sure he's not the SK. Later agreed that the directing of role manipulators was good; not sure if (as role opener) he woudl have agreed to that more as town or as scum. Also don't see him bringing up the possibility of the reopener or roleswitcher being one of those killed. Quickben screwed up (lol) when he said that we didn't know that the reopener wasn't scum (cuz he knew the doc and switcher were, lol). Later disstraction votes o nDP while saying he is being distracting; this is righ tafter DP says that we should focus on lynching scum instead of arranging NKs, as well as claiming unpowered/no-role. Not good for him.SensFan wrote:Since this is a (partially) open set-up, I think we might be best off with a full claim. The scum will have no choice but to claim their actual roles (or get busted on a 1-for-1 basis), and we can ask for everyone to tell the town what they did the night before, forcing the Scum lie. Ideally, we can catch scum in lies in a few days...
HEh, which is what Sensfan did at the beginnign fo the game, which is why I think her's prolly not scum.SensFan wrote:That is not WIFOM in the slightest. WIFOM would be if he bussed a buddy, with the hopes of looking Town later on. What he did is STRICTLY WORSE than his other options as scum: he would alert the town of his theory, and it has ZERO chance of getting others to look favorably upon him.kabenon007 wrote:Yeah, but that can dip into WIFOM for the record... but I agree that Korlash is seeming mostly townie to me.