Newbie 1867 - Game Over

[Scioness Sajj]

Well Rampage is a more likely scum candidate... that's some potential info--lol. And (though it seems obvious) now we know that Ircher is town. Had rampage flipped green and we went into day 2, there is a good chance some of us would still be leaning scum on him.

yeah okay but that's in NO WAY is an argument for ircher lynch. i don't understand.

[vulcan logician]

You got anything to say other than a simple lynch prediction Rampage? Seems odd that you pop in with a comment then clam up.

Yes, I read all the EOD stuff after Ircher's flip. Anything pop out at you?

Here is something: I'm leaning town on you Scion for trying to protect Ircher there,

[vulcan logician]

Well Rampage is a more likely scum candidate... that's some potential info--lol. And (though it seems obvious) now we know that Ircher is town. Had rampage flipped green and we went into day 2, there is a good chance some of us would still be leaning scum on him.

yeah okay but that's in NO WAY is an argument for ircher lynch. i don't understand.

Look, if you're asking me to justify my part in the Ircher wagon, it seemed like he was most likely scum using the best of my intuitive powers. I was willing to hammer rampage too... it was EOD and we needed a lynch. I went with my gut.

I try to use deduction whenever possible, because (as evidenced) my gut is often wrong.

[vulcan logician]

Look at it this way. Players that read scum (when they are town) give the real scum a place to hide... and someone to target.

If you think that there is a (ballpark) 25% chance Rampage is town then he is worth examining. I really don't like how he popped in said one thing and then left either.

[Scioness Sajj]

i didn't read anything really, thought i'd be too much effort in case are die

p.edit - no, it's just i remember somebody(s) using an argument that ircher will be good info flip. i don't remember who was it exactly but i plan on keeping them accountable.

okay, so my math looks like this:
7 players - me = 6

6 = 2s + 4 town

sooo 25% he is town? i'm not sure how i got that number lmao sorry

[Scioness Sajj]

1/3 that he is scum?????

help

[Scioness Sajj]

I really don't like how he popped in said one thing and then left either.

yeah, well i guess that's how rampage is going to play this game?

[Scioness Sajj]

wish i knew how to read nsg would make poe so much easier

[northsidegal]

huh

[Scioness Sajj]

[vulcan logician]

LOL. I hate math. Let me save you the trouble of tracking the player down. I pushed Ircher as a good info flip. I missed it if somebody else did-- but that was me.

What's up with nancy being the NK? Didn't predict her...

[vulcan logician]

what are your thoughts on the flip nsg?

[vulcan logician]

@Huntress & everyone: My other game finished up so I won't flake anymore. Sorry about that. Now I know--- I only have time for one mafia game in my schedule. Sorry about before.

[northsidegal]

Mafia Rolecop

Ircher (Vanilla townie) was lynched Day One.

It is now Night One.

Deadline for Night One is Wednesday, 23th May, 10.15pm BST, (in (expired on 2018-05-23 22:15:00)).

well, for one,

this

bothers me a lot.

[Scioness Sajj]

why would it?

[northsidegal]

i feel like rampage just has to be the lynch here?

like, i still have to go back to see how much ircher/rampage looked like T/S vs T/T, but even then i'm not sure how comfortable i'd be bringing him to lylo.

[Scioness Sajj]

LOL. I hate math. Let me save you the trouble of tracking the player down. I pushed Ircher as a good info flip. I missed it if somebody else did-- but that was me.

What's up with nancy being the NK? Didn't predict her...

i thought it was rampage and dranyth so i'm either wrong or there's more.

either way we will have to look closely at ircher's and nancy's iso.

[northsidegal]

why would it?

hm?

it's just people claiming scum like that, even just as twilight trolling if they know they're getting lynched. especially in a newbie game, i feel like that sets a bad example - i think if you're town you should be trying to help town and trying to show that until the thread is locked and you're officially dead.

[Scioness Sajj]

i agree about rampage in lylo

but eh

p.edit - it was before twilight, i feel like he said that because i was whiny about hammering lol

[Draynth]

teacher hmmmmm

What did you think about this at the time?
(As in, you were asked about lynching teacher. Did you consider it at all?)

[vulcan logician]

why would it?

hm?

it's just people claiming scum like that, even just as twilight trolling if they know they're getting lynched. especially in a newbie game, i feel like that sets a bad example - i think if you're town you should be trying to help town and trying to show that until the thread is locked and you're officially dead.

Meh, that's Mafia... Ircher definitely sent out shady vibes which is why I think there is a silver lining to his mislynch.

Unless town gets lucky... there's usually a D1 mislynch. We should learn what we can from it and move on.

I don't want D2 to be a simple formality of lynching Rampage though. Even if we do end up lynching him, we need to look at other people and have an alternative wagon going.

[Scioness Sajj]

Draynth:
i mean i have said that i would hammer anybody so i did consider everybody?

ircher mentioned wagoning teacher and i was considering being on a wagon i guess, why are you asking?

[Scioness Sajj]

nancy was pretty good lynch all round, sadly

[Scioness Sajj]

Draynth:
i mean i have said that i would hammer anybody so i did consider everybody?

ircher mentioned wagoning teacher and i was considering being on a wagon i guess, why are you asking?

wait, i wasn't asked about lynching teacher though lol

[Draynth]

Also, @Nancy, I would definitely support a teacher lynch, but again, I don't think there is enough support from the rest of the game, and we really do need a lynch before deadline.

teacher hmmmmm

I interpreted this as being asked about a teacher lynch?